THE SOUL—NO. 3.
REPLY TO DR. KELLOGG'S REJOINDER
BY. REV. N. WARDNER, D. D.
The Doctor seems anxious for me to stop reviewing him, and shoulder the burden of proof in regard to the nature of soul and spirit. I do not wonder that he wishes to get rid of proving his theory. But the burden of proof is with him, while I have nothing to do, as his reviewer, but to show wherein he fails to substantiate his positions. I quote his own language against him: "We hold that in a candid, logical investigation of this subject, as with all other investigations, no position can be granted for which there has not been presented logical and indisputable evidence." This the Doctor has failed to do in favor of his new, and hitherto almost unheard-of, definition of soul. He virtually admits that lexicographers and commentators are against him. Human consciousness and the Scriptures are also clearly against him. They recognize a clear distinction between spirit and body, spiritual beings and physical beings. The Doctor, on the contrary, seems dissatisfied with their teaching, and so appeals to science. He says, "We believe that from science alone can a concise idea of the nature of the soul be obtained;" and complains that the Bible leaves many things in the dark, and evidently includes this with the rest. But Christ says, "God is a Spirit," and "a spirit hath not flesh and bones," hence no brains; yet God is an intelligent entity. Now, when the Doctor proves that God is not an intelligent entity, he will prove that other spiritual beings are not intelligent entities, and not before. The Scriptures clearly teach that they are. find them proving altogether too much for his purpose, and "what proves too much, proves nothing."
The Doctor says, "Christ asserts in substance that God has a form, and that he has the same form. Christ also says that he was the image of the Father's person." And to explain, he quotes Heb. 11:1, and says the Greek word here used for person is translated substance—"Now faith is the substance of things hoped for." Is faith matter, "flesh and bones?" On the contrary, it pertains to thought, which the Doctor says "is not material." Christ never represented the Father to be matter, but "Spirit;" and if he is in the image of the Father, it is the image of what the Father is. What kind of an image did Paul name when he said, "We all beholding, as in a glass, the glory of the Lord, are changed into the same image, from glory to glory, as by the Spirit of the Lord." He says, "The new man," "the inward man," as distinguished from the body (the outer man), "is renewed in knowledge after the image of Him who created him." Col. 3:10. Renewed in knowledge after the image of him who "is a Spirit," hence a spiritual image. "Put ye on the new man, which, after God is created in righteousness and true holiness." Eph. 4:24. In Hebrews 12:9, God is said to be "the Father of our spirits," in contradistinction to the fathers of our flesh. A father transmits his own nature to his offspring. Does this passage mean that God is simply the Father of our "breaths"? "God is a Spirit," and Christ says, "That which is born of Spirit is spirit, and that which is born of flesh is flesh."
The Doctor goes on to say, "From these texts it is very clear that the above argument is based upon a weak foundation, or at least before an argument can be legitimately based upon the immateriality of God, it must be shown that such is his nature,—a position which, as just seen, is contrary to the plain teaching of the Scriptures." Reply: I have only tried to show that "God is a Spirit." What the composition of a spirit is, I do not pretend to know; but the Doctor does, and claims that God is matter; and therefore I may say, with double propriety, that before an argument can be legitimately built upon the materiality of God, it must be shown that such is his nature,—a position which, as just seen, is contrary to the plain teaching of Christ, who says, "God is a Spirit." It matters not what is the essence of a spirit. It is enough that it is an intelligent, responsible entity, capable of moral character, and may thus exist without "flesh or bones."
The Doctor says, "As our reviewer maintains that create does not refer to the material or physical nature of man, which was formed, to be consistent he must drop his belief in the trinity, and adopt the views of those dualistic philosophers, who maintain that God is male and female. He must also hold that the human spirit, instead of the body, possesses the property of sex." Reply: The Doctor's theory would compel him to "adopt the views of those dualistic philosophers," since he claims that man and woman are in the physical image of God. But in reference to myself, he had better wait till I adopt trinitarianism or dualism, before he classes me. I prefer to choose my own company. In regard to sex, universal observation teaches that men and women are as different in spiritual and mental characteristics as in their physical, and God has given them bodies in harmony therewith. The two natures perfectly blended, as in Christ, are necessary to a perfect spiritual character. He had all the tenderness, sympathy, and love of perfect womanhood, blended with the justice, dignity, and inflexibility of perfect manhood. The union of two such spirits, in love, are necessary to perfect manhood and womanhood.
After fruitless efforts to convict me of error on the word "create," the Doctor admits my interpretation to be correct. He says, "We agree with Eld. W., that create probably does not refer to the matter of which Adam and all other living beings were formed... The thing created was the organization of man and of animals. The creation of man was simply the organization of matter. The matter had existed before; the organization had not previously existed. Evidently the word 'create' must refer to the thing which had not before existed, and hence it must refer to the organization." Reply: The Bible says nothing about an immaterial organization; hence the novelty of the Doctor's soul, invented to meet a necessity. He says, "The creation of man was simply the organization of matter." This limits all there is of man to his material organization, and when disorganized his identity is forever gone.
