The largest center of the Roman church in America is the archdiocese of New York, with an estimated Catholic population of 1,200,000. Its numbers surpass those of all the most crowded centers of Italy, including Rome, Naples or Milan, and only the principal archdioceses in Europe, such as Cologne, with 2,528,000 people, and Vienna, with 1,900,000, go beyond it.
Catholic Population of New York
From Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 12., March 25, 1903