AdventAI

DEATH

By N. Wardner

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 15., September 30, 1880

REPLY TO DR. KELLOGG'S FOURTH REJOINDER

BY REV. N. WARDNER, D. D.

The Doctor tries to make capital out of my quoting Dr. Murphy's literal rendering of Gen. 2:17, as a witness to the correctness of our common version. He says, “It is clear that it could not be considered as reliable evidence, since it is very evident that the translator had a theory to maintain, and endeavored to make his translation to fit his theory.” Then Dr. Kellogg himself goes to translating Hebrew, in the interests of his theory, to show how the Bible ought to read! All translators agree upon this text, and have they all belied the original in the interest of a theory? “Judge not, that ye be not judged.”

The Doctor is greatly mistaken when he assumes that I make my argument turn upon the length of the day spoken of here. I simply raised the query whether it meant nine hundred and thirty years. The question has force in it, as we shall see. Adam and Eve gave proof, before being called to an account, that they were dead, as all the unregenerate are represented in Scripture to be,—dead in the sense that made redemption necessary. But whether the eating day was twenty-four hours or twenty thousand years long, had nothing to do with the real question at issue, viz., what was the penalty threatened? The Doctor says the obvious meaning of “thou shalt surely die,” is that “in consequence of eating the forbidden fruit, man would pass into a state subject to death.” Answer: The record does not say that he should be subject (liable) to death, but, “In the day of thy eating thou shalt surely die.” The Doctor makes physical death to be the only penalty for transgression; but the Scriptures teach that man is in a state of death while still living a physical life. I ask again, How long was Adam passing into that state? Did it take him nine hundred and thirty years? If physical death was the penalty for sin, then the resurrection revokes it, with reference to saint and sinner; and once revoked, it cannot be inflicted again for the same offense. Redemption was to restore the life that was lost by sin; and if physical life was all that was thus lost, then the resurrection restores it to all. The Doctor says, “It has not yet been shown that man possesses anything more than a body. Whatever refers to a person's body in its fullest sense, refers to all there is of him.” Answer: If so, then there is nothing of man to be affected but his body, either by sin or redemption. And when his body ceases to exist, his identity as a man is forever gone. Again he says, “Eld. Wardner remarks, in criticising a comment by Eld. Loughborough on Matt. 10:28, ‘Here he decides that killing the body is not killing the soul, therefore the soul is not the body.’ Certainly, this is just what the Bible says.” Answer: The Doctor here virtually admits, in opposition to his statement just quoted, that there is a living entity connected with man's body, whose life does not depend upon that of the body, which, as Christ says, cannot be killed by killing the body. But the soul which the Doctor contends for cannot meet this description, for that has no element of life or intelligence about it.

The result of the fall spoken of in Gen. 3 was declared to be, that the woman should have sorrow, and be subject to her husband, but no death was threatened. For Adam's sake, the ground should be cursed, and should bring forth thorns and thistles, and in sorrow and in the sweat of his face he should eat the fruit of earth till he returned to the ground. That was to end it all. His body, being of the earth, would return to the earth at death, but not so his spirit.

There were two distinct processes in the creation of man, not named in the creation of animals. His body was first formed of dust; the physical machinery was then perfect; the air, an appurtenance of the earth, was then to fill his lungs and set the machinery in motion. All that pertained to the earth and was to return to the earth, was there. But the man was not yet complete. God then breathed into him that which does not return to the earth with the body. A large part of the body goes into the air, it belonging to the earth; but Solomon says, “The spirit shall return to God, who gave it.” Eccl. 12:7. And Christ says, “Fear not man, who can kill the body, but cannot kill the soul.” Matt. 10:28. The body, therefore, may be annihilated, and the soul still live; and life implies action. Now, if Christ's statement does not make this certain, then he makes nothing certain.

All the evils spoken of in Gen. 3 were to extend no farther than till death. Whereas the Doctor says, “The Bible gives no hint of either rewards or punishments until after the resurrection of the dead.” Hence, the Doctor being witness, nothing spoken of in that chapter belonged to the penalty threatened for sin. The gospel plainly teaches that the death which Christ came to deliver us from is the death in sin, which characterizes the unregenerate. If otherwise, then the atonement and regeneration affect only the body; and not even that, till the resurrection. Yet it is declared that God will then raise some to life and glory, and others to shame and everlasting contempt. Would this show him to be no “respecter of persons,” if all are alike dead in trespasses and sins till the resurrection? In regeneration, those thus dead are made alive in Christ, and this restoration takes place while still tabernacling in the flesh.

Again, the Doctor says, “Character is not an attribute of mind, but of the organization,” which he says “is not the individual, but a representation of him.” This makes man irresponsible for his thoughts or designs, good or bad. Motive, then, has nothing to do with character; nor has “the individual,” according to his theory.

