THE COMING OF CHRIST AS RELATED TO THE SINNER'S DOOM

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 4, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 19.

Read the full edition

THE COMING OF CHRIST AS RELATED TO THE SINNER'S DOOM.

I know there are those who would fain hope that there may be a second probation for some in an intermediate state between death and the second coming of Christ; but to me, neither science, nor sound reason, nor Scripture affords any good ground for such a hope. Indeed, we have yet to be assured that there is any such ghostly state of consciousness and freedom for human souls, apart from their bodies, as heathen philosophy has conceived of, and as the traditions of the papal church have imposed upon our Protestant theology.
The supreme importance which is given to the probation of this life, the tone of finality which is everywhere employed in the word of God, when speaking of the issues of this life, forbid us to believe that there is any hope for those who go down to the dead unsaved. This is the chief reason why the heathen need the gospel,—the grand motive for giving it to them now, while there is hope, “if by any means we might save some.” Without it, they are perishing. By this word “perishing,” as used in the Scriptures, is not meant that they are doomed to a state of eternal suffering hereafter, but to extinction and utter loss of all life.
No one would have thought of putting any other construction upon such plain Scriptural terms as to die, to perish, to be destroyed, to be punished with everlasting destruction, were it not demanded by the false philosophy of Plato, which has become our traditional theology, that the soul of man cannot die, cannot perish, cannot be destroyed. And then, when the enlightened Christian heart revolts against the shocking injustice of God in consigning to an eternity of misery these wretched mortals to whom no way of escape from their terrible doom has ever been made known, it naturally seeks some way to relieve our Heavenly Father of the dreadful imputation that this traditional dogma casts upon him, and finds relief in the hope of another probation in an intermediate state.
If men would be willing to accept, in the simplicity of their hearts, the plain teaching of the word of God as to the nature and destiny of man, there would be no need of the suggestion of this forlorn hope to justify the ways of God to man. If, instead of twisting it and perverting it to suit the requirements of a heathen philosophy, they would read it as it is, and believe what it says, the goodness, wisdom, and justice of God in his dealings with our fallen race, would need no special pleas or extenuating apologies to commend him to the love and confidence of all.
The children of Adam are represented in the Scriptures as mortal and transitory in their present condition, and this, through no fault of their own, however much it might have been the fault of their progenitor. Though in a state of absolute purity their life on earth might have been endlessly prolonged, it is now cut short, and cut short in mercy. For no sooner had man sinned than he was excluded from the tree of life, lest he should eat and live forever, and so perpetuate his life in sin and misery! Apart from God, without that divine life in his soul which makes it possible or even desirable that he should live forever, he must die, and die utterly. The race of men descended from Adam is a mortal, perishable, transitory race, as truly so as all the orders beneath them in the scale of being. Man, in his present condition, is born a mortal, and he dies as really as every other earthly living thing. He is an earthly creature, and unless he is lifted up, by the grace of God, into another state of being, and endowed with a spiritual life, he must pass away.
This condition primitive, into which every child of Adam is born, does not necessarily imply a desert of punishment, much less of the punishment of eternal misery. That all men may and do become sinners and ill-deserving, according to the light they have, need not be questioned or denied. But all men must die whether they sin or not, and after death the judgment, according to the deeds done in the body.
How many of this mortal race are to be rescued by the grace of God from the death that comes upon all, and made heirs of an eternal life of blessedness; how many are to be cleansed from their own individual sins and saved with an everlasting salvation; how many out of Christian lands, how many out of heathen lands, we will not undertake to guess. When our Lord himself was asked this great question, “Are there few that be saved?” he replied, “Strive to enter in at the strait gate; for many, I say unto you, shall seek to enter in, and shall not be able.” There must, then, be a striving on the part of man, a seeking and a successful seeking, a concurrence of the human with the divine will, in order to salvation.
Neither the Scripture promises, nor our observation of the lives of men, warrant us in believing that the life everlasting will be the final portion of all. That all men—both the good and the bad—will be raised at the last day and judged, believing as we do the testimony of God’s word, we cannot doubt; but those who have no moral fitness for another and a higher life cannot enter into it. The door will be, must be, shut against them. Their lamps will go out in darkness. To perpetuate their miserable lives would be no mercy to them, nor to the saved. “As many as have sinned without law shall also perish without law; and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law.” Those who have lived and sinned in comparative ignorance, shall be beaten with few stripes, and they who have sinned against greater light and knowledge shall be beaten with many stripes. But whether the stripes be many or few, their disappointments, regrets, lamentations, whether great or small, whether prolonged or cut short, must end in the second death, from which there is no resurrection.
When our Lord shall come again, it will not be to proclaim a truce with his enemies, and to make such terms with them as he can. It will not be to arrange for a partition of this world between himself and Satan into two separate kingdoms, that each may henceforth enjoy his own peculiar rights, and reign in their separate spheres forever; nor will he consign them, as irreclaimable subjects, to a penal colony, nor to a prison-house where he may torment them unceasingly and forever. But he will withdraw from them his sustaining power, without which no creature, however high or low, could live for a moment, and let them drop out of being; or he will destroy them with such severity of judgment as justice and mercy shall require.
How long a time may elapse between the coming of Christ in judgment, and the utter extermination of all his enemies; through what scenes of misery they shall pass, and what shall be the precise method and manner of their destruction, we do not now propose to inquire. It is only with the final disposition that is to be made of them that we are now concerned. In regard to this there ought not to be any doubt in the mind of any one who honestly accepts the testimony of the Scriptures. Indeed, there would be none, had not men been taught to accept Satan’s lie, “Ye shall not surely die,” instead of the sure word of God, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die.” “The wages of sin is death.” “Sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death.” “His latter end shall be that he perish forever.” “The day cometh, that shall burn as an oven; and all the proud, yea, and all that do wickedly, shall be stubble; and the day cometh that shall burn them up, saith the Lord of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.” “Who shall be punished with everlasting destruction.” “Whose end is destruction.”
Many of our Lord’s parables are given to teach this very truth,—the utter destruction of the wicked, the complete extinguishment of all life in them, their utter extermination. What else can be meant by the parable of the Draw Net, and the gathering of the good into vessels and the casting of the bad away, when Christ shall come again; or of the Ten Pounds, in which he takes away from those who had misimproved their privileges even that which he had given them, and slays them before his eyes; or of the Rich Fool, whose soul was required of him; or of the Tares, and the gathering of the wicked, like tares, into bundles to be burned at the end of the world; or of the Ten Virgins, and the giving out of the lights of the foolish virgins when the bridegroom comes?
But it is useless to multiply citations on this point. The Scriptures are full of such texts. To quote them all would be to quote a large part of the Bible. There is no doctrine upon which its teachings are more full, positive, and definite than in respect to the destruction of the unsaved at the second