AdventAI

SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS AND SEVENTH-DAY BAPTISTS.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 20., November 11, 1880

A REPLY.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Concluded.)

Proposition 4: “They must arise this side of 1798.” Inference: According to the Seventh-day Adventist interpretation of the prophecies, a people possessing “the patience of the saints,” who “keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus,” could not arise before 1798. The Seventh-day Adventists have arisen since 1798, and are, therefore, “the true people of God!”

With what the gentleman has said on this point we have no particular fault to find, except that in this case he says that we claim we are the people of God because we have arisen this side of 1798; whereas, we coupled with this reason ten others, of equal importance, before drawing our conclusion.

Proposition 5: “They must arise within the United States.” Inference: According to the interpretation of the prophecies by the Seventh-day Adventists, the true people of God must arise within the United States. The Seventh-day Adventists have arisen within the United States, and are, therefore, “the true people of God.”

Of Proposition 5, also, we remark that the same strictures urged against Propositions 3 and 4 will apply here.

Proposition 6: “The people brought to view in the text must arise subsequent to the proclamation of the first and second angel’s messages.” Inference: In the light of the interpretation of Rev. 14:6–8, by Seventh-day Adventists, they are the people and the only people described by the spirit of Inspiration, as “here is the patience of the saints; here are they that keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus!”

To the above inference we offer no special objection. It is the most nearly legitimate of any which the gentleman has as yet attempted to put in our mouth. Let the reader remember, however, that the point which we made under Proposition 6 was simply that Seventh-day Adventists are the special people brought to view in Rev. 14:9–12, as proved by the fact that in addition to the other ten points which that “special people” were to meet, Seventh-day Adventists also met the eleventh one, which also was to constitute a peculiarity of that “special class”; i. e., they have arisen this side of 1798, or, in other words, at the right time.

As we would not be captious, and appear to be disposed to find fault unnecessarily, we shall not dilate upon the mistake made by the writer in declaring that in that proposition we sought to prove that Seventh-day Adventists are the people spoken of in Rev. 14:6–8. It was the class in Rev. 14:9–12 with which we claimed they were identical.

Proposition 7: “They must stand in a period entitled, ‘the hour of God’s judgment.’” Inference: Seventh-day Adventists must be God’s only true people, because their interpretation of Rev. 14:7 makes “the hour of his judgment” “the investigative Judgment,” or testing period covered by the Advent proclamation subsequent to 1844.

The objection which we offer to this inference lies in the fact that the expression “only” true people of God is one which we have nowhere employed, and one which, as it is here used, is calculated to mislead.

The average reader would be sure to conclude from the inference attributed to us by our reviewer, that we thought that God had no true people outside of the Seventh-day Adventist body. But such a conclusion would be utterly false. The book entitled, “Position and Work of the True People of God under the Third Angel’s Message,” while it argues that Seventh-day Adventists are giving the message in question, and while it insists that no others besides themselves can be properly said to be giving that message, nevertheless concedes that at the present time there are many who are not connected with that work who are earnest and sincere followers of Christ.

In proof of the foregoing statement, we subjoin the following citations from the book in question: “Furthermore, we will, for the sake of the argument, grant that they [the orthodox churches] have the faith of Jesus [p. 44]; while it may be said of others who are without it [i. e., the spirit of prophecy] that they are Christians. It would be futile to urge that they are the Christians who are giving the message in question [p. 59]; that they [Seventh-day Baptists] keep the commandments of God, it gives us great pleasure to say is undeniably true; also that they [Seventh-day Baptists] accept the teachings of the New Testament, or the faith of Jesus as they understand it. [p. 48.] ‘The faith of Jesus’ is nothing more nor less than the gospel of Christ, which is brought to view in the New Testament.” p. 48.

The reader well understands how sensitive men are in the matter of having others arrogate to themselves the honor of being the only true people of God. He will readily observe the effect which the unauthorized introduction of the word “only” into the proposition would have upon the minds of those reading the article of Eld. B.

