AdventAI

A SMALL WAY OUT.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 10., August 26, 1880

In Review No. 2, present volume, we made the statement that A. N. Seymour would never be chargeable with the guilt of turning J. M. Stephenson and D. P. Hall away from the truth; that the design of these men in their visit east was to gain control of the REVIEW, and transform it into an Age-to-Come organ, but failing in this, they soon broke their connection with this people. In The Restitution of July 28, 1880, * J. M. Stephenson, under the heading of “Charges Confuted,” undertakes to disprove these statements. The reason he urges to show that there was no conspiracy or design to gain control of the REVIEW on their part is the fact that he and D. P. Hall were invited to attend the Conference in New York and Michigan by Eld. White. Very well, could they not, because of this invitation, have been cherishing the design to secure control of the REVIEW and make it an advocate of the Age-to-Come doctrine? Will they say that they had no such design, or rather will they offer any proof that they had no such design, and that they never expressed such a purpose to any of their brethren? If they do deny this, and can support such denial with any proof, showing that this was not the case, it will simply follow that we were misinformed in the matter.

But what goes to show that we were correct is the fact that J. M. S., according to his own testimony, did, soon after his return to Wisconsin, commence the publication of a paper called The Bible Investigator, advocating the same theories defended by the REVIEW, with the addition of the doctrine of the Age-to-Come. This is proof positive that there was a determination on his part to foist that doctrine into the views advocated by S. D. Adventists; and could the REVIEW have been by any means brought around to its advocacy, his paper would not, as in that case it need not, have been started.

But oh! there could not have been any such design on their part because, forsooth, Eld. White had invited them to come East! Is not this amazing proof?

As to the matter whether Seymour’s question led him to renounce the Sabbath, J. M. S., in his article says that after publishing the questions of A. N. S., arrangements had been made for “a discussion between J. B. Bazzo and H. V. Reed” on this question, and that in the discussion he soon became “convinced” that Bro. Reed had the truth on the unity of the law. So it was Reed, and not Seymour, after all, who turned him from the Sabbath. Our statements, therefore, do not seem to be very badly “confuted.”

His whole article is taken up with this inexpressibly weak defense of himself, and he has not a word of rebuke for the hypocrisy and falsehood of A. N. S., as exposed in our article in the REVIEW.