REVIEW OF HOLLIDAY

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 11, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 20.

Read the full edition

REVIEW OF HOLLIDAY.

BY A. SMITH.
(Concluded.)
Mr. H. then became very eloquent over Isa. 66: 20-23, representing that in “Life Incidents” Eld. White applies the whole prophecy in this life. He claimed that for “all flesh” to go up to Jerusalem from America alone would require four hundred thousand large ships; that from Siberia they would have to build railroads, or go by the “north-west passage;” that the throng of men, women, and children overland from Joppa to Jerusalem, would necessitate excellent care of the roads; and that the magnitude of the commissary department at the latter city would be enormous.
Such a glaring misrepresentation of the author of the book referred to is hardly excusable in a man of ordinary intelligence, much less in a professed minister of the gospel. What Eld. White did say in the work alluded to in reference to the text under consideration, is as follows:—
“There is no point of time in the past when all flesh have come to worship before the God of Heaven on the Sabbath; and this can never be while the wheat and tares, the children of the kingdom and the children of the wicked one, grow together; and these will not be separated until the harvest, which is the end of the world. This unity in reference to the memorial of the great God will be seen only in the immortal state, when from one Sabbath to another, and from one new moon to another, all flesh shall come to worship before the Lord.” p. 364.
We do not know but that immortal man will be able to go through the air with the rapidity of lightning. At any rate, we may rest assured that God will provide means to verify the prophecy.
Speaking further of the covenants, Eld. H. said in reference to Heb. 12:18-24, “God now wants men to obey without law. There are serious objections to legal enactments in this age.”
Yes, no doubt. This is a lawless age. Paul speaks of it in 2 Tim. 3:1-5. We pray that it may speedily end.
As an illustration of the obedience “without law” on our part with which he says God is well pleased, he cited the cheerful alacrity with which some children, even without being so ordered, seem to anticipate their parents’ wishes and commands. We think the illustration a very good one, when properly applied. The child is under law to the parent, and pleases the parent, when, as in the above illustration, he fulfills the law without making it necessary to frequently remind him of his duty. So God has a law requiring the sanctification of the seventh-day Sabbath, and is doubtless well pleased when cheerful obedience is rendered.
In endeavoring to prove a change of the Sabbath at the cross, he said, “Christ did things on the Sabbath that would hardly have been allowed in Moses’s time, and would have rendered him liable to be stoned. But I think he did no wrong; for the Sabbath was then in its dotage. Christ fulfilled the law of the Sabbath, and nailed it to his cross.”
Our language does not abound in mild terms of sufficient strength to express our astonishment at such an insult against the Sabbath and its divine Lord. If, indeed, the Sabbath was in its dotage, why not have allowed it to die a natural death, and not, in its feeble old age, hasten its dissolution by the pain of crucifixion? Christ loved the law of God, and preached its binding obligation (see Ps. 40:7-10, and Matt. 5:17-19); and that law contained the Sabbath. Christ did upon the Sabbath only acts of justice and mercy, and freed the holy day from the senseless tradition with which the Pharisees had burdened it.
Eld. H. expressed it as his opinion that Christ, after his resurrection, appeared on the first day only of each week; but his manner of speaking of the meeting at the Sea of Galilee proved it to be one of his celebrated packhorses that his Sabbatarian friends find it so easy to swallow. It seemed to be a gnat of huge dimensions in his own throat, but it had to go down.
Eld. H.: “After Christ’s ascension, the apostles, being Jews, were reluctant to give up the Sabbath.”
But why so reluctant, if Christ had taught them a change of the Sabbath? How eloquently and persistently they taught the freedom of Christians from the obligations of the ceremonial law, while they always spoke of the seventh day as the Sabbath, never once honoring the first day of the week with that distinctive title. There was no compulsion in the premises to give rise to reluctance. The seventh-day Sabbath is spoken of fifty-eight times in the New Testament, while the first day is only mentioned eight times, and is never called the Sabbath.
Eld. H. next dwelt at considerable length on Acts 20:7, and Rom. 14:5, 6; and finally said that if any one thought best to keep the seventh-day Sabbath, he did no wrong. The gist of his arguments on these two texts, was, of course, to prove a change of the Sabbath, by the example of the apostle as recorded in the first text, and by his advice in the second, concerning the observance of certain days of the week. But it is bad for his theory, that, while the apostle was preaching, his traveling companions, mostly ministers no doubt, were pursuing their journey. To be consistent, it would appear more in order for Paul to have first converted his companions to his way of thinking, had he believed in a change of the Sabbath. Had he so believed, what an excellent opportunity that meeting afforded to say something about it; but not a word on that subject is recorded. If the holding of a single religious meeting on the first day of the week is evidence of its sanctity, how much more is the holy character of the Sabbath attested by the custom of Paul and other primitive Christians of constantly meeting for worship on that day. See Acts 16:13; 17:2; 18:4, 11.
We deny that the term “day” in Rom. 14:5, 6, has reference to the weekly Sabbath; it refers only to such days as Easter, Good Friday, Christmas, etc. But admitting, for argument’s sake, that they have such reference, then, according to Paul’s reasoning, every man must become fully persuaded, not according to his own mind, but in his own mind. To be correct, that persuasion must be according to the will of God, and that will will always harmonize with his revealed word. There is a persuasion that God does not approve of (see Gal. 5:8), and we think that the persuasion which, at the present day, makes the observance or neglect of the Sabbath a matter of indifference or of worldly policy, is of this kind.
We have no objection to Eld. H.’s conclusion that those who keep the seventh-day Sabbath do no wrong; for while his acknowledgment is correct in terms, he thereby forfeits his whole argument. If Sabbatarians are right in their practice, the reasons upon which their practice is based must be correct, and those reasons are in direct antagonism to any other day than the seventh as the weekly Sabbath.
On Rev. 1:10, Eld. H. made the usual claim that the term “Lord’s day” means the first day of the week. The Lord calls the seventh day “The Sabbath of the Lord thy God” (Ex. 20:10); “My holy day;” “Holy of the Lord” (Isa. 58:13); etc. And Christ calls himself “Lord also of the Sabbath.” Mark 2:28. What more natural, therefore, than to conclude that the term “Lord’s day” means the seventh-day Sabbath?
But supposing the early Christians to have understood John to mean by the term “Lord’s day” the first day of the week, or Sunday, it must be observed that he did not say it was the first day, or Sunday, or the Christian Sabbath; nor did these early Christians regard it as the Sabbath.
In “The Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge,” pp. 1095-6, I find the following testimony concerning the first day of the week:—
“Although it was in the primitive times indifferently called the Lord’s day or Sunday, yet it was never denominated the Sabbath,—a name constantly appropriated to Saturday, or the seventh day, both by sacred and ecclesiastical writers.”
We close this article by inviting the reader to carefully consider the foregoing arguments in the light of Scripture testimony, and, unbiased by creeds or early education, decide as one who must finally appear at the bar of God to answer for his faith and works.