To avoid the necessity of admitting that pneuma signifies a spiritual being, he renders it mind. Does this prove that God, a pneuma, is not a spiritual being? On the contrary, it shows that in Scripture mind is so inseparably associated with spirit that one suggests the other. The Bible teaches that the mind of God is known only to his Spirit. The same also of man, proving that intelligence pertains to the spirit, and not to the flesh. 1 Cor. 2:11.
Again the Doctor says, "We believe life and thought in all their phases, and with all their modifications, to be the result of organization, which is the product, not of matter, but of almighty power." But whence this "almighty power"? The Doctor claims that there can be no force without matter, or thought without brains. If so, God could have had no thought or power till he had brains. If he could, the Doctor's theory fails to the ground. But Christ said, "God is a Spirit," and that "a spirit hath not flesh and bones," and therefore no brains. Here the Doctor is against Christ, and one or the other must give way. Which shall it be?
Again, the Doctor says, "We define the word 'spirit' to mean breath, or that which is dependent upon it, life and mind, with its various attributes, which result from life." Then it follows that "almighty power" is almighty breath! He claims that Christ, when dying, simply commended his breath to the Father! Breath expired is carbonic acid gas. Was this all that Christ commended to the Father? The following passages show that the word "spirit" generally means something more and very different from carbonic acid gas. "When the unclean spirit has gone out of a man, he walketh through dry places, seeking rest, and findeth none. Then he saith, I will return into my house from whence I came out; and when he is come, he findeth it empty, swept, and garnished. Then goeth he, and taketh with himself seven other spirits more wicked than himself, and they enter in and dwell there; and the last state of that man is worse than the first." Matt. 12:43-45. Here is an intelligent entity, that Christ calls a man, and has moral character, hence was accountable, rewardable, and punishable. Can that be said of a breath of air, or of mere life? "And all the devils besought him, saying, Send us into the swine, that we may enter into them. And forthwith Jesus gave them leave. And the unclean spirits went out, and entered into the swine; and the herd ran violently down a steep place into the sea (they were about two thousand), and were choked in the sea." Mark 5:12, 13. "And in the synagogue there was a man, which had a spirit of an unclean devil, and cried out with a loud voice, saying, Let us alone; what have we to do with thee, thou Jesus of Nazareth? Art thou come to destroy us? I know thee who thou art, the Holy One of God. And Jesus rebuked him, saying, Hold thy peace, and come out of him. And when the devil had thrown him in the midst, he came out of him, and hurt him not." These were all called "pneumas," which Christ said "have not flesh and bones." It also be noticed how repeatedly and plainly it is stated that they entered into, and came out of those possessed. The Doctor claims that they "did not actually enter into them." I shall notice this further on.
The Doctor says, "Since the thing given to man by the Creator was the pneuma, or life-giving breath, it is the same pneuma that is given up at death. The thing that goes back to God is the same thing that came from him, which, as elsewhere shown, is life-imparting breath, that which sets in motion the vital machinery, the very same thing that was given to all living animals." "Pneuma is never represented as having life." These statements are abundantly disproved by the passages quoted above. If a pneuma has no life, then God has none, for he is a pneuma; yet he is the source and fountain of all life. Hence the Doctor's statement is not true. He says, "Pneuma is breath, and is the means of imparting life, but does not itself possess life or intelligence; and hence it has no life to lose, and it would be eminently improper to speak of it as dying." If this be so, then God is a mere puff of air, or at least had no life or intelligence till imparted by a puff of air! Let us see how the Doctor's definition agrees with the following texts: "And the Lord came down in a cloud, and spake unto him, and took of the spirit that was upon him, and gave it unto the seventy elders; and it came to pass, that, when the spirit rested upon them, they prophesied, and did not cease." Num. 11:25. Was this simply a breath of air? If so, why does it not thus affect all men? "There is a spirit in man; and the inspiration of the Almighty giveth them understanding." Job 32:8. "The spirit of man is the candle of the Lord, searching all the inward parts of the belly." Prov. 20:27. "But when the Comforter is come, whom I will send unto you from the Father, even the Spirit of truth, which proceedeth from the Father, he shall testify of me." John 15:26. "And they were all filled with the Holy Ghost, and began to speak with other tongues, as the Spirit gave them utterance." Acts 2:4. "Then the Spirit said unto Philip, Go near, and join thyself to this chariot." Acts 8:29. "The Spirit beareth witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God." "For we know not what we should pray for as we ought; but the Spirit itself maketh intercession for us with groanings which cannot be uttered. And he that searcheth the hearts knoweth what is the mind of the Spirit, because he maketh intercession for the saints according to the will of God." Rom. 8:10, 16, 26, 27. "Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times, some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits." 1 Tim. 4:1. "Searching what, or what manner of time the Spirit of Christ which was in them did signify, when it testified beforehand the sufferings of Christ, and the glory that should follow." 1 Pet. 1:11. Multitudes of such passages might be quoted, but these are more than sufficient to prove that the spirit, pneuma, is the seat of knowledge and moral character, and not mere air.
