RESPONSE TO A PASTOR

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 15, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 4.

Read the full edition

RESPONSE TO A PASTOR

From Les Signes des Temps.

RESPONSE TO A PASTOR.

BY ELD. J. N. ANDREWS.
WE have received a courteous letter from a pastor in the canton of Neuchatel, in which he seeks to convince us that the first day, and not the seventh, ought to be observed as the Sabbath. We thank him for this effort, and will give due weight to his argument, as we compare it with the Bible.
He regrets that at a time when there is so general an effort to establish the observance of the first day of the week, we should call in question the divine authority of this day, and should seek to cause men to return to the ancient Sabbath. To this we answer that if we sought our own pleasure or our own advantage, we should go with the multitude; for it is much easier to justify the general practice than it is to correct it. But we have no choice in the matter. The seventh day rests upon God’s commandment. The first day has no authority but the tradition of the elders. Nor is this the only thing to be considered. The tradition in favor of the first day has set aside the commandment which bids us hallow the seventh. God rested on the seventh day at the close of his creative work, and he blessed the day and sanctified it in memory of that rest. (Gen. 2 : 2, 3.) In the moral law, which is of perpetual obligation, he commands us to remember the day of his rest, and to keep it holy. (Ex. 20 : 8–11.) The New Testament, which mentions the rest-day of the Lord fifty-nine times, mentions the first day eight times, and the annual sabbaths of the ceremonial law once. But it says nothing concerning the change of the Sabbath. It does not call the first day the Christian Sabbath. It does not say that it should be observed in memory of the resurrection of Christ, but it ordains baptism for that purpose. (Rom. 6 : 3–5.) These are truths of the Bible, and we dare not suppress them.
Our correspondent thinks that we are acting under a temptation of Satan, because we call attention to these facts respecting the authority of the first day of the week, as compared with that of the seventh. If we have falsified the Bible in a single point, then he has reason to make complaint; but, in fact, we have stated the exact truth of the Bible, and no man ever offended God or pleased Satan by doing this. Almost all the world now observes the first day, and profanes the seventh. It is pleasant to say to men that in thus doing they are obeying God; but how can the observance of the first day be an act of obedience to God, when he has never commanded it? and how can the transgression of the fourth commandment be a light matter, when God has not abolished his moral law? (Matt. 5 : 17–19; Rom. 3 : 31; Jas. 2 : 8–12.) Were all the world agreed to make a divine institution of the first day of the week, it would still lack the one thing essential to such an institution, which is divine authority. In like manner, when all the world unite to trample beneath their feet the day God sanctified at the creation, and commanded in the moral law, it still remains his holy rest-day, and is still honorable in his sight as the memorial of the creation. We live in the period when even the people of God have the Sabbath beneath their feet. (Isa. 58 : 13.) God bids his servants awaken his people to the sinfulness of their conduct. He says, “Show my people their transgression;” and these words are our warrant for the work we do. (Isa. 58 : 1–14.)
But our correspondent asks, “Do not the Holy Scriptures instruct us as to our duty as much by example as by precept? Now the New Testament does not lack examples as to the rest upon the first day. (Matt. 28 : 1; Mark 16 : 2–9; Luke 24 : 1; John 20 : 1; 19 : 26; Acts 27; 1 Cor. 16 : 2; Rev. 1 : 10.)”
This means that God teaches us his will in two ways: 1. By his law; 2. By the example of his inspired servants. In his moral law, God has made a perfect revelation of his will. He has also instructed us with respect to our duty, by the example of the patriarchs, the prophets, and the apostles. So far we are in perfect accord with our correspondent. But does God teach one course of action in his law, and a different course by the example of inspired men? If so, which shall we follow? Our friend seems to teach that these two rules may conflict; that is to say, the law of God commands certain duties, but the example of inspired men authorizes us to substitute other things in place of those that God has commanded. From this doctrine we wholly dissent. We say that the law of God is right in every precept, and that the conduct of good men is right when it agrees with that law, and not otherwise.