The Doctor charges me with saying that spiritual life means simply a state of favor with God. The word “simply” is his addition to my statement. My language, without his addition, implies no such idea. I claim that the Scripture use of the word “life,” in reference to man's relation to God, generally represents the result of fellowship with God, which secures every bliss that love and communion with him can bring. This is restored to man in regeneration and sanctification. The opposite, which results from disharmony with God, is spiritual or moral death. But do the Scriptures teach that harmony with God merely depends upon the operations of “a delicately constructed machine”?

Again, the Doctor untruly charges me with maintaining that “the word life is not used in Scripture in a figurative sense,” and then draws from this false representation an inference too ridiculous and unfounded to deserve notice.

Again he says, “If the penalty did not mean what it says, ‘Thou shalt surely die,’ but meant instead, ‘Thou shalt surely go into a state of disfavor with God,’ what was its significance? A state of disfavor with God is a state of sin. Hence, according to this view, the text means, ‘In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely be a sinner;’ and ‘The soul that sinneth it shall die,’ simply means, ‘The soul that sinneth shall be a sinner.’” Reply: This is a strange caricature of Scripture and putting of the effect for its cause. If there is any one thing plainly taught in Scripture, it is that sin is the cause and reason for this disfavor and death, instead of being disfavor and death.

In the next paragraph he substitutes a word of his own in place of mine, and then bases an argument upon it. I used the word “ascription,” and he substituted “description” in its place. Did he know better than I what I meant to say? I meant that the results ascribed to the fall in Gen. 3:14–19 were different from those ascribed to it in Gen. 2:17. The death spoken of in Gen. 2:17 comes clearly into view all through Scripture in connection with the doctrine of atonement by Christ, and is thus shown to be altogether different, and of infinitely greater consequence than briers and thorns and the sweat of a man's face, or the death of the body. I said the Scriptures clearly teach that what made Adam a conscious, accountable being did not proceed from his body. The Doctor asks, How and where do the Scriptures teach this? And says, “We do not find such teaching in the Bible.” He thus assumes that the body,—flesh and bones,—are the only moral and accountable part of man. What the Scriptures teach in regard to the human race, in this respect, would apply to Adam as the head of the race. The text in connection with which I made the remark reads, “Fear not them which kill the body, but cannot kill the soul.” Matt. 10:28. Here is Christ's testimony that the soul has life, so independent of the body that killing the body does not affect the life of the soul. Life implies active existence. If killing the body does not affect the life of the soul, neither does the same result by disease affect the life of the soul. Such language could not apply to the Doctor's soul; for that has no life, being “a mere abstraction,” or “form,” and “no part of the individual.” This statement of Christ would be of no force or consistency if the spirit were not the seat of consciousness and responsibility; for in that case it would be of far less value than the body. But Christp. 227 represented it to be of such surpassing value that the body and all pertaining to it were not worth thinking of when the safety of the soul is at stake. Paul corroborates this sentiment in 1 Cor. 5:5: “Deliver such an one to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.” Did Paul's anxiety have reference only to the saving of the man's “breath” in the day of the Lord Jesus?—a puff of carbonic acid gas?

REPLY.

Eld. W. “is greatly mistaken when he assumes that” we have endeavored to make capital out of his quotation from Dr. Murphy. Neither can we find any foundation for the remark that we go to translating Hebrew in the interest of our theory “to show how the Bible ought to read!” We made no attempt at translation in the article referred to, and see no possible excuse for the insinuation. We simply quoted the marginal reading, “dying thou shalt die,” making no attempt to even suggest any other reading than that given in the Bible. We should have been better pleased and the reader more edified if Eld. W. had answered our argument, instead of passing it over in silence. We shall not recapitulate, as the reader will have no difficulty in recalling the fact which we pointed out, that the marginal explanation of the text wholly destroys the force of Eld. W.'s argument based upon the words “in the day that thou eatest,” etc. The sin of eating the forbidden fruit deprived Adam and Eve of access to the tree of life, and that very day their vital vigor began to deteriorate. Being no longer able to replenish their vitality by resorting to this marvelous source of life and strength, they became subject to all the causes which operate to produce physical degeneration and disease, and, ultimately, the death threatened in the penalty. The aptness of the expression, “dying thou shalt die,” in the words of our reviewer certainly “could not be accidental with Infinite Wisdom.”

