THE THEOLOGICAL TREND

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 29, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 6.

Read the full edition

THE THEOLOGICAL TREND.

A few months ago, the Evansville (Ind.) Journal reported a sermon by the Rev. Mr. Chainey, a Universalist minister, on “Iconoclasm,” the discourse being the first of a series of lectures on “The Church of the Future.” The idols he attacked, and which he thought the church of the future would overthrow, were, “the church’s idea of Jesus,” “the idea of the church concerning the Bible,” “the idea of the church concerning man as a depraved and worthless being,” etc. This reverend gentleman says that the Bible will be more of a curse than a blessing, so long as it is regarded as anything but a human production; that if we say anything respecting the inspiration of its writers, “we should make it plainly understood that it was only in the same human way that Shakespeare or Burns were inspired,” and plenty more of the same sort.
But we will call attention to no more of the ultra utterances of an unorthodox and somewhat obscure man, even though they sketch with a bold hand the church of the future. The theological trend of the present day is shown by utterances couched in language less shocking to the sensibilities, and these utterances are the expressed opinions of men who are the leaders of thought in the theological world. The Independent of May 6, 1880, contains an article on the “New Orthodoxy,” an orthodoxy of which Prof. Swing is the apostle, and his organ, the Alliance, is the exponent. One of the tenets of this new faith, as given in the Independent, is this: “The truths which are not spiritually discerned and which are debatable, those truths which have to be proved by the Bible, cannot properly be required to be believed as articles of faith.”
The same paper says: “The peculiarity of The Alliance’s ‘New Orthodoxy’ seems to be that it depends on intuitions of the mind. It makes religion a matter of innate certainties and transcendental convictions. In the philosophy which sees God because it sees him, which knows sin forgiven, because it knows it, which is assured of the inspiration of the Holy Spirit because it is assured of it, we find no intelligible sense, and can have for it no intellectual toleration.” It comments on the above as follows: “We agree with Dr. Walker that it is by the route of The Alliance’s new orthodoxy that the road runs to the wildest fanaticism.”
Yes; such a faith leads to wildest fanaticism, and can give full credence to the Sunday Sabbath, or any other unscriptural doctrine in the golden cup in the hands of the woman “arrayed in purple and scarlet color.”
One more example. From the Christian Weekly of July 24, we take the following:—
“If language means anything, the Rev. Henry Ward Beecher has gone clean over to the position of the rationalists. We certainly do not see how any other interpretation can be put upon the utterances of his sermon of July Fourth, as reported. Here are some sentences from the sermon, and we are sure we are doing him no injustice in quoting them in this isolated manner, because they are distinct and clear enunciations:—
“The human race has been, and is, an unfolding race. The world is developing. It is a gigantic lie, told with much circumstantiality, that men were created upright and then fell; that in Adam and Eve the human race fell all around. It began in a fallow state, and the world is as God meant it to be. There was no trick. God did not make a bad job, and then paint it pretty and plaster it up. . . . The origin of evil is a cob that has been gnawed upon for thousands of years, but no one ever got a kernel from it. It is still a cob. . . . In a sense God made laws to be broken—that is he knew that nascent and imperfect beings would break them. The idea is to be disclaimed and trampled under foot that men must do thus and thus, or be destroyed. God’s way is to lift, aid men, to sympathize with them. . . . We don’t throw away the Bible when we say that the system of the Old Testament is not the system for to-day. . . . I don’t hold the theory of the Atonement. . . . I hold that the Divine Nature broods over the human family everywhere, and tenderly stirs men to rise from a lower to a higher stage of action. . . . I reject the Mosaic economy and take a larger view of Christ’s work. . . . The truths of the Bible are not to be swallowed whole, but to be sifted. He who interprets it literally will go over. If the records of God’s work in the infantile period of the world are applied to us, all will go over.”
“Two or three things stand out in these utterances, and they are in complete contrariety to the gospel which Mr. Beecher was ordained to preach.”
“In the first place the Bible is not in the true sense the word of God. ‘The system of the Old Testament is not the system for to-day,’ says Mr. Beecher. ‘The truths of the Bible are not to be swallowed whole, but to be sifted,’ he adds. We are at liberty, that is, to take what parts we like and throw the rest away. That is precisely what the rationalist claims. The Christian believer takes the whole Bible as being the revelation of what man is to believe concerning God and what duties God requires of man. If he cannot understand as yet all the whys and the wherefores, he nevertheless obeys, and waits in calm trust till in ‘open vision’ the ways of God shall be made plain. By his own confession, Mr. Beecher is a rationalist, not a Christian believer.”
“Again, Mr. Beecher denies the fall of man. ‘It is a gigantic lie that men were created upright and then fell.’ If man did not fall, he is not lost. If he is simply in an imperfect, undeveloped state, he needs a teacher to be sure, an exemplar perhaps, but he has no need of a Saviour. Man is not to be saved, but to be ‘tenderly stirred to rise from a lower to a higher stage of action.’ This is just what the rationalistic-humanitarian claims. But assuredly, Mr. Beecher, what the Bible teaches and experience confirms, is that this race of ours needs not ‘tender stirring,’ but the strong uplift of those arms once outstretched in agony upon the accursed tree, or it never will be saved.”},{
“Of course when the fall of man is denied, the atonement becomes unnecessary. This modern apostle of the gospel of good nature, glories in a ‘Divine Nature brooding over the human family everywhere,’ but he does not, with that elder apostle, ‘glory in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ.’ Mr. Beecher again takes his stand with the ultra-humanitarians, for if he persists in calling himself a Christian, his is a Christianity without Christ.”
“We are not heresy-hunters. The platform upon which the Illustrated Christian Weekly stands, in the nature of the case forbids this. Such utterances as these to which we have called attention go farther than heresy. They come perilously near, even if we may not say that they quite touch, apostasy. We do not see how any ingenuity can explain them to mean anything else than we have interpreted them. We deny the right of any professed Christian teacher to make utterances that fly directly in the face of the Christian Scriptures. When the truth of the Bible, the fallen condition of man, the atonement through Christ, are denied, there is no room for explanation; what is needed is recantation. Would that the great preacher of Plymouth church would see this in the light in which we do.”
“It is significant that ‘A Bible-Class Teacher,’ to whom, for the present month, has been relegated the exposition of the Sunday-school lessons in the Christian Union, takes the same view of the teachings of the opening of Genesis that Mr. Beecher does. ‘The common idea,’ he says, ‘that man was created morally, mentally, or physically perfect at the beginning is one which is not to be found in the book of Genesis. . . . Genesis does not teach that man began at a high point of civilization or morality.’ More is added in this and the following lesson to the same effect.”
“We have no space for further comment. We simply say that it becomes all Christian believers to enunciate with increasing clearness and with no uncertain sound their belief in an infallible because divinely inspired word; a human nature lost because fallen; a Saviour able and willing to save unto the uttermost all who will come unto God through him.”
The Christian Weekly adds later, in the same article:—
“Since the above was in type Mr. Beecher has devoted a sermon to a careful exposition of his views on the great fundamentals of Christian faith. He modifies somewhat the expressions of the sermon we have criticised. But it is still evident that, at least on the three great points we have mentioned above, he does not hold the views commonly accepted by evangelical Christians. His teaching is radically unsound. We believe it to be dangerous, and therefore speak.”
All of which shows that the leaven is working, which will finally result in the apostate church described in Rev. 18.