But the question relates particularly to the action of the apostles with respect to the fourth commandment. That commandment requires us to rest on the seventh day, in memory of the fact that God rested on that day from the work of creation. It says nothing of the first day, only as it includes it with the six days which it appropriates to labor. But our correspondent teaches that the apostles, by their example, reversed this commandment, and, making the first day a day of rest, in honor of the resurrection of Christ, ceased to rest on the seventh. Such a conclusion is too important to be adopted without careful examination.
The law which commands us to hallow the seventh day is very definite. The example of the apostles, which authorizes us to hallow the first day in place of the seventh, ought to be equally definite. Several things must appear in their example: 1. That they rested the first day, in honor of Christ’s resurrection; 2. That they did this not once or twice merely, but on every first-day; 3. That they used the seventh day for ordinary labor. It is necessary that we should find all these conditions in their example, if we are to make their example the occasion of setting aside the fourth commandment; for if they did not set the example of resting from ordinary labor on that day, they did not elevate the day above the rank which it occupies in the fourth commandment as one of the six working days. Compare Ex. 20 : 8–11 with Eze. 46 : 1. Also if they did not rest on each successive first-day, there would be no ground to believe that they regarded the day as really more sacred than any other.
But it is also necessary that they should, by their example, abase the seventh day, and use it as an ordinary day of labor; for even if we find that they treated every first-day as a sacred day, it would not show that the seventh day had lost its sacred character. It would simply show that we have two sacred days; one made such by the example of the Creator, and by his law; the other, by the example of the apostles. But if the first day has become sacred, and the seventh day has ceased to possess that character, we must find by the example of the apostles that they treated the first day as sacred, and the seventh day as a day of ordinary labor.
It cannot, in justice, be said that we ask too much with respect to apostolic example; for it is on the authority of this example that we are to reverse the fourth commandment. It is admitted by those who keep the first day, that Christ never said anything concerning the change from the seventh day to the first; and they make the same admission as to the apostles. The proof of the change is found in the practice of the apostles, and not in their teaching. Our correspondent gives us the passages which show what they did to consecrate the first day, and to abase the seventh. The first is Matt. 28 : 1. This text simply states that the Sabbath was past and the first day had commenced when the women came to the sepulcher. The second passage is Mark 16 : 1–9, which gives the same facts. The third passage is Luke 24 : 1, which says that the women came to anoint Christ on the first day of the week. The fourth text is John 20 : 1, 19, 26. The first of these verses says that one of the Marys came to the sepulcher early on the first day. The next one of them tells us that in the evening of that day Christ appeared to his disciples, who were assembled together. But we learn from Acts 1 : 13, that at this time they all dwelt together; and from Mark 16 : 14, that they were eating their evening meal when Christ came in, and upbraided them for their unbelief concerning his resurrection. This shows that they were not celebrating the first day of the week in honor of the resurrection of Christ. The last of these verses says that eight days after this, Thomas being present with the other disciples, Jesus again met them. This could not have been earlier than the evening of the next first-day, and might have been, as the Greek seems to imply, even later than this. If this was to teach us by example that a new Sabbath was thenceforth to be observed, then we should celebrate the hours corresponding to this evening interview. In such case our Sabbath will not commence till the evening at the close of the first day of the week. But Christ did not choose the times of meeting his disciples with reference to establishing a new Sabbath; for the third time he met them they were fishing (John 21); and the last and most impressive visit, was on Thursday, when he ascended into Heaven. (Acts 1.)
But our correspondent affirms that the Sabbath was changed to the first day to commemorate the resurrection of Christ. As no such thing is said in the Bible, he infers it from apostolic example. But we have already examined every instance in which the first day is mentioned in connection with the resurrection, and find no hint of the new day of rest, nor any intimation that the ancient Sabbath had lost its sacredness. The period of nearly thirty years elapses before the first day is again mentioned. This is unaccountable if the apostles had actually ceased to keep the seventh day and commenced to keep the first day from the resurrection of Christ. Look at the case. If the apostles knew that this great change had taken place in man’s duty toward God, they must publicly teach the people this fact; for every week those who knew it not, were ignorantly transgressing. And they must not only teach this change, but their example must show it. Now let us take the record of the first thirty years as given in the book of Acts, and look for their teaching and their example.
