CHURCH AND STATE

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 30, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 15.

Read the full edition

CHURCH AND STATE.

We readily give a place to such utterances as the following respecting a religious revolution which we believe is sure to be seen at no distant day in this country. For the more men argue that a certain event cannot take place, the more striking is it, when it is accomplished. The writer asks, with an air to indicate that the question is sufficient to annihilate the idea, which church, in this land of so many different churches, the State will unite with.
This question we have often asked for the sake of recording the answer. The prophecy itself seems to anticipate the question, and make provision for the answer; for it declares that it is necessary for an “image” to be “made.” Rev. 13:14. Should the government adopt or recognize any one of the existing denominations as a State church, that would not be, in the terms of the prophecy, “saying to them that dwell on the earth, that they should make an image to the beast.” But if from the discordant religious elements in this country, there should be formed, under government patronage, a new ecclesiastical organization, on the principle of political fusion, and the government should give such organization “life,” or power to act in ecclesiastical matters, here we should have, not, strictly speaking, a union of Church and State, like that of which we have had such hideous examples in the past, but a veritable image of the beast, such as the prophecy calls for.
The prophecy will be fulfilled. And if this is a correct interpretation of the prophecy, this is what is to be. Then it will not matter how much men talk against it, or argue its impossibility. They might as well attempt to turn back the waters of Niagara by a shout. The article is from the Boston Post, of Sept. 17, 1880:—
The London correspondent of the Manchester Guardian has been indulging in strange statements. In his reference to the intended visit of Dean Stanley to the United States he says it will be made for the purpose of investigating the church question, and sapiently adds that it is said the growth of Catholicism in the United States is creating a current of feeling there in favor of State and Church union as a safeguard against the growing evil. If there are phases of Catholicism in this country that tend to give sober-minded observers apprehension we believe they are sporadic rather than characteristic. But if we were to admit the worst, we can see nothing but a nonsensical suggestion in this statement. It is made in rather indefinite terms; but what State and Church union could be effected in this country were there any reason for a fusion of secular and sacred interests? With what church would the State unite? It would be impossible to establish a church to work in harness with the civil government, and which of those already in the field should it be? Or would there be a union of all anti-Catholic religious bodies, including the Jews? or would the Protestant denominations fall into line and debar all Catholics from participation in civil government? We opine that society in this country would be very lively for a time, and the Christian statesmen would be in danger of committing greater excesses than ever. Yet we have heard good orthodox teachers and preachers declare that it was much better to be a Catholic than to have no religion. So what would be done with Bob Ingersoll and other unbelievers? Would they be outlawed and made fair plunder for both sides? Disestablishment is hard enough, but establishment to the extent of a union of Church and State would be still more difficult in a country and a society of such heterogeneous and infusible religious elements as are to be found in the United States. A theocracy is not a nice thing to threaten, and it will never be established with the consent of an independent and liberty-loving people. Cotton Mather started to feel his way to priestly elevation, encouraged and upheld by his followers and admirers, but he found a lion in his path, that democratic giant in body, mind, and soul, John Wise, who crushed this crafty conspiracy with logic and satire that were irresistible. He was a living force and promoter of a love of liberty long after his body was laid in the earth, and if any think that the church should have authority in secular and civil affairs, we refer them back to the words of John Wise, which were full of truth, and carried a wholesome warning for all times.