On the Census

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 29, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 6.

Read the full edition

On the Census.

BY BROOKE HERFORD, PASTOR OF THE CHURCH OF THE MESSIAH, CHICAGO, ILL.
TEXT: “Thou hast multiplied the nation, and not increased the joy.” Isa. 9: 3.
There is a great interest just now about the census. The newspapers are busy discussing the ways in which it has been taken, and the various results which it shows. Every city is very anxious to have it made out that its numerical progress has been a little larger than that of its neighbors. Chicago is jubilant that it can make a showing of half a million, with so little stretching that it will, probably, forthwith begin to claim 600,000! Then St. Louis, Cincinnati, Milwaukee, are all equally excited about their returns, mostly aggrieved that they do not foot up as was expected, and not a village but has something to say, some little note of complaint or congratulation in the great chorus of national jubilation which will probably rise to its loftiest strains this 4th of July!
But what I am struck with is, that amidst all this discussion about numbers, I seem to meet with so very little appreciation of what numbers really mean—of what is involved in all this massing together of larger and ever larger populations! It is treated as if the question were a perfectly simple one, or, indeed, as if there were no question at all involved, except that of mere statistics. By so much as a city has increased in population, by so much is it to be congratulated. I hardly meet with a single misgiving that numbers may not be all, hardly with a sign of the sense that the increase of city-populations especially involves the very gravest problems and difficulties. And therefore it is that I have chosen for my text these old words which seem to come in so aptly with their suggestion that a nation may be multiplied, and yet its joy, its happiness, not increased. I do not say it is so here. Indeed, I do not even know whether it was so in that old Jewish people about whom the prophet was writing. There is a disputed point among critics about a single Hebrew letter, which makes all the difference of negative or affirmative. But the real question for us is not how that text should be read for those old Hebrews, but how it is going to read for us, in America, to-day! Is it to be, “Thou hast multiplied the people, and not increased the joy;” or is it to be, “Thou hast multiplied the people, and increased its joy”? That is not the difference of a mere letter now; and it is worth spending a little time in considering some of the elements of that difference, some of the problems involved in making increase of population to be at the same time increase of welfare and happiness.
And let me say, to begin with, that there is a great difference between the increase of the population of a country as a whole, and the increase of city populations. With regard to a country as a whole, I think increase of population is almost universally a sign of increasing welfare and happiness. Certainly it is so in countries where people are free to come or go as they will. Those thousands upon thousands who every week are landing in New York, from almost every country of Europe, those hundreds who are landing in San Francisco from the crowded population of Asia—which is to be thousands, also, if America can carry out its own profession of a free welcome to all—those teeming currents of immigration certainly mean that here in this country is some new scope for human life, some larger opening for industry, some more hopeful and happy prospect for man. And—it is so! It is not without reason that into the hovels of Connaught, and by the fiords of Norway, and to the remote villages of Bohemia, and among the peasantry of Germany, and even into remoter places yet, word keeps spreading of this great, wide, western land, where every man has a chance, where every one may own his own little farm, where no aristocracy lords it over the poor, where no secret police dogs the steps of liberty, and no conscription tears men from their homes!
These pictures of prosperity are, indeed, often painted too brightly. Many come, and are disappointed. If the struggle of life here is perfectly free, it is also very severe. Life is laid out here on the basis of every one’s shifting for himself, and every one has to do, and the weaker have to go to the wall. It is no wonder that many of those who have grown up in the dull, stagnant life of the peasantry of Europe, cannot go the quicker pace here, and cannot settle into the new ways. Still these are lost in the larger view of the myriads who do find homes, and work, and comfort; who fill up the outskirts of the ever-growing cities; whose homesteads dot the ever-widening area of cultivation; whose corn fields cover the wide prairies with a golden glory; and whose villages spring up at every creek and crossing on the great lines of travel! I do believe that all this kind of increase of population does stand for solid increase of human welfare; that every new township staked out, every new village planted, every new county organized, every wild region admitted as a territory, every territory settled up into a State, means increase of wholesome, independent life,—not very public-spirited life at first; and that is not surprising. It takes a generation for the cramped and undeveloped life of semi-serfdom to learn what a free government means and needs. But never mind! That sturdy, self-reliant manhood of to-day is excellent raw material for the nation of the future!
But it is a very different question when we come to consider the massing of great populations into cities. I suppose it is inevitable. There always have been great cities. And, now-a-days, there is a special tendency that way. The tendency is for all things to gather to great centers. Business concentrates into a few mighty enterprises. The large firms freeze out the smaller ones. The great railroad lines absorb all the local ones. More and more, industrial and commercial life divides into two classes,—a few great capitalists and the rest their agents and employees.