We do not deny that “the Scriptures teach that man is in a state of death while still living a physical life,” at least that this is sometimes the case; but where do the Scriptures say that this sort of death, or spiritual death, is a penalty for sin? This very important item of evidence Eld. W. has omitted to give us, though the fault must not be charged to him, as he has certainly done the best he could, and if there had been any such evidence to offer, either in the Bible or out of it, he would not have failed to produce it. But suppose this point had been established, let us look for a moment at the logical consequence of this view. If spiritual death, “a state of disfavor with God,” is the penalty of sin, then spiritual life, “a state of favor with God,” must be the reward of obedience to God. According to this doctrine, the penalty of sin and the reward of obedience are wholly received in this life; for both spiritual life and death may occur in the present life, and hence there is no need of a future life nor of a resurrection, no necessity for an immortal, immaterial soul. This theory proves too much if it proves anything; but we need not spend more time upon it, as we have already shown that its basis is too flimsy to afford support to anything more than an hypothesis.

Says Eld. W., “If physical death was the penalty for sin, then the resurrection revokes it, with reference to saint and sinner; and once revoked, it cannot be inflicted again for the same offense.” Very true; this is good theology, and we should never think of disagreeing with Eld. W. if his views and ours could harmonize as well upon other points as they seem to on this; but it appears to us that the statement is irrelevant unless it is intended to intimate that our view involves the absurdity of a double penalty for a single offense, which certainly is not the case. The Bible clearly represents that there will be two actual deaths, leaving out of consideration the figurative use of the term “death,” since a person may have several spiritual deaths. Paul said, indeed, “I die daily;” and as we know that he did not die physically, and Eld. W. insists that to die cannot possibly mean to be subject to death, it must be, according to Eld. W., that Paul died spiritually every day of his life. The two deaths referred to are distinguished in the Bible as the first and the second death. As nothing is intimated to the contrary within the lids of the Sacred Book, we are justified in believing that both these deaths are physical. The first death is the penalty of Adam's transgression; the second death is the penalty of the individual's own sins. Since the first death is the result of sins for which no one but Adam is responsible, the resurrection restores all to life alike, the wicked as well as the righteous; but from the second death, which the wicked die for their own sins, there is no resurrection. Now where is there any absurdity in this? It does seem to us very singular that our reviewer will persist in misrepresenting our views on this subject. If he fails to comprehend them, he is, of course, excusable; but we can hardly conceive of anything more simple than the teachings of the Bible on this point.

Our reviewer next attempts to involve us in a contradiction, basing the attempt upon our statement that “whatever refers to a person's body in its fullest sense, refers to all there is of him,” and the remark made upon Matt. 10:28, that “the soul is not the body.” There is no contradiction here whatever, as the reader will see. The soul is a part of the body, using the term “body” in its fullest sense, and yet is quite distinct from it, since it may survive the death of the body in the manner which we have before described. The plan of a house, and the house itself, are two different things, and yet the house includes the plan; nevertheless, the house may be destroyed and the plan preserved. This is all very simple, and equally simple is the explanation of the contradiction in which Eld. W. attempts to involve us.

The word “kill” does not necessarily imply life, since it is often used in the sense of destroy. That this is the real meaning of the word in this instance is shown by the fact that the word “destroy” is used in the very same text, and the Greek word employed is defined “destroy” as well as “kill.”

Says Eld. W., “There were two distinct processes in the creation of man, not named in the creation of animals. His body was first formed of dust. God then breathed into him that which does not return to the earth with the body.” This something breathed into the body, was the “breath of life,” the Hebrew term for which is ruach, corresponding to the Greek pneuma, which Eld. Wardner claims to be “the rational or moral nature of man.” As shown in a previous article, this theory will not stand, since the very same original word is used with reference to the “breath of life” possessed by lower animals. “And they went in unto Noah into the ark, two and two of all flesh wherein is the breath of life.” As before pointed out, if “breath of life” means “rational or moral nature” for man, it means the same for the beast.

Now about the “two processes” involved in the creation of man and only one in that of the beast. The record says with reference to the creation of man that God “breathed into his nostrils the breath of life.” The same record says that beasts have in their nostrils the very same “breath of life.” Query No. 1. How did the breath of life get into the nostrils of the beast? Query No. 2. So long as the “breath of life” is possessed by the beast, so that as Solomon says of man and beast, “They have all one breath” (Heb. ruach), can it make any possible difference how it was placed there? This argument, when examined, proves to be as attenuated as the “immaterial entity” it was devised to maintain.

We see no objection to the conclusion drawn by Eld. W. that the atonement affects only the body, provided the word “body” is used in its fullest sense, which makes it include all there is of an individual. If redemption applies to a change which takes place wholly in this life, why did Paul say, “If Christ be not raised, . . . they also which have fallen asleep in Christ are perished” (1 Cor. 15:18); and “If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable”? And what is the meaning of the same apostle's expression in the Epistle to the Romans, “waiting for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of our body”?

The next paragraph unfairly represents us as maintaining that character does not pertain to the individual, but to a representation of him, because we claim it to be an attribute of the organization. We have already answered this argument several times by calling attention to the fact, too patent to need pointing out, that the soul is only a representation of the individual after and during death. While the soul is a part of the body, during life, it is evident that the character pertains to the individual also.

