AdventAI

ABOUT THE SEVENTH-DAY SABBATH.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 6., July 29, 1880

A very well-written article appears under this heading in The World's Crisis, Boston, Mass., of July 14, 1880, from the pen of C. E. Barnes, the concealed sophistry of which seems more calculated to do mischief than that of any article we remember to have seen in that paper on this subject. He writes in reference to an article in the REVIEW, Vol. 55, No. 21, wherein the position is taken that “the moral law of God, that written upon two tables of stone by the finger of God, is primary in its nature,—primary in the sense that it is first in rank, and that it can never be done away so long as God and intelligent moral beings exist, and have relations to each other.”

He avers that in this position there is “a fallacy and an assumption which is frequently met in S. D. arguments.” The assertion, he claims, is that all the ten commandments are moral laws; then he takes the position that the Sabbath commandment is not moral, but is positive; that while the other duties would exist if there were no commandment enforcing them, the duty of Sabbath-keeping would not exist without such commandment. Even if we admit the distinction which he tries to sustain between moral and positive law, it cannot affect the question of the obligation of the Sabbath when we look at the origin of that institution. By primary laws, we mean those laws which would have existed if man never had fallen. These, as all must acknowledge, are of first rank, and from the very nature of the case are perpetual and immutable. By secondary laws, we mean such as grow out of the change in man's relation to God after the fall, and in consequence of the fall. These, of course, include all the typical and ceremonial observances, or duties which man has to perform as a sinner, in order to become reinstated in God's favor; laws which are peculiar to, and characterize, the different dispensations in the plan of salvation. These may change or cease altogether, according to the circumstances under which men are placed.

But now we inquire when the Sabbath law was given, and to what it owes its origin. There is but one answer. It was given before man fell. It would have been binding on Adam and his posterity if he and they had never fallen. It does not owe its existence to man's needs after becoming a sinner. It is not a law of that kind. It is not affected by any change of dispensation.

Now men may call such a law moral or positive, or give it whatever name they please, there is its origin, that is its nature, and there is its position among the primary laws which would have been binding upon man just the same if sin had never entered our world, and which of course cannot be in any way affected by the entrance of sin.

We do not, however, admit the assumption of Mr. B. that the Sabbath law is not a moral law. What is a moral law? That which grows out of the nature of our relation to God and to our fellow-men. We are to have no other gods but him because he is our creator. We are to devote some time to his worship for the same reason. The moral duties which exist between man and man grow out of the relation in which God has placed us to each other as fellow-creatures of the same creator.

Now the duty enjoined by the fourth commandment is just as moral as that enjoined in the first and second; that is, the principle is the same in each. Man has in his nature the principle of worship; but it is in his nature just as much to devote some special time to the being he worships, as it is to perform the worship itself. Hence according to Gilfillan, we find in all pagan nations, except those sunk to the lowest degree in the social scale, traces of sacred days of some sort. And the fact that God specifies or tells us what particular time to devote exclusively to his worship, no more destroys the morality of the commandment, than the fact that he has been obliged to reveal himself as the Creator in order that we may know whom to worship, destroys the morality of the first commandment.p. 90

Mr. B. states that there is a fallacy in many of the S. D. A. arguments, which is, “a failure to distinguish between the abolition of a duty, and the abolition of a code of laws.” He then goes on to argue that all the duties of the ten commandments except the observance of the Sabbath were duties just the same before the commandments were given, and hence that the commandments may be abrogated and these duties still remain.

This is itself a fallacy of the most glaring nature. It is based on false reasoning altogether. Our friend tries to draw a conclusion with only one premise. He does not go back far enough to really reach the beginning of his argument. If these laws were laws enacted by men simply, if they were only human regulations, his position would be correct. But we are to remember that these laws are not the laws of men, but the laws of God. They are laws by which he has given expression to moral duties which originated in his own nature. The laws, like the duties themselves, come from God, and hence if he changes or abrogates the law, and no other power can abrogate or change it, then he changes or abrogates the duties.

