BY WM. PENNIMAN.
Under the heading, “The Observance of Sunday,” a recent issue of the Saturday Review has the following:—
“The observance of Sunday, or the Lord’s day as it is called in the New Testament—to which other festivals were gradually added—is unquestionably coeval with the Christian Church, but it was never before the sixteenth, or in England the seventeenth century, confounded with the Jewish Sabbath. It has been very generally believed that this was one of the ‘commandments’ which our Lord gave his apostles during the forty days between the resurrection and ascension. Be that as it may, the practice can be clearly traced up to the apostolic age, while it is equally clear that the observance of the Jewish Sabbath was never held obligatory on Christians, and St. Paul sharply denounced it as a dangerous superstition. The Sabbath was no doubt observed for a time, as were also other portions of the old ceremonial law, by some Jewish converts. And from an early period Saturday was observed in the West as a fast, in memory of the burial of our Lord, as it afterward came to be consecrated to the honor of the Virgin Mary, who had an Officium in Sabbato in the Latin ritual—a consideration which we commend to the notice of the Sabbatarian societies. But these usages served rather to distinguish the day from Sunday than to identify the two. The latter was invariably kept as a festival, the two duties insisted on being attendance at the service of the eucharist and abstaining from servile work, with the exception of agricultural labor in cases of necessity. The Council of Laodicea laid down express directions on both points, and after the conversion of Constantine the State added legal sanctions to the rules of the church. An edict of Constantine enjoins the cessation of military exercises, law business, and work of all kinds—with the exception just now mentioned—‘on the venerable day of the sun.’ The Emperor Theodosius went further, and suppressed all public spectacles on that day, and these prohibitions were renewed afterward in the Capitularies of Charlemagne. Meanwhile the clergy used their whole influence, very beneficially on the whole, to enforce this observance, and various legends were current.”
The leading argument in the preceding paragraph seems to be a reference to the suppositional, or unwritten, commandment which Christ gave between his resurrection and ascension. Why is Sunday called the Lord’s day? Certainly not because Christ claimed it as his day; for he said he was “Lord of the Sabbath day.” Neither can it be established (as some attempt to do, though the writer of the paragraph we are reviewing does not) that the Sabbath of the commandment was Sunday; for the Sabbath always comes on the seventh day of the week, and Sunday on the first. Christ’s saying, “The Sabbath was made for man,” is sometimes quoted, “Sunday was made for man;” but this is a gross mistake, as Sunday was made by man.
It is claimed that “John was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day” (Rev. 1: 10), and this must have been the first day of the week, or Sunday; but where is the proof of this? The first day of the week is never so called, but the seventh is, repeatedly. (See Ex. 20: 10; Isa. 58: 13; Mark 2: 28.) But the most effectual way of overthrowing this claimed-to-be Sunday or first-day pillar is given in the criticism by Eld. D. T. Bourdeau, in the REVIEW of June 24, and we will quote it for the benefit of new readers, and for those who did not notice it closely. It is as follows:—“But does the genius of the Greek language really require that we apply the term κυριακῇ, in Rev. 1: 10, to Christ? By no means. In Greek, as well as in English, Lord’s or lordly may be applied to other things than to those which belong to Christ. But there is a principle which is true in all languages, and which permits us to apply the term in question to Jehovah; namely, that the sense of an adjective or qualifying word which is derived from a substantive, must be determined by the aid of that substantive. Take, for example, the words ‘office’ and ‘official.’ The official duties of a person are the duties which grow out of his office. Let us apply this principle to the case before us. We have κυριακή, lordly, which is derived from κυριος, Lord, and κυριος is applied in the original to God the Father as well as to Christ. David, speaking of Jehovah and of Christ, says, ‘The Lord [κυριος, the Father] said unto my Lord [κυριε, the Son; it is the same noun as the first, only in a different case], Sit thou on my right hand, till I make thine enemies thy footstool.’ Matt. 22: 44. Other texts could be quoted in support of this point.”
The name of Lord’s day for Sunday is of papal origin. (See J. N. Andrews’ “History of the Sabbath,” p. 259.)
“Other festivals were gradually added.” This statement is an admission that Sunday was a festival day, and “an admission in favor of the truth from an opponent is a strong argument in support of it.” Sunday has been a festival day from remote antiquity, and is more ancient than the Christian Church, having its origin in the pagan worship of the sun. The North British Review styles the day, “The wild solar holiday of all pagan times.”
The observance of Sunday as the Sabbath is not coeval with the Christian Church; for we read: “The first great effort made to put down the Sabbath, was the act of the church of Rome in turning it into a fast, while Sunday was made a joyful festival.”—History of the Sabbath, p. 242. Thus it is seen that the struggle began with the third century; that is, immediately after the year 200. In the “History of the Sabbath,” abundant historical proof of these facts is given by quotations from various writers.
Our writer intimates that an attempt has been made to confound Sunday with the Sabbath (not the Jewish Sabbath, for no such appellation is found in the word of God); but the two days do not mingle any more than oil and water, and all who are reasonable and consistent have given up trying to make them blend. This is more especially true of those who hold that the Sabbath is God’s institution, and the Sunday’s man’s.
His strong point is thus stated: “It has been generally believed that this was one of the ‘commandments’ which our Lord gave his apostles during the forty days between the resurrection and the ascension.” There was a time when it was generally believed that the sun revolved around the earth; but the belief did not make it so. If the law for Sunday was one of the commandments which Christ gave between his resurrection and ascension, it must be referred to in John 21: 25, which reads: “And there are also many other things which Jesus did, the which, if they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that should be written.” As we find no commandment for Sunday observance either in the Old Testament or the New, Sunday-keepers are obliged to base Sunday observance on the unwritten commandment contained in one of “the books” not written. By appealing to these unwritten books, any doctrine can be proved, no matter how unscriptural or absurd. There is no doctrine held by the church of Rome, no iniquity practiced in the name of religion by Catholic, Mormon, or spiritualist, that may not be sustained by these same unwritten books. But who believes that God will hold us amenable to rules which he has never had recorded in his word? The God of Heaven is not like the prince who posted his laws so high that the people could not read them, and then punished his subjects for their violation. In the Judgment, we shall not be held responsible for obedience to any law which is not clearly stated in our guide-book, the word of God.