It is probably true that there is a certain gain of mechanical and productive efficiency this way, but I do not think it is a gain in human life and power. I remember, years ago when I removed to Sheffield, the center of the steel and cutlery trades, after having lived all my youth in the cotton-manufacturing districts of Lancashire, I was very much struck by the much sturdier independence of the Sheffield population, and the much wholesomer mingling of all ranks and classes together, than in the Lancashire life to which I had been accustomed. And seeking for the cause of it, I found it largely in this: While, in the cotton districts, it required large capital to be an employer, and so the business was centralized in a comparatively few powerful hands, the rest being their clerks and work-people; on the contrary, in the cutlery districts any one could start in business for himself who could raise a hammer, an anvil, and a few dollars’ worth of steel. I learned a lesson then on the value of separate, individual enterprise;—and it is that, you know (individual enterprise widely spread throughout the people), which has made America;—and though I do not see how the present centralizing and massing tendency is to be prevented, yet I dread it. I do not think it is good for the manhood of a nation. It tends to mass not only wealth but power in a few hands, and to introduce an aristocracy of great corporation-managers which may easily become just as unscrupulous and oppressive as any of the feudal aristocracies of older days!
And in like manner, I do not think this massing of population into great cities—which is another outcome of the same tendency—is productive of real human welfare and happiness. It is not from any sentimental feeling about country life and scenes being specially elevating. I have none of the feeling which breathes in Cowper’s saying that “God made the country,” and “man made the town,” or as it was put earlier and still more epigrammatically by Cowley,— “God the first garden made, and the first city, Cain!”
I believe in social life for man, and that man’s life attains its best when aggregated in societies. But it is one thing to have life so drawn together as to constitute “society,” and another thing to have it so massed together as it is in our great cities to-day! Why, this dense city-life is often as injurious to true social life as it is to true individual life. There is no loneliness, no solitude like that of a great city! No! the city makes very intense life, very feverish life; it sharpens life amazingly on certain sides of it; but I do not think it makes either particularly wholesome or happy life.
If I wanted to point to about the most wholesome and happy life, all around, I should be apt, I think, to take the New England village-life, as I have heard it described, or the life of the smaller towns and cities out in this West, where the population is not so dense but that the people can for the most part know each other, where the competition is not quite so intense, and life is at once a little less ambitious and a little less pretentious than it is in the great crowded city. Why, the mere fact that in these smaller towns land is not too dear for every house to stand in its own lot,—that, of itself, is a wholesome element of manly and social culture! Human nature always grows stunted, cramped in some way or other, when too crowded. In families brought up each on a separate lot, however small, life is more varied, the division of labor is not carried to such lengths as in the city, the girls and boys grow up accustomed to do a little of many a thing, in garden and farm, that city girls and boys hardly know anything about.
And so, too, people know each other better. In the city, the man who comes to mend your fence or to collect your gas or water-rate is an impersonal human item—just a link in business—no one with whom you have any human feeling. But it is not so in smaller towns and villages. There, the carpenter or the collector is not a mere impersonal human item in the great machine—it is such and such a man, whose little house you know as you pass by it, and whose children are very likely in your class in the Sunday-school. When you go to the store,—it is not mere buying and selling,—there’s a word about this one’s wife who is sick, or that one’s lad who is away at college or at business. I do not say that there is more kindness or sociality in the small town or village than there is in the city, but it is more wholesomely mixed up with the work and business, and so it tends to soften competition a little, and to make the battle of the world not quite so keen, not quite so driving, with a little more leisure in it for quiet, happy living.
But the most serious drawback to the happiness of the great multitudes in these ever-increasing cities is the difficulty of wholesome government. The more crowded together people are the more life needs organizing to prevent their treading on one another. But how few people think of all the organization and government needed for a community of half a million people, to keep life at all wholesome, and orderly, and safe! to have the poor cared for, and the criminals held in check, and the careless kept from endangering the health and lives of the rest—apart from the mere material matters of roads, and lighting, and water, and sanitary regulations! Why, it is infinite,—the intricacy of all that wants doing to make this massing of people together in a city, as happy, and convenient, and wholesome as it might be. But where is it done, as it might be done? We have an honest city government now; but is it an efficient one? Go and look at the outrageous fouling of this river of ours, and say! Go and see how the most elementary laws of health are violated in every back alley in the best parts of the city, and in the poorer quarters in every front street as well! Go and see how timid and half-hearted our police-managers are in suppressing the haunts of vice, and in keeping saloons within even the very moderate bounds prescribed by law!
