[The New York Examiner and Chronicle, said by its editor to be the “largest Baptist newspaper in the world,” contains, in its issue of June 14, 1877, the following statement relative to the indebtedness on church property. J. G. Wood.]
The following table from the Tribune, with comments of its own, needs no comment of ours, except that the mortgage on the Fifth Avenue church has been reduced to about $35,000, and we suppose that on the Fifty-Third street property to be less than $60,000. But the statement as a whole is a thing to be pondered:—
Recent foreclosure proceedings in the case of Dr. Hepworth’s church of the Disciples, and similar procedures in other suits, have lately directed attention to the fact that many of the finest and costliest of the fashionable churches in this city are heavily mortgaged. No other class of improved real estate in the city appears to be so heavily encumbered as that of its religious associations. Of course, no sort of property has more uncertain tenure of its income, the whole depending in large measure on the popularity of the ministers engaged, and on the good will and prosperity of the church members.
Nearly the whole of the debt created by these mortgages has been for the purpose of enlarging edifices, or for the construction of new ones. There can be found scarcely an example where a church has incurred debt for the purpose of increasing the salaries or the numbers of its laborers, or to enlarge its contributions to general charity or missionary funds. All has apparently been for show. Indeed, many of the churches owe their existence to the mortgages with which they are encumbered.
The following list shows the financial condition of many of the New York churches which are mortgaged, and of some religious societies. All mortgages registered prior to 1869 are omitted, and others less than $9,000 in amount disregarded, except in the grand totals. The other figures are exact, as taken from the County Register’s books:—
| American Bible Union building, | $20,000 |
| American Tract Society “ | 123,000 |
| Annunciation, P. E., West 14th street, | 16,000 |
| Ascension, P. E., 5th ave., | 35,000 |
| Ascension Chapel, P. E., | 21,000 |
| Atonement, P. E., Madison ave., | 25,000 |
| Brick Presbyterian Church, 5th ave., | 25,000 |
| Christ, P. E., Church, 5th ave., | 29,000 |
| Covenant, Presbyterian, Park ave., | 29,000 |
| Disciples, Cong., Madison ave., | 189,000 |
| Fifth Avenue Baptist, | 42,000 |
| Fifty-Third Street Baptist, | 67,000 |
| First Baptist, East 39th street, | 45,000 |
| First Baptist of Harlem, | 22,000 |
| First German Baptist, East 14th street, | 18,000 |
| First United Pres., East 116th street, | 12,500 |
| Fourth Avenue Pres., Fourth ave., | 25,000 |
| Fourth Ger. Ref. Dutch, | 10,000 |
| Fourth Ref. Pres., West 48th street, | 20,000 |
| Grace Church, P. E., Harlem, | 10,000 |
| Heavenly Rest, P. E., 5th ave., | 137,000 |
| Holy Apostles, P. E., 9th ave., | 12,000 |
| Holy Saviour, P. E., East 25th street, | 60,000 |
| Holy Sepulcher, P. E., East 74th street, | 50,000 |
| Holy Trinity, P. E., Harlem, | 65,000 |
| Holy Trinity, Ev’n Lutheran, W. 21st st., | 23,886 |
| Incarnation, P. E., Madison ave., | 14,000 |
| Intercession, P. E., West 158th street, | 45,000 |
| Jane Street M. E., | 14,000 |
| Madison Ave. Ref., Madison ave., | 100,000 |
| Madison Square Pres., Madison ave., | 45,000 |
| M. E. Church, East Circuit, New York, | 45,000 |
| M. E. Church, Harlem, | 40,000 |
| Memorial, Pres., Madison ave., | 130,000 |
| New York Pres. Church, West 11th st., | 15,600 |
| North-west Protestant Ref. Dutch, | 20,000 |
| Phillips, Presbyterian, Madison ave., | 250,000 |
| Puritans, Presbyterian, West 136th st., | 155,000 |
| Plymouth, Baptist, | 18,000 |
| Ref. Prot. Dutch Church, | 471,000 |
| Ref. Prot. Dutch Church, West 34th st., | 25,000 |
| Ref. Low Dutch Church, Harlem, | 28,000 |
| Sacred Heart, R. C., West 51st street, | 15,000 |
| Second Cong. Unitarian Church, | 64,000 |
| St. Andrew’s, P. E., Harlem, | 60,000 |
| St. Bernard, R. C., West 14th street, | 70,000 |
| St. Esprit, R. C., French Church of | 10,000 |
| St. John, Evang. Lutheran, | 16,000 |
| St. John the Baptist, R. C., W. 30th st., | 75,000 |
| St. Luke, Ger. Evang., West 42nd st., | 30,000 |
| St. Nicholas, R. C., Second ave., | 19,000 |
| St. Stephens, P. E., West 45th street, | 34,000 |
| St. Teresa, R. C., Rutgers and Henry sts., | 27,000 |
| St. Vincent de Paul, Asylum of R. C., | 5,000 |
| St. Vincent de Paul, R. C., West 23rd st., | 65,000 |
RECAPITULATION.
| Presbyterian, | $706,000 |
| Reformed, | 644,000 |
| Prot. Episcopal, | 453,000 |
| Roman Catholic, | 229,000 |
| Baptist, | 212,000 |
| Methodist, | 79,000 |
| Lutheran, | 44,886 |
| Total, | $2,367,886 |