A MEDIUM BETWEEN EXTREMES; OR A CONSERVATIVE UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 9, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 12.

Read the full edition

A MEDIUM BETWEEN EXTREMES; OR A CONSERVATIVE UNION OF CHURCH AND STATE.

BY WM. PENNIMAN.
The Commencement Annual, published at Oberlin, June 9, 1880, contains the baccalaureate sermon by Pres. Fairchild, on “Religion and the State.” We give some extracts, as follows:—
“The population of our country is a mixed multitude, gathered from all lands. It matters not who first occupied the territory and organized the government, or whether the multitude from all nations had any right to come, or were merely admitted. Here we are, a heterogeneous people, living together, with interests to be protected by a common government. We must all share in that government, or it cannot have the confidence of all; and in the end the government which does not secure the confidence of all, will fail to meet the wants of any. If our government does not measurably satisfy its Roman Catholic and Hebrew and Chinese subjects, it will in the end fail to protect its Protestant subjects. The widespread suffrage, which often seems to be our greatest danger, is probably our only safety. The problem before us is, to harmonize and unify a people of such diverse history, and traditions, and religions. We may fail, but we cannot succeed by putting the civil power into the hands of Protestant Christians to govern the rest against their will. Nor is it any dishonor to God or rejection of his authority, that we institute such a government as will enable us to live in peace with our Roman Catholic and Hebrew and pagan neighbors. In his providence, this problem is upon us, and nothing could be more favorable to the establishment of his kingdom of righteousness, than that out of these diverse elements should spring a homogeneous and consolidated nation. Such an achievement would vindicate the divinity of Christianity, and open the way to its universal prevalence.”
“But the choice is not submitted to us. The form of government as well as the population of the country is determined for us, and we must get on with it as we can. No radical change is possible, even if it were desirable. But the question still returns, What attitude can the government wisely hold in reference to religion? Over against the idea that we should maintain a distinctively Christian government, lies the other extreme, of a government entirely secularized, disclaiming all responsibility in reference to religion, and leaving the people, without help or hindrance, to establish and maintain their own religious institutions. Toward this opinion there is, unquestionably, a decided tendency in our country. This is not the present attitude of our government, but it is claimed to be the natural and logical outcome of the principle of freedom of conscience and universal toleration. It is claimed by those who maintain this view that the legitimate work of government is purely secular, as distinctly so as that of a business corporation; that while it keeps within these proper limits it will not in any way affect the religion of the people; and that the true wisdom of government is to leave all arrangements in the interest of religion to the voluntary, unconstrained action of the people themselves, confining itself to its own proper sphere of the maintenance of personal rights, providing for the public security, and meeting other common necessities which belong to all alike, whether Christian, or Jew, or pagan. It is claimed by those who maintain this view that it is the logical and practical solution of the problem of religion and government in this country,—the only theory upon which their relations can be adjusted. Let us consider what results will follow from the consistent and thorough application of this theory, before we yield it our assent.”
“In the first place, a Sabbath is an institution in the interest of religion—religious in its origin and its purpose. The government cannot provide for it, or afford it any protection. All Sabbath laws must be abrogated, not because the suspension of business one day in seven is detrimental to any public or private interest, but because the government must leave all religious affairs to the unconstrained action of the people. Those who wish a Sabbath can take it for themselves, and no one shall hinder; but a group of reckless boys, who fear not God nor regard man, must be permitted to intrude upon the quiet with their boisterous sports, and the worldly and irreligious may crowd the streets with all the pursuits of business and pleasure.”
The president proposes a solution of this difficult problem which is a kind of conservative platform designed to conciliate all parties, as follows:—
“Let the government accept religion as a great fact of human experience, an essential condition of the permanency of public institutions, and of all prosperity. In all its own arrangements which bring men together, let it provide the conveniences of worship and religious instruction, meeting, as far as possible, the religious preferences of those for whom this provision is made, not undertaking to discriminate between the true and the false, or to secure the acceptance of one form of worship as against another. Let the people, in their voluntary associations, be encouraged to provide religious worship and instruction for themselves and for the stranger that is within their gates; let no restraint be placed upon them by the imposition of taxes upon the buildings which they erect at their own cost, for these great public uses. It would be no interference with the proper rights of conscience if the government itself should erect such buildings at the public expense, as it covers the land with school-houses, and thus provide for the various forms of worship which the people require. But the least that can be asked is to leave untaxed these spontaneous efforts of the people to meet a great public want. So much encouragement, at least, let the government afford to the churches, and to places of worship of every name.”
“For the uses of religion, a day of rest from business and labor,—a day of public quiet,—is required. Let the government secure such a day of rest, protected from disturbance by such laws as may be found needful; and let the people occupy it for worship or not, as they choose. The Jew and the Sabbatarian will not find their views met in the day which shall be selected; but they are the few, and in the interests of religion they will suffer the disadvantage. Limited misadjustments of this kind are inseparable from human society. The want of the many must be regarded, at the risk of inconvenience to the few.”
The president’s motives seem to be good, and we like the unifying and pacific spirit which seems to breathe through the whole sermon; but, after all, it can be plainly seen that it is not so much a Sabbath that the agitators of this church and state question want, as “the Sunday;” and from the very fact that they do not wish their Sunday quietude disturbed by “reckless boys,” beer saloons, and “Sunday trains,” they will urge on the question till they accomplish their object. When the object of this party is once accomplished, there will not be much conservatism. Even Pres. Fairchild admits this when he says, “The Jew and the Sabbatarian will not find their views met in the day which shall be selected.” Therefore, as they are “the few, they will suffer the disadvantage.” Christ says that only a few will find the strait and narrow way which leadeth unto life. The few have “suffered the disadvantage” in all ages when they have stood up for the truth; and they are suffering it now, and will still more in the future when the Sunday law is made, when no man can buy or sell, save he that has the mark of the beast or the number of his name. Rev. 13:17. But though the few may suffer the disadvantage here, they will not hereafter; for Christ says (Rev. 22:12), “And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.” When this reward is given, there will be no “risk of inconvenience” to “the [comparatively] few” who will receive it.