At a glance he will perceive that it furnishes a strong appeal to their prejudice and passions. While they might be willing to admit that Seventh-day Adventists are the people of God in common with themselves, they would not concede that they were so to their own exclusion; hence the importance that our proposition should have been correctly stated.

We hope that our reviewer is not anxious to place us in a false attitude before his people; but if he be not, he should be extremely cautious how he either adds important words to, or takes them from, the conclusions which we have drawn.

The simple facts are these: Seventh-day Adventists believe that the time will come in the future, when all the people of God will be gathered together into one fold and prepared for the coming of the Lord. How far distant that time may be, they do not pretend to say; but until it shall be reached, they believe that many of the followers of Christ will still be found among the orthodox churches, as they are at the present time.

Proposition 8: “They must arise subsequent to 1844.” Inference: In the light of their own interpretation of prophecy, Seventh-day Adventists must be “the true people of God,” “because they arose subsequent to 1844.”

Here, again, we urge, as in Propositions 4, 5, and 6, that we did not infer that Seventh-day Adventists are giving the third angel’s message simply because they arose this side of 1844, but because, in addition to this, they fulfill the other ten specifications.

Proposition 9: “They must be Adventists.” Inference: Seventh-day Adventists are the true people of God, because they are Adventists.

In the foregoing, Eld. B. does discredit to himself, in that while purporting gravely to give the inference drawn by me under Proposition 9, he simply burlesques the position there taken. He does this, also, without giving the least intimation to the reader of the humor in which he speaks. Now observe the difference between his statement and the fact.

He says that I inferred that Seventh-day Adventists are the true people of God because they are Adventists. Now what I did infer is simply this in substance: Those who give the third angel’s message, in addition to answering to the other ten points specified, must also be Adventists. Seventh-day Adventists meet the other ten specifications, and are also believers in the near coming of Christ; therefore, they are giving the third angel’s message.p. 306

Further comment on this point will not be needed by the candid reader. He will also perceive the injustice of the inference imputed to us when, by turning to p. 46 of the pamphlet in question, he finds that we there considered the claims of the First-day Adventists to the honor of giving the third message, and set them aside in the following words: “Entering the territory which lies just outside the orthodox world, we find an order of persons entitled by some First-day Adventists. These, as the very name implies, if tested by the rules already applied, will also be found lacking.”

If Eld. B. stated our inference fairly, then inasmuch as we conceded that they are “Adventists,” we ought to have admitted that they are giving the message of the third angel. But did we do so? Just the reverse of that. Hence it will be difficult for a fair-minded person to see how our critic could have indulged in the statement which he has done in putting the above inference in our mouth.

Proposition 10: “They must occupy a position which can properly be called the patience of the saints.” Inference: Seventh-day Adventists understand themselves to be in possession of the patience of the saints, and are, therefore, God’s true people!

When our reviewer reached Proposition No. 10, the habit of either mistaking our inferences, or only stating them in part, had become so far chronic, that we doubt whether we ought to hold him responsible for what he has said under this head.

Our position was simply this, not that Seventh-day Adventists possess the “patience of the saints” in the common acceptation of that term, but that their lot is cast in a period in which the people of God were to undergo great trials, temptations, and persecutions; and that as such a period is at times spoken of in the Scriptures as “the patience of the saints,” they also meet this specification of the prophecy.

Proposition 11: “They must have the spirit of prophecy.” Inference: Seventh-day Adventists believe and proclaim themselves to be in possession of the spirit of prophecy, and are, therefore, the true people of God described in Rev. 14:12!

On this point we offer the same strictures which were offered under Propositions 4, 5, and 6.

After leaving the eleven points considered above, Eld. B. strikes out into an independent discussion of his theme, containing a few points at which we wish to glance briefly.

Among other things, he asserts that Seventh-day Adventists “arrogate to themselves a superiority in unerring understanding.” To treat this point in the shortest manner possible, would be simply to say that it is utterly untrue. Seventh-day Adventists do not, and never have, arrogated to themselves unerring understanding. They frankly concede that they may still hold erroneous opinions in some particulars, and, in the use of the language of another, that new light may still “break out of the word of God.”

