AdventAI

THE TEN LOST TRIBES.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 13., September 16, 1880

To our notice of the Anglo-Israel Ensign given in a late REVIEW, that paper of September 1, 1880, makes reply. As the reader will remember, that paper is devoted to the advocacy of the doctrine that the British nation are descendants of the ten lost tribes of Israel. We take the position that those of the ten tribes who were carried into captivity were cast out of God’s presence, rejected and destroyed, and put beyond the pale of God’s purposes and promises, nationally considered. To this the Ensign objects on account of the words of Paul that God has “not cast away his people,” and that “all Israel shall be saved.” That in no way conflicts with our statement; because we showed that some of the ten tribes joined themselves to Judah and were still reckoned as Israel. What Paul says, therefore, so far as he has any reference to the literal seed, applies to these, and not to the ten tribes who were carried into captivity.

Again the Ensign quotes certain statements concerning Israel in the days of Ahab and Elijah, and argues, therefore, that Israel was still recognized then as the people of God. It is sufficient to reply that all this was before the ten tribes were carried away captive. And we still think our statement holds good that none of that people were afterward recognized as Israel except such as joined themselves to Judah, and returned with them after their captivity. The others are not to be taken any account of whatever in the divine economy, if we understand the Scriptures.

The Ensign says, “Our friend seems to dispose of the whole question with a few random utterances, and a majestic wave of the hand.” We are glad he recognizes the majesty of the argument which we introduced, and we trust that the present “majestic wave” will suffice to scatter all his objections.