THE following item clipped from a secular paper is suggestive:—
Wisconsin has tried imprisonment for life instead of hanging for over a quarter of a century, and the total number of life-prisoners received at the State Prison at Waupun, since its organization in 1853, is ninety-four, of whom fifty-four were convicted of murder, twenty-nine murder in the first degree, and eleven in the second degree. Of this number there have been discharged by Executive pardon, thirty-one; order of the Courts, eight; removed to the Insane Asylum, three; and six have died. Of those pardoned out, the longest term served was seventeen years, and the shortest service was two years and nine months. The directors of the prison, in their last annual report, allude to the fact that popular attention has been called to the expediency of restoring death as a punishment for murder in Wisconsin. They do not argue against the proposed change, but give their impressions of the horror of a life-imprisonment. They say the condition of most of the life-members is deplorable. Some of them are already insane; but, “however wild their delusions may be on other subjects, they never fail to appreciate the fact that they are prisoners for life. Others, not yet classed as insane, as year by year goes by, give only too conclusive evidence that reason is becoming unsettled. The terribleness of a life sentence must be seen to be appreciated,—seen too, not for a day or week, but for a term of years. Past experience leads us to expect that some of them will become insane in less than ten years, and all of them who live, in less than twenty.” The directors even go so far as to suggest to the Legislature whether life sentences should not be abolished and long but definite terms substituted therefor, thus leaving some faint glimmer of hope for even the greatest criminal.
This is certainly a serious objection to imprisonment for life,—the thought of it dethrones reason. One object of punishment is the reformation of the offender, but life-imprisonment makes its victims insane, and thereby defeats the design of punishment. But if life-sentence on earth makes men insane, what will sentencing them to eternal imprisonment in hell do for them? The directors of the Wisconsin prison, in view of the fact that life-imprisonment has such a deplorable effect, suggest its abolishment, thus leaving “some faint glimmer of hope for even the greatest criminal.” But in hell there is not even the “faintest glimmer of hope” for any one. There is only one sentence for all. The “greatest criminal” and the least criminal are alike cursed with the same eternal sentence, without the faintest glimmer of hope. Such a terrible doom, unless an eternal miracle prevents, must drive every one of its victims to insanity, and hell be a vast mad-house perpetuated by the might of the Almighty. Is it not amazing that sane men and women entertain such a diabolical view of the result of making man in the image of God?