That the charge is unjust, the gentleman himself proves; for in the immediate connection he states that since 1844 they have “modified their conclusions.” Now modification of conclusions implies change of opinion, and change of opinion is not consonant with unerring understanding; hence how could Seventh-day Adventists, while changing their views, as they certainly have done on some points quite recently, still have the brazen effrontery to urge that they were infallible guides in matters of doctrine? We leave the answer to the question to the ingenuity of the one who made the charge and himself refuted it.

Further on there are several minor declarations to which, were space permitted, we would be glad to give attention more fully; but we shall be compelled to dispose of them with a passing remark.

The gentleman states, for example, in substance, that Seventh-day Adventists have been in error in the past, and are as likely to be as likely to be disappointed again as they were then is not so readily admitted. They would be dull scholars indeed, if they had learned nothing by one mistake and thirty-six years of hard study.

But let us see just how much weight this one mistake should have in the matter of the interpretation of prophecy. To begin with, is the gentleman aware of the fact that not one out of twenty of the existing Adventist denomination were Adventists at the time the mistake in question was made? Does he not know, also, that to Seventh-day Adventists belongs the credit, if any be due to any one, of correcting and explaining the mistake of Wm. Miller?

This being true, should not the claims of Seventh-day Adventists as interpreters of the prophecy depend very largely upon their ability to explain the error in question, rather than upon an error which they as a distinctive denomination never made?

If the gentleman would grapple with their theory of the sanctuary, and demolish it, then—since they claim that it explains the mystery in question—he would have taken a long step in weakening their reputation for correct Scripture exegesis. Should he ever attempt to do this, we fancy he would find himself called upon to explain more of what he is pleased to call “inferences” than he could dispose of with any degree of comfort.

By the way, does he know of any denomination of men who have never made mistakes in their theological deductions? Are Seventh-day Baptists of that order? Are they in the habit of discounting the authority of those who turn to the observance of the seventh day of the week and unite with them, because formerly, through error, they had observed the first day? On the contrary, does not the candor of those individuals in confessing their mistake, as well as their ability to discover the same, commend those persons to their favorable consideration?

Again, astronomy is termed an “exact science”; but who does not know that astronomers have recently corrected a mistake in the former computations of the distance of the sun? Shall we, therefore, reject the science of astronomy, and along with it the professors of that science? Or shall we rather conclude that these professors have learned something by past mistakes, and, therefore, are now more worthy of our confidence than they were formerly?

But we must pass with the single remark that the dates which Mr. Miller employed, and which Seventh-day Adventists believe that “God fixed,” are the same which are now employed by that people; they believing that Mr. Miller’s mistake was simply in the event, and not in the time.

In conclusion, we call attention to the following statements of our critic: “Seventh-day Baptists should seek, in the fullest application of the truth revealed, that renewal and sanctification which will make them a power for good; but they cannot be faithful conservators of that truth if they shall treat as a matter of no importance, a system of interpretation which rests upon human inference instead of the sure word of God.”

The reader will now please bear in mind that the main objection urged against Seventh-day Adventists in the article under review, the one out of which its author designed to make the most capital, was that Seventh-day Adventists are exclusive in their character.

With this fact fresh before his mind, and while remembering that the point in discussion by the gentleman in question is the propriety of extending to Seventh-day Adventists, by an interchange of delegates, etc., to their respective Conferences, those amenities common between different denominations on good terms with each other, let him ask himself, Who, after all, would prove themselves to be the more exclusive in fact; those who, like Seventh-day Adventists, are to a man, as far as we are aware, anxious to send delegates to, and receive them from, the Seventh-day Baptist body, or those Seventh-day Baptists, who, like the gentleman, would say to Seventh-day Adventist ministers, as the heathen priests used formerly to say to those who were not of their following, and who sought to approach their temples, “Stand afar, lest ye profane”? In other words, who should be considered exclusive, the humble delegates from the Seventh-day Adventist General Conference who might apply for admission to the similar body belonging to Seventh-day Baptists, or an individual, who, like the one to whom we are replying, should wrap himself in the robe of his own self-sufficiency, and, rising to his feet, warn his brethren not to receive into their number the humble applicants in question, since Seventh-day Baptists could not be the conservators of God’s truth if they should treat as a matter of no importance a system of interpretation “which rests upon human inference instead of the sure word of God?”

