We give this week another installment from T. T. Munger’s “Familiar Talk” to the Andover theological students, as published in the Independent. After saying that “an understanding of the exact thing to be done in the ministry, and, consequently, of the means of doing it,” is one of the things that he wishes might have been made plain to him at the outset of his ministerial career, he criticises the statement that the “object of the sermon is ‘the saving of the souls of men.’” He thinks the object to be aimed at is “the persuading and moving of men’s souls.” He says:—
Preachers do not save men. God saves men. The preacher’s business is to persuade and move; or, as I prefer to name his vocation, to inspire men.
There is an immense amount of beating of the air in vain, and shooting arrows at random, and striking in the dark, under the vague generalization that the object of preaching is to save souls. This assertion is too general. It does not tell the young preacher what he is to do. Many a ministry, that otherwise might be valuable, is wasted through lack of perception of the work in hand.
I am filled with pity and sorrow as I think how the young minister turns hither and thither, trying this method and that, all for lack of an illuminating purpose; and also because the pressure is so great that he cannot formulate his plans. I dare not think with how many ministers the main object is to get ready for the next service; to have something, old or new, that will “pass muster” and keep things going.
I do not think we can get nearer the exact thing to be done in preaching than the definition given,—“To persuade and move,”—to inspire men. The object, while general, is also sharp and definite. It tells the preacher exactly what he is to aim at in every sermon, whatever the occasion or subject. He is to uplift, to move the spiritual nature, to arouse the higher emotions and faculties; in one word (and the word itself is a definition), to inspire. Every sermon should be bathed in this element of inspiration. It should breathe into the people spiritual thought and feeling. It should awaken in every one who has ears to hear a sense of being lifted up, a feeling of how grand and noble the gospel and the Christian life are. It should always suggest the higher view of every subject, and clothe it in its noblest garb.
The sermon, of course, will shape itself according to its subject and the knowledge you have to build into it; but its spirit—the quality that makes it what a sermon should be—is this dominating purpose to inspire out of which it sprang.
You see at once how such a conception of the sermon shuts out a hundred faults—sensationalism, personalities, dolorousness, dryness, formality, artistic neatness; for a sermon cannot well be artistic, because it is, as Luther said of Paul’s epistles, a living creature, with feet and hands. You see, also, why I began by speaking of health and vitality, since none but a strong and well man can constantly command this inspiring force; and you will see, also, why I now go on to speak of personality as an element of preaching.
We are beginning to see how personal Christianity is; how little a matter of dogma, how much a matter of life; how meager and fragmentary it is as a doctrinal system, and how full and complete it is as a system made up of personal relations. God is a person; Christ is a person; and Christianity is but a name for the right relations of man to God. The method, the power, must be personal. In its application, it will always have the characteristics of the person through whom it passes, who teaches it, rather than of the truths themselves. To come to the point, I mean that a community or a church will, in the long run, reflect the personality, the temper, spirit, conception, habits of mind, of its minister, rather than reflect the character of the system of doctrine held by both parties. And a minister may, through the force of his character, neutralize, for good or for ill, the force of the creed. Fenelon stood between his flock and Romanism, as many a genial, sympathetic New England and Scotch pastor has toned down the high Calvinism of the creed into a tolerable or even warm faith in the hearts of his people. So powerful is personality. The thing runs very deep, and is divine in its wisdom. Personality is the stable and final thing. “Our little systems have their day;” but the person Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, to day, and forever. And a Christ-taught, Christ-inspired man (as Dr. Bushnell used to say, “a Christed man”) will always teach the truth men need.
If theological education were not already somewhat cumbersome, I think a department for the training of personality might profitably be added. I mean something a great way beyond mental discipline. All that is now insisted upon, as a condition of your presence here, is credible evidence of piety and decency of living; but these are about as far off from the character essential to a minister as the cocoon of a silkworm is from a robe of silk. I think that one great trouble with the pulpit is that it is filled with preachers who are only pious. You will not misunderstand, nor think I scoff. I am speaking in dead earnest. A minister needs something beyond piety. He needs a trained character.