Why, take education! I believe that the educational matters are about the purest and best part of American city-life! And yet how terribly, in such a city as this, the best that you can do—or, at least, the best that you dare do—how terribly it fails to master the real educational problem! That problem is manageable in a small town or village; social opinion brings its pressure to bear. If a man neglects his children, there are sure to be some around to try to get them into the school. But, here! Why, if you will go about the poorer parts of Chicago, you can find as many ragged, untaught little gutter children as in Manchester or Sheffield. I tell you these problems of ignorance, and neglect, and poverty, and sin, become simply awful in a large city, and the larger the city the more awful these problems, unless there is a larger public spirit to match them, and a nobler idea of city government. So, whenever a man says to me,—as many a one does,—“In ten or twenty years, Chicago will probably have a million inhabitants,” I have only one answer: “If you think it likely, you ought to pray God it may not be.” Do you ask why? Because, with half a million you have already about five times as many as you have any wholesome organizing and governing power for; and what you could do with a million—and the same proportion of them selfish shirkers who will not lift a hand, and still, all through, the same happy-go-lucky, do-as-you-like style of managing things—what Chicago would be with a million, it is something awful to think of!
Friends, I am afraid that this may seem rather a discouraging spray of cold water upon the enthusiasm which is usually regarded as appropriate for the 4th of July. Were I a St. Louis man, you would say it was sheer envy. But you know I have as ardent an appreciation of Chicago as any American among you, as keen a sense of what it has done and of what it might be; but I know that that “might be” is not “going to be” of itself; and I know that this increase of population, which you like to boast about, is not even a help toward it, but, rather, that every hundred thousand added makes the state of things a little worse and the problem a little harder than before. Numbers? What are numbers, after all? Suppose you increase faster than ever this next decade, crowding into tenement houses and piling up in flats—will that make a happier city? People get accustomed to it? Yes; they can get accustomed to anything! When the Manchester corporation abolished cellar-dwellings, there was quite an uproar for a week or two among those who had lived in them all their lives! A London city missionary illustrated the crowded state of some parts of London by telling how in one room he had found a separate family living in each corner and another in the middle; but, he said, they got along very well till the family in the middle took a boarder—that made trouble! Ah, friends, I know what the under side of dense city-life is! I know what this crowding together means, not to those who live in the open suburbs, but to those who live in the patches, and back streets, and alleys of the poor; and therefore it is that I feel that this increase which the census shows is a cause for trembling quite as much as for congratulation.
Nor is this only for the city’s own real welfare. It is through this increase of your city-population that are going to come the real trials of that national experiment of which this day commemorates the beginning. In these cities it is that you also are going to feel the pinch of those problems which you have fondly dreamed were left behind in the effete old world of Europe: the problem of a chronic and hereditary pauperism; the problem of systematic and degrading mendicancy; the problem of a criminal class that will increase in spite of all that you can do; the problem of labor and trades unions, and the antagonism of rich and poor, of labor and capital! For all your earlier generations you knew nothing of these things; the vastness of your country and its sparse and open life preserved you from them,—but now this city-life, with its old difficulty of massing all poor, shiftless, turbulent, evil elements together, is bringing them upon you year by year. And so, while the need of America in the past was labor,—let there be labor, for life could not go of itself,—the need of America in the future is wise, public-spirited, thoughtful citizenship and statesmanship.
And so my deepest desire is to arouse you from this poor complacency with what Chicago is, to this nobler ambition to make it what a true city might be!
I dream of a city in which the patient sagacity now lavished in pursuit of individual gain, shall also be freely given to help on the common welfare, and all men shall take their fair and honest part in citizen and public duty!
I dream of how its citizens, as they become wealthy, might rejoice to spend their wealth in enriching it with the encouragements of art, and learning, and of all that might make it a center of enlightenment, and fair and happy life!
I dream of the churches being rescued from the slough of pride and fashion in which at present they are axle-deep, and coming to be, in the midst of all the busy, crowding life, a leaven of the spirit of that lowly, merciful Christ to whose name they still cling, uplifting life with happy faith, softening it with kindly brotherhood, bridging over a little the chasm between class and class, and becoming the rallying centers of clear integrity, and all sweet charity and noble public spirit.
That is my “Fourth of July” dream. Who is going to help to make it a reality?