When, therefore, men claim that that law has been abolished, which is the transcribing of the Divine mind, and the defining of moral duties which spring from his own attributes, we have a right to ask, “Are men at liberty, then, to worship idols, to covet, and steal, and kill?” They are at liberty to do so if God, on whose authority all moral duties rest, has changed his will, and the expression of it, which is his law. The fallacy of Mr. B.'s argument lies in his treating the law of God, the law of ten commandments, as if it were a law of men, and not a law of God.

Mr. B. further says, “The seventh-day theory rests upon a frame-work of unwarranted assumptions. It assumes there was a duty to observe the Sabbath ages before the law relating to it was announced. We reply, The seventh-day theory assumes nothing of the kind. Has Mr. B. ever read our arguments? Has he ever read Genesis 2:3? Will he tell us what the word sanctified means in that passage? He knows, as every one else knows, that the word means to set apart to a sacred or religious use, and that can be done only by giving a law concerning its observance. Therefore as soon as the great facts upon which the Sabbatic institution is founded were accomplished, a law was given to our first parents for its observance, and through them to all their posterity in all places and all time.”

He says further, “It [the seventh-day theory] assumes an unscriptural and fictitious division of the Mosaic law into moral and ceremonial, and then assumes as a part of the moral law a command which plainly is essentially distinct in nature from the moral law.”

Here he very adroitly tries to confound the Sabbath commandment with the ceremonial law, whereas he has only claimed it to be a positive law, which is a very different matter. But in regard to the division between moral and ceremonial, so far from being unscriptural and fictitious, it is what every one acknowledges, and what he himself acknowledges. This distinction exists as a fact, and no man can destroy the fact. Some laws are moral and some are ceremonial, and it is impossible to destroy this distinction. The fallacy of his position is in placing the Sabbath among the ceremonial laws, with which it has not the slightest connection. It antedates them in time, and is absolutely and essentially different from them in nature.

Again he says, “It [the seventh-day theory] assumes that to abolish a code of law which embodies prior existing duties would result in the abolition of those duties whose existence is altogether independent of that code.”

We have already shown the fallacy of this assumption. These duties are not altogether independent of the code; for both the duties and the code come from God, and God gives one as the expression of the other. If he abolishes that instrument by which he gives expression to the duties, he abolishes the duties themselves.

Mr. B. says again, “It assumes that the observance of the first day of the week as a day of worship and rest instead of the seventh, is ‘the mark of the beast,’ when the beast did not exist until centuries after the apostolic church, with whom the observance of the ‘Lord's day’ (as the first day of the week was called) began, and assumes that those who turn to Jesus Christ for the knowledge of duty in accordance with the prediction of Moses of the prophet to be raised up in after time, and in obedience to the command of God, ‘Hear ye him,’ shall fail of salvation unless they also obey the law of a superseded dispensation, and yield obedience to a covenant, good in its day, but which now gendereth to bondage.”

We easily bury these unwarrantable assertions under the crushing weight of a few facts. The first day of the week was not called the Lord's day for nearly two hundred years after this dispensation began. Its observance as a Sabbath was not practiced by the apostolic church. They never gave any direction of the kind concerning it. But their example, as in Acts 20:7, and their precept, as in 1 Cor. 16:2, devoted the day to secular uses. It did not come into the church as an authoritative institution until manipulated by Pope Sylvester after the so-called conversion of Constantine. The testimony of all history, and the reiterated claims of the Roman Catholic Church itself, have so sharply crystallized the great fact that Sunday observance is purely an institution of the church, that any man exposes himself to the charge of ignorance or dishonesty, who attempts to deny it.

God said of Christ indeed, “Hear ye him.” Will Mr. B. hear him and keep that law which Christ, in his first recorded sermon, so fully vindicated, and taught that it should not pass until heaven and earth passed?

Nothing of the former dispensation is superseded except those shadowy and typical ceremonies which characterized that dispensation. All the types ceased when the substance, Christ and his priestly work, was introduced; but of these types and shadows the Sabbath was not one.