There is no proof that the practice of observing Sunday as a Sabbath can be “traced up to the apostolic age.” The observance of the Sabbath was obligatory upon the human race. Christ especially declares that “the Sabbath was made for man.” The Sabbath was established in Eden, and is coeval with the marriage institution. If “man” means the Jew, then the woman was made for the Jew; for the word expressly says that “the woman was made for the man.” So if the Sabbath is Jewish, the marriage institution is Jewish also.
It is very strange that if Paul denounced the Sabbathp. 242 as such a “dangerous superstition,” there is no record of it. It may be claimed by some that Col. 2: 16, or some part of the chapter, refers to this dangerous doctrine of Sabbath-keeping; but the sabbaths referred to are ceremonial, and good first-day commentators admit it. Superstition is defined as “the doing of things not required by God.” Then certainly Sunday-keepers are superstitious; for God nowhere in his word requires the observance of the first day of the week.
Again, there is abundant proof that the Sabbath was observed in the apostolic age. (See Acts 13.) We read (Acts 18: 17) that Paul “committed nothing against the custom of his fathers.” Could he have said this truthfully, had he been a Sabbath-breaker? Certainly he did not say much about the Sabbath as a dangerous institution. Paul taught the perpetuity of the law. Rom. 3: 31: “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” If Paul thought the Sabbath so “dangerous,” why did he, in this text and in so many others which might be quoted, teach the perpetuity of that law which commands it? Peter taught the perpetuity of the law in preaching repentance. James taught the validity of the ten commandments in teaching that he who violates one of them is guilty of all. John taught it (Rev. 22: 14) when he said, “Blessed are they that do his [the Father’s] commandments [and the Sabbath commandment is one of them], that they may have right to the tree of life.”
But while speaking of this “dangerous” doctrine of Sabbath observance, we must not omit to say that if Paul could visit some of the modern “Mars’ hills,” and behold the millions of Sunday-keepers not only worshiping the “Unknown God,” but also obeying the unknown and unwritten commandment for Sunday-keeping, he would cry out, as he did of old, “I perceive that in all things ye are too superstitious.”
There is, indeed, no doubt about Jewish converts observing the Sabbath; for in the early stages of Christianity there was no other day for them to observe; the pagan Sunday, which both Jews and Christians would naturally be so averse to keeping, had not then been made a Sabbath.
By what authority can it be said that the Sabbath was a “part of the old ceremonial law”? If the Sabbath is ceremonial, the law against idolatry, the making and serving of images, and also the law against profanity and stealing, are all ceremonial. Some seem to forget that the Sabbath was founded in Eden, many ages before the ceremonial law was given. (See tract entitled “The Two Laws,” published at REVIEW AND HERALD Office, Battle Creek, Mich.) John Wesley taught the perpetuity of the law; consequently he did not teach the abrogation of any part of the moral law by representing it as ceremonial. But the “advocates” of his doctrines, and among them the New York Christian Advocate, go directly against him in publishing such sentiments. (See Wesley on the law.) We are glad to see the admission that “Saturday was observed in the West as a fast.” This is one of the things that brought about the general observance of Sunday, the “festival day,” as men love feasting so much better than fasting.
The “Officium in Sabbato” of the Virgin Mary, consecrated in the Latin ritual, is another illustration of the way the Roman power has mangled the law of God. Not wishing to entirely neglect an institution so plainly commanded, and which they claim to have changed (See Dan. 7: 25, and Catholic Catechism, or tract, “Who Changed the Sabbath?”), they kept up its memory, not by observing it, but by the Officium in Sabbato in the Latin ritual. The reason for the observance of this part of the ritual “we commend to the consideration” of Sunday-keepers.
If one is candid, he has only to read Constantine’s edict in regard to “agricultural labor in cases of necessity,” to be convinced that the claims of the Sunday-Sabbath are spurious. This edict, issued A. D. 321, reads as follows: “Let all the judges and town people, and the occupation of all trades, rest on the venerable day of the sun; but let those who are situated in the country, freely, and at full liberty, attend to the business of agriculture; because it often happens that no other day is so fit for sowing corn and planting vines; lest the critical moment being let slip, men should lose the commodities granted by Heaven.” The original of this edict in Latin can be seen in the Harvard College library. (See “History of the Sabbath,” 2d ed., p. 342.) The command for the true Sabbath says, “Thou shalt not do any work,” which of course does not prohibit genuine works of necessity.
What do the “express directions” of the Council of Laodicea amount to, if they are not in accordance with God’s directions? Christ applied to those who substituted the traditions of the elders for his Father’s law, the words of God by the mouth of the prophet, “In vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” How much more authoritative did the rules of a paganized church become, after there had been added to them the “legal sanctions of the State,” which was terribly corrupt under the influence of Constantine, a pagan emperor only partially converted to Christianity?
The “Capitularies of Charlemagne” were a combination of the ecclesiastical and civil laws, which were in fact a union of church and state, the very thing which some Protestants are now trying to bring about; and their object is now as it was then, to promote a better observance of “the venerable day of the sun.”
We advise the Saturday Review to try again, as it is true now as formerly, that “various legends” (incredible or unauthentic narrations) are current to prove the genuineness of the day which the unwritten commandment enjoins.