Eld. W. says that we charge him with saying “that spiritual life means simply a state of favor with God,” and remarks that our addition of the word “simply” wholly changes his meaning. We do not see how such a change is effected. To our mind, the statement that “spiritual life means a state of favor with God,” which Eld. W. acknowledges, is not materially different from what we stated. This looks to us like making a distinction without a difference.

Eld. W. asks, “But do the Scriptures teach that harmony with God merely depends upon the operations of a delicately constructed machine?” We understand the question to be, in other words, Do the Scriptures teach that harmony with God merely depends upon the operations of the brain? In reply we will ask, Did our reviewer ever know of an individual's being in harmony with God without the operations of a brain? This is begging the question utterly.

Eld. W. charges us with “untruly” charging him with maintaining that “the word ‘life’ is not used in the Scriptures in a figurative sense,” and asserts that we found upon this “false representation” an “inference too ridiculous and unfounded to deserve notice.” Well, this is a pretty severe charge. We have meant to be truthful, candid, and honest in this discussion, and can hardly feel satisfied to let the matter pass without stating the grounds upon which our statement was made. In his first article Eld. W. quoted several texts as illustrations of the use of the word “life” as meaning “spiritual life,” among others the following text: “We know that we have passed from death unto life, because we love the brethren.” In reply we took the position that this use of the word is figurative, since the term “life” in a literal sense implies vital functions. In his rejoinder, Eld. W. objected to our position, and treated it rather uncandidly, intimating that a word cannot be used in a figurative sense in the statement of a fact. This looks to us very much like maintaining that the sense in which the word “life” is used in the text quoted is not figurative. If this is not the intent of the argument, it is most disingenuous, to say the least, besides being wholly lacking in force.

In his article on “Death,” Eld. W. takes the position that spiritual life means “a state of favor with God.” As he objected to our statement that the use of life in a spiritual sense was figurative, it seems to us that he has no right to object to our statement that he had maintained the contrary of our position. This manner of dealing with our argument on this question was probably much easier than to reconcile his position previously maintained that the use of the word “life” in such texts as, “We know that we have passed from death unto life,” etc., was not figurative, with the position that spiritual life means “a state of favor with God.” If “life” in the text quoted does not mean “a state of favor with God,” will Eld. W. please tell us what it does mean? And if the use of the word “life” as meaning “a state of favor with God” is not a figurative use, will he kindly explain what a figurative use of the word would be?

We called attention to the fact that according to Eld. W.'s position the penalty pronounced, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die,” simply means, “The soul that sinneth” shall go into “a state of disfavor with God.” Eld. W. does not attempt to meet this argument. Is he willing to maintain the position that “a state of disfavor with God” is the only penalty for transgression of God's law? According to this theory, when Job said, “The wicked is reserved to the day of destruction,” Job 21:30, he did not mean destruction at all, but “a state of disfavor with God;” and when the psalmist said, “The wicked shall be turned into hell,” his language was stronger than he meant, and he should have said, “The wicked shall be turned into ‘a state of disfavor,’” etc.; and when the psalmist said again, “The wicked shall be no more,” he really meant, “The wicked shall be” forever in “a state of disfavor with God.” Certainly “this is a strange caricature of Scripture;” and if the whole Bible should be interpreted with the same disregard for the actual meaning of the language employed, what theological doctrine could be made to stand by Scripture evidence?

With reference to our substitution of the word “description” for “ascription” we have only to say that we did our best to see a point in the language as written, but failing to do so, and appealing to a learned friend for help, it was suggested that as there were several slight typographical errors in the article it was possible that this also was one, the word “ascription” being substituted for “description.” As this seemed to help matters a little, we accepted the suggestion; and it now really seems to us that the argument is just as good with the substituted word as with the other. As remarked before, Eld. W. has not shown that death means one thing in Gen. 2:17 and an entirely different thing in Gen. 3:19. If death means “a state of disfavor with God” in Gen. 2:17, there can be no logical reason given why it should not mean the same in Gen. 3:19.

The argument from Matt. 10:28 we have already answered, and we need not recapitulate. Eld. W. says, “This statement of Christ would be of no force or consistency if the spirit were not the seat of consciousness or responsibility.” How does our reviewer know this? If the soul is capable of preserving an individual's identity after he is dead, and securing to him a future life through the resurrection, it is certainly of greater importance than the body, even though it possesses neither responsibility nor consciousness independent of the body.

Our reviewer finally winds up his notice of our reply with “a puff of carbonic acid gas,” which, we are impressed, is a very appropriate conclusion, but an argumentp. 228 which we shall not attempt to answer, as, if it possess any point at all, it is too attenuated to be visible with the most powerful logical microscope which we are able to bring to bear upon it.

J. H. KELLOGG.