Now it is declared, and with seemingly some show of reason, that Elsie Siegel was not killed by the Chinese at all, but that rather she eloped with her supposed murderer, and that the girl found in the trunk was another individual. This seems to be demonstrated by a very full comparison made between the body found in the trunk and Miss Siegel herself, not only as regards the physical features of the person, but the clothing that was worn, and other circumstances.
The Elsie Siegel Murder Mystery
From Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 35., September 8, 1909