JOSEPH COOK and Professor Smith of Andover, are dealing hard blows to each other on the subject of probation after death. Mr. Cook denies, and we think the truth is with him, but he has so many errors in his methods of argument that it enables the Professor to show his argument to its disadvantage. If Joseph Cook could by some means be cured of his egotism, and of his dependence on German philosophy, he would be strong in his advocacy of the truth.