The day of Pentecost was the public opening of the gospel dispensation. Peter set before the people their duty in view of the fact that Christ had died and risen. They were to repent and be baptized. (Acts 2.) What did he say with respect to the keeping of the first day of the week? Nothing. But this was a duty toward God which henceforward they would disregard every week till it was made known to them. Read all the chapters of this book during the history of about thirty years, and find where the apostles ever taught the people this new-day, or where their enemies ever charged them with breaking the ancient Sabbath or with establishing a new one. It is impossible that such a change could have been made without the notice of their enemies. But no such notice ever appears. But during this time there are many references to the ancient Sabbath. (Acts 13 : 14, 42, 44; 15 : 21; 16 : 13; 17 : 2; 18 : 4.)
But at the end of nearly thirty years, the first day is once mentioned. It is our friend’s next text,—Acts 20 : 7. Paul had a farewell meeting at Troas, on the first day of the week; but it was in the night-time, for they had many lights; and Paul preached till midnight. The disciples came together to break bread; but this could not have been to commemorate the resurrection of Christ, for it commemorates his crucifixion. (1 Cor. 11 : 26.) It was because Paul was to leave them never to return, that they thus employed the hours of his last night with them. (Acts 20 : 38.)
One very interesting fact is to be noticed in the case of Luke, the writer of the book of Acts. When he mentions any act that was customary, he states it as such. Thus he speaks of Christ that it was his custom to go to the synagogue on the Sabbath. (Luke 4 : 16.) He speaks of the meeting by the river-side at Philippi, on the Sabbath, where prayer was wont to be made. (Acts 16 : 13.) He says that it was Paul’s manner to preach in the synagogue on the Sabbath. (Acts 17 : 2.) He also says that Paul reasoned in the synagogue every Sabbath. (Acts 18 : 4.) It is instructive to us to know what was the manner of Christ, of Paul, and of others concerning the Sabbath, though that was an ancient institution resting upon the express commandment of God. But if the first day of the week, which has no commandment of God in its behalf, and which is a new institution, is to be introduced to us as a divine institution on the authority of apostolic example, it is of the highest importance that we should know that such example exists. If the disciples were accustomed to meet on the first day, and if they, by that custom, changed the Sabbath, it was a thousand times more important that Luke should say that this was their custom, than that he should so often tell what was the custom respecting the Sabbath. But he says not one word of any custom in the case, a positive proof, under the circumstances, that no such custom existed. And we have seen, from the silence of the book of Acts for the thirty years preceding this meeting, that first-day sacredness was unknown to the apostolic church.
The next text of our correspondent is 1 Cor. 16 : 2. But this says nothing of first-day sacredness, nor even of any meeting on that day. Paul commanded the disciples every first-day to lay aside something at their own houses, for the poor, each according to his ability. Seventh-day Adventists seek to obey this precept literally, but I know of no denomination of first-day Christians that does this.
The last text is Rev. 1 : 10. This passage is made to refer to the first day by a false translation in the ordinary French Bibles. But the Lausanne Bible correctly translates it the Lord’s day. There is no place in the Scriptures where the first day of the week is claimed by the Lord as his day. But in the beginning, when God gave man the six days, he reserved the seventh to himself. (Gen. 2 : 2, 3; Ex. 20 : 8–11.) And by the prophet Isaiah he calls it his holy day. (Isa. 58 : 13.) Christ calls himself even the Lord of the Sabbath. (Mark 2 : 28.) He counts this as a distinguished honor in claiming that day as his, that had been set apart in memory of the Creator. It is indeed said that the first day of the week, according to ecclesiastical history, was familiarly known as Lord’s day in John’s time. But this is false. There is no instance of applying this title to the first day till the latter part of the second century.
(Concluded next week.)