The next and only remaining quotation to which we wish to refer runs as follows: “With such views of themselves and their divinely appointed mission, is it possible for them [i. e., Seventh-day Adventists] to have in view, or seek, in their intercourse with Seventh-day Baptists, any other end than to win them to the acceptance of the message which they believe themselves commissioned to proclaim to the men of this age?”

In the above citation, we fancy, is found that which is, in fact, the key to the mystery of Eld. Burdick’s opposition to an interchange of delegates with Seventh-day Adventists. The motive of his action is here so thinly disguised that we think no one can fail to discover it.

He evidently apprehends that Seventh-day Adventists have an ulterior object in view, and that this object is the bringing over to themselves of the Seventh-day Baptist denomination. If we are right in our surmises, we inquire whether, even though we should concede that the gentleman is correct in his inference, Seventh-day Adventists ought to be censured or rejected on that account. Why so timid in the matter? If Seventh-day Adventists are really what the gentleman claims they are, would it not be well to exhibit some “live specimens” of them before his people, so that they might the sooner become disgusted with them through actual observation of their arrogance?

But why, we ask again, be so fearful of the contact? Does not the gentleman believe in the survival of the fittest in spiritual things? Is not his denomination of the longest standing? Does he not claim for it the prestige and the history? If so, and if, indeed, they have so much truth, and Seventh-day Adventists so much error, would not the latter be the more likely to be absorbed by contact? thus saving them from both error and mistake by being swallowed up by a denomination who have but little of the one and who have never committed the other.

As an individual, we should be ashamed of Seventh-day Adventists should they urge as a reason for rejecting the delegates of the Seventh-day Baptist denomination the fact that the latter hope to absorb them into themselves. In fact, should the time ever come when they should make such a plea, we should decide that the sooner they were absorbed the better.

Again we inquire, Should it be admitted that the ulterior object of Seventh-day Adventists is that of the absorption of Seventh-day Baptists through the interchange in question, would such a concession reveal an unworthy motive on their part? Would the gentleman insist that such an absorption as might result from fair and honorable contact should not be sought for by them? Would he censure them for an earnest desire to bring into their own fold those who they believe would be greatly benefited by the change?

If so, let us apply his own logic to the case of his own people. If we are not mistaken, Seventh-day Baptists entertain the belief that at some time in the future all the churches are to be brought to the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath, and that they stand as the “conservators of God’s truth,” awaiting and endeavoring to hasten that glorious event.

In performing this mission, what are they doing?p. 307

Are they not, in all legitimate ways, trying to draw men into the Seventh-day Baptist church, whether members of other denominations, or non-professors? We think the answer will be in the affirmative. As an individual, also, we honor them for doing what they are doing from their standpoint.

If, however, at this late period in their history, they shall develop a timidity of contact with others such as is manifested by Eld. B. and his coadjutors, we fear that their power as an aggressive force is rapidly waning, if not actually extinct. But in conclusion let us say that we cannot believe that they have become thus weak-kneed; that we cannot hold responsible for the spirit and sentiment of the article which we have been reviewing even a majority of a denomination whom we hold in such high esteem as we do Seventh-day Baptists. We are confident that when the rank and file of the members have been heard from, their verdict will be, “Away with that exclusiveness and that timidity which would shut us as a people out from friendly co-operation with a young and rising church, who, though not agreed with us at present in certain points of faith, do, nevertheless, hold in common with us a love for the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.”