AdventAI

REVIEW OF HOLLIDAY.

By A. Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 19., November 4, 1880

BY A. SMITH.

While the arguments adduced in defense of the Bible Sabbath are clear, concise, and invincible, those urged in support of first-day sanctity are so devious and contradictory that one who should attempt to trace them would become almost lost in the intricate maze.

In the following arguments by Eld. Holliday, a Congregationalist minister, who recently gave a series of Scripture readings on the subject of the Sabbath at Allendale, Mich., some points were made in defense of the so-called Christian Sabbath that were interesting, not because of their weight, but as furnishing an example of the extreme positions to which the defenders of a false doctrine are sometimes driven.

The first point worthy of notice which Mr. H. made, was that the days of the creation week were long, indefinite periods, or ages, of time.

In reply, I will call the reader's attention to the fact that in the fourth commandment of the decalogue no distinction in point of duration is made between the days in which God wrought and rested, and those in which man labors and reposes. Now, substituting Eld. Holliday's definition, the command would read thus: “Remember the Sabbatic indefinite period to keep it holy. Six long indefinite periods, or ages, thou shalt labor, and do all thy work,” etc. If the same rule be applied to like terms in Gen. 8, it would make Noah's stay in the ark greatly exceed the natural period of his life as elsewhere given; and Adam, who was created in the sixth “long period,” rested on the seventh “age,” and lo, when he died he was only nine hundred and thirty years old!

But Mr. H. had only loaded and primed his piece, to blaze away at the Sabbath as mentioned in Gen. 2:2, 3, in the following manner:—

“Of the books of the Pentateuch, Genesis was the last written by Moses, near the close of his life. His recollection of Sinai, doubtless, influenced him in writing the third verse of the second chapter. Paraphrased in harmony with his meaning, it would read about like this, ‘And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it,’ when he gave it to you at Sinai as the Sabbath.”

We had rested in the belief, in harmony with 2 Tim. 3:16; 2 Pet. 1:20, 21, that the Holy Ghost influenced Moses, and other holy men, to write the Scriptures. We had also believed Moses to be an honest narrator; but, according to Eld. H., a certain impression made upon his mind several years before by a terrible scene that he had witnessed, overruled the influence of Inspiration concerning an event that had occurred in Eden, two thousand five hundred years before, and betrayed him as a reliable historian. We believe that such a misconstruction of the text is equivalent to handling the word of God deceitfully (See 2 Cor. 4:2), and deserves the frown of those who cherish the integrity of the Bible.

Having demolished the Edenic Sabbath, and attacked Moses's reputation as an historian, Eld. H. takes a towering position in the following emphatic sentence: “The Sabbath was given to the Jews, and to the Jews alone, and in nowise was it binding upon any other portion of mankind.”

Well, Christ said, “The Sabbath was made for man.” (See Mark 2:27.) But the Sabbath thus made was the seventh-day Sabbath, and no other; and what God made he pronounced “very good.” It is claimed that the Greek text is emphatic, and limits the gift of the Sabbath to the man, or Adam. But what was given to Adam was shared by his wife, and inherited by their offspring. There was no injunction given directly to the woman in Eden, but she shared with her husband in the bitter consequences of the fall. Why not also in the good gifts of God? Did she not need the sacred calm and holy associations of the Sabbath as much as did her husband, that there might be a refreshing break in the otherwise ceaseless round of arduous toil; and that her mind, in unison with his, might be directed in adoration to their Maker? And was not the calm, holy influence of that rest equally good for their children, and their children's children, even to a thousand generations? (See Ps. 105:8.) The only connection that Christ had with the human race was by being born of a virgin; yet he is called “the Son of [the] man” for whom the Sabbath was made. The “man,” therefore, was perpetuated, through forty-two generations, from Adam to Christ; and the gift of the Sabbath was just as certainly perpetuated as was the hope of redemption.

The following testimony concerning the universal obligation of the Sabbath I transcribe from “The Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge,” p. 1038-9:—

“The Sabbath was appointed at the creation of the world, and sanctified, or set apart for holy purposes, ‘for man, for all men, and therefore for Christians; since there was never any repeal of the original institution. . . . It was made for man,’ not as he may be a Jew or a Christian, but as man, a creature bound to love, worship, and obey his God and Maker, and on his trial for eternity.”

Says Dr. Wm. Smith in his “Bible Dictionary,” p. 590:—

“The consecration of the Sabbath was coeval with the creation.”p. 291

Such testimonies weigh heavily against the argument of Eld. H.

The existence of the ordinary week is a recognized division of time in the book of Genesis; and as its days recurred in succession, they must have impressed the people, as doubtless God designed they should, with a recollection of the events of the creation week, including the sanctification of the seventh day.

Mr. H. read numerous texts, and garbled their meaning to fortify his position, endeavoring to show that Israel existed only till the time of Christ. But Paul tells us, in Gal. 3:29, “If ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise.” “Now we [Christians], brethren, as Isaac was, are the children of promise.” Chap. 4:28. The new covenant was made, not with the Gentiles, but with the “house of Israel.” (See Heb. 8:8.) Every Gentile, therefore, who becomes a Christian, does thereby become, by adoption, an Israelite. (See Rom. 11:17-24.)

Concerning the perpetuity of Israel, Jeremiah thus writes: “Thus saith the Lord, which giveth the sun for a light by day, and the ordinances of the moon and of the stars for a light by night, which divideth the sea when the waves thereof roar; the Lord of hosts is his name: if these ordinances depart from before me, saith the Lord, then the seed of Israel also shall cease from being a nation before me forever.” Chap. 31:35, 36. Peter addressed the great body of Christian Israel as a “holy nation.” 1 Pet. 2:9. Over this nation, Christ now rules on the throne of grace; but the time draws near, when, attended by myriads of holy angels, he will appear to the astonished world in the dazzling splendor of the kingdom of glory. Then there will be a final separation between those who honor God and his word, and those who lightly esteem or asperse it.

One of the texts relied upon by Eld. H. to limit the existence of the Sabbath (Ex. 31:16, 17), is proved, by the foregoing considerations, to emphatically express its perpetual obligation.

Eld. H.: “Moses gave the first, or old, covenant, but God gave us the new.”

Thus, unwittingly perhaps, the elder stultified the declaration of the Lord that he gave the first covenant himself. See Heb. 8:9.

Eld. H.: “Thank God, the old covenant and Sabbath are gone forever, and those who try to resurrect them are like the hypocritical Pharisees, who strained at a gnat and swallowed a packhorse. One of the reasons for observing the Sabbath, on the part of the Jew, was his deliverance from Egyptian bondage; but you, whose ancestors were not in Egyptian bondage, are under no obligation to keep the Sabbath.”

If the reader will compare Deut. 5:15 with Deut. 24:17, 18 and Lev. 19:35, 37, he will see that, according to such reasoning we are also free from the obligations of justice and humanity. So galling was the bondage of the Israelites in Egypt, that they could not properly keep the Sabbath, nor obey the dictates of humanity; but when they were free, God required the performance of both these duties.

Eld. H.: “Those who return to the keeping of the Sabbath are like those who, at the present day would exchange their beautiful porcelain and china ware for the pewter service of their grandmothers.”

We like grandma's quaint old pewter set very well. It is substantial. It can't be easily broken.

(Concluded next week.)