Your character will be more than half your outfit. You get an enormous amount (not too much, however) of critical knowledge of the text, of history, of theology, of rhetoric, of philosophy; but, get as much as you will, and you are only half fitted. You yourself—the shape, force, fixedness, and temper of your character—make up the other half. We go into the ministry and strive to fly with the one wing that is so plumed and nourished by these studies, and often its very strength renders our flight more uncertain and erratic. Happy are we if the other wing is sufficiently developed by grace and self-knowledge to lift us above the earth. When both are alike, with what easy flight we bear the messages between Heaven and earth.
Character is a growth; but it is also a matter of education and training. The Romanists, especially the Jesuits, are wise in this matter. They train and test the temper of the candidate for the priesthood. They have exercises that develop and restrain certain traits. In short, they train the personality, instead of crowding the mind with knowledge. Within two years one of the most eloquent preachers in Paris, a monk, was remanded by his superior to the monastery, and set to menial service in the refectory, not for any misdemeanor, but because his success fostered a pride that hurt him as a preacher. It was thought that after washing dishes a year, he would go back to the pulpit with a fuller use of hisp. 245 great powers. It is not difficult to think of some Protestant preachers who would be improved morally and professionally by taking the place of the sexton for a year and living on his salary. The Romish method may not be the best; but the church of Rome, in its long experience, has found out many things that are worth thinking of.
Why not a department of ministerial character, with an incumbent whose business it would be to study the characters of the students, and point out to them their defects and excesses, and suggest the discipline suited to each case? I am sure that in a large body of students of even credible piety there are those to whom some one should say, and say with authority: “Your motives are wrong; you are swayed by ambition; you are a self-seeker. You have talent; you took the prizes at college; you are studying well here; you are eloquent in a certain formal way, and can easily command what is usually called an important pulpit, i. e., a church that pays a large salary and excludes the poor; but you have no right to be in the ministry. Your temper of mind, your ruling purpose, your habitual thought, your entire make-up, do not consist with the office of pastor and preacher.”
To another he might find it necessary to say: “You are right at heart; but you are too vain, too self-conscious. You will be prone to demand constant flattery, and your ministry will be weak by the constant obtrusion of this quality; wherefore check it, scourge it away, and get both lower down and higher up.”
Another is timid; another is unsympathetic, hard; another is lazy; another is sluggish, dull; another is dreamy and sentimental.
A minister is not educated until he is trained away from his faults, and I see not why this training should not form a distinct part of his preparation. The whole matter is relegated to the assumption of piety. Having that, one is supposed to have everything. But, if my observation has taught me anything, it is the frequency with which, under a general assumption of piety, the details of character and conduct are left unheeded. And, as I have observed ministers, they will bear a strain and test everywhere better than in their characters. I do not refer to gross lapses; but to what are called infirmities and faults. They endure any amount of work, and a great deal of self-denial. They serve in all capacities, fill any place, from addressing an agricultural society to haranguing a caucus; they are laborious in their appointed duties and full of devotional zeal; but I must say they are very apt to break down in a test or strain that actually involves the substance of ministerial character, which I take to be devotion to Christ’s kingdom.
You are trained here to meet any demand that can be made upon you mentally; you could write the history of the town, or the governor’s message, or the ode on Decoration Day; but are you so disciplined in moral qualities that you can bear the contradiction of sinners and of the parish saints also? As I recall the spirit with which most of us left the seminary, in my day, we were surcharged with the spirit of independence. The parishes that took us must look to themselves. They must beware of us, or they would find out we were not to be trodden under foot with impunity. Oh that some Christly one, armed with a whip of cords, could have lashed such nonsense out of us; or, girded with a towel, could have taught us the glory of humility!
But in default of such training, and being already in the ministry, let me say to you, Where you think once of your preaching (I mean of its quality and effect), think twice of your conduct. Don’t raise the question: What sort of preacher am I? But you may sometimes ask yourself: What sort of man am I? When you are first settled, and on re-settlement, the town and newspaper mention of you will refer to your preaching abilities; but in a year or two that will lessen or cease, and the chief mention will refer to the kind of man you are. And however you preach, to this rest you will be brought at last; and there could be none truer. The highest quality in a minister is that which leads men to say, as he walks the streets: “There goes a man I believe in.”