As long as there are live boys, this will be a living question. Though untold wisdom has been lavished on it, it is a problem still, and there will always remain something to be said, which, if it have not the charm of original discovery, may yet have point. For the average boy is “a harp of a thousand strings,” many of them out of tune. He has but one prominent fault,—you set yourself to correct it, and succeed in setting the whole boy askew.
I want to make a few suggestions, the result of some years of experience. First “catch” your boy. Mrs. Somebody’s receipt for cooking the hare applies here. You can do nothing with a boy till you gain possession of him. It is not enough that he is in your class. He may be there a year, and yet you feel that you have no “hold” upon him. If you have ever fished for salmon, you know that to get that lively fish on your hook is one thing, and to land him is another. Too great a strain, and away goes your line; too little, and away goes your fish. It sometimes takes hours ere you have the fine fellow actually panting at your feet. It is so with catching boys. But when once you have drawn by the cords of love and bound to you by a boy’s loyalty that wayward, forceful, clever, mischievous, and thoroughly interesting specimen, you have not spent your strength for naught. You have already gained a great point in managing him. But here rises another difficulty, for if you like a boy you are tempted to humor him; and the next thing therefore is,
Second: See that he doesn’t manage you. Boys that have will, and are under no legal compulsion to yield themselves to the influence of another, are pretty sure to measure strength with a teacher, sometimes in combination, sometimes singly, and the issue has got to be determined which is master. The contest is apt to be like the Greco-Roman wrestling,—a quiet, steady tug, in which very much depends on how you take hold and how much endurance you have. If the boy masters you, by all means have him removed to another class. If you master him, you have gained half the battle in the matter of managing him, especially if in the process you have retained not only his respect, but his love and confidence.
Third: Having gained command, hold the reins as lightly as possible. This will require self-command. Often it will be necessary to let his turbulent temper break its wave on your rock-like patience, or his indolence and frivolity must be met not by sharp rebuke so much as by glowing earnestness, or his conceited smartness by your sober wisdom. Your own balanced weight of character, the poise of conscious power and right, will do more in managing a boy than any mere display of authority or aggression upon his will. Loss of patience or display of temper on your part is almost fatal to your influence. The sun controls the movements of the stars by his own massiveness. And there must be volume and value and equilibrium in the teacher’s character if he would control boys.
Fourth: Get hold of the boy’s heart. Yonder locomotive with its thundering train comes like a whirlwind down the track, and a regiment of armed men might seek to arrest it in vain. It would crush them, and plunge unheeding on. But there is a little lever in its mechanism that, at the pressure of a man’s hand, will slacken its speed, and in a moment or two bring it panting and still, like a whipped spaniel, at your feet. By the same little lever the vast steamship is guided hither and yon, upon the sea, in spite of adverse wind or current. That sensitive and responsive spot by which a boy’s life is controlled is his heart. With your grasp gentle and firm on that helm, you may pilot him whither you will. Never doubt that he has a heart. Bad and willful boys very often have the tenderest heart hidden away somewhere beneath incrustations of sin or behind barricades of pride. And it is your business to get at that heart, get hold of that heart, keep hold of it by sympathy, confiding in him, manifestly working only for his good, by little indirect kindnesses to his mother or sister, or even his pet dog. See him at his home, or invite him to yours. Provide him some little pleasure, set him to some little service of trust for you; love him, love him practically. Any way and every way rule him through his heart.
Fifth: The process will be aided and supplemented by your teaching him to manage himself. This will be your ultimate aim; and here his conscience and intelligence, and the passions of hope and fear, will come into play. All that is needed with some boys is that your own intelligence and conviction of right should impress itself on their thoughts and awaken their moral sense. Many a bright boy will yield to reason if you will take the trouble to make him see a thing, when he will kick at your mere opinion, and he will acknowledge God’s will and the naked right when he might dispute your authority. You don’t want to break a boy’s will, but to teach him to will right. Next to his heart, his own self-respect is the best helm by which you can manage a boy.
Lastly, give your boy something to occupy and inspire him, as an aim, a goal, and patiently keep his eye on it. Especially make conversion and a noble Christian life your definite purpose with him till at last he sees it.
I do not enter on the actual work of class management with boys, which is a theme by itself, but suggest: Be so full and bright with your lesson as to interest them, and they will behave well. And if discipline is necessary, remember that, as in nature, the silent forces are best. The steadfast eye, the touch of the hand, the “still small voice,”—what power there is in these!—J. Spencer Kennard, in S. S. Times.