In regard to 2 Cor. 5:1-8, the Doctor says, "We readily grant that this text contains some somewhat obscure expressions, and at first sight seems to contradict the views which we have endeavoured to maintain." The obscurity he complains of results from his having a theory that conflicts with Paul's teaching. Go back to where Paul starts this idea, and see how clearly he unfolds it. 2 Cor. 4:16: "Though our outward man perish, yet the inward man is renewed day by day." Here are two men, one outward and one inward. While the outward man is perishing, dying, turning to corruption, the inward man is taking in new life and vigor, as he says in another place, "We all beholding, as in a glass, the glory of the Lord, are changed into the same image from glory to glory, as by the Spirit of the Lord." "Put ye on the new man, which is renewed in knowledge after the image of Him that created him." This transformation into the divine image, this daily renewing, does not refer to the body; for that, meanwhile, is perishing and turning to corruption. It, therefore, must refer to a conscious, accountablep. 196 entity in man, superior to the body, which was created in the image of God, which image, being marred, is thus restored through Christ. The apostle goes on (chap. 5), "For we know that if our earthly house of this tabernacle (outer man) were dissolved, we have a building, a house not made with hands, eternal in the heavens. For in this we (the inner man) groan, earnestly desiring to be clothed upon with our house which is from Heaven; if so be that being clothed we shall not be found naked. For we that are in this tabernacle do groan, being burdened; not for that we would be unclothed, but clothed upon, that mortality might be swallowed up of life. Now he that hath wrought us for this selfsame thing is God, who also hath given unto us the earnest (part, or pre-payment) of the Spirit. Therefore, we are always confident, knowing that whilst we (the inner man) are at home in the body, we are absent from the Lord. . . . We are confident, I say, and willing rather to be absent from the body, and to be present with the Lord."
Now, who is it that is at home in the body? who that desires to be absent from the body and present with the Lord? Is it the body itself? Is it the breath? Is it the "inner man" who "is renewed day by day, and being transformed into the image of God from glory to glory, while the body, the outer man, is perishing? What language could express more clearly that this inner man is a conscious, accountable entity, the subject of regeneration and sanctification, rewards and punishments; also that it will, at death, depart out of the body or tabernacle, and be with the Lord, into whose glorious image it had been changing, day by day, while in the body, and while the body was turning to corruption? Christ represents this inner man to be the subject of the new birth. John 3:3. He says, "Except a man be born from above, he cannot see the kingdom of God." In reply to Nicodemus' materialistic query, he said, "That which is born of flesh is flesh," the outer man, "that which is born of Spirit is spirit," the inner man. It is the Spirit of God that "witnesses with our spirits" (not our brains nor breath) "that we are the sons of God," "which are born, not of blood, nor of the will of the flesh, nor of the will of men, but of God," who "is a spirit." "That which is born of Spirit is spirit." Peter says, "Seeing ye have purified your souls in obeying the truth, through the Spirit, unto unfeigned love of the brethren, see that ye love one another with a pure heart fervently; being born again, not of corruptible seed (flesh), but of incorruptible (spiritual), by the word of God, which liveth and abideth forever." 1 Pet. 1:22, 23. Was it their imagined organizations or breaths that were purified in obeying the truth through the Spirit, and love of the brethren?
The Doctor thinks Paul did not expect to be with Christ till the resurrection, because he expressed a desire "to be clothed upon with" his "house from Heaven." Reply: That is no evidence, for Paul was then looking beyond the intermediate state, as Christians generally do, when contemplating the final triumph and reward, when he should receive his crown that was laid up for him to be given him "at that day."
The Doctor calls my attention to 2 Pet. 1:15, where the apostle, speaking about putting off his tabernacle, calls it his "decease." I thank him for citing me to that verse, for I find the Greek word for "decease" to be exodon, which means to go out of, march out of. (Liddell & Scott.) This was Peter's idea of dying, that the inner man would go out of the outer man, or body. Thus, from whatever standpoint we look at the apostle's language, the idea is the same, that there is an intelligent, responsible entity dwelling in man's body, which at death departs, goes out of it, puts it off, and then the saint will rest from his labors. Resting signifies existence. Nothing can rest that does not exist. The saint's rest is to be a blessed or happy rest, and nothing can be happy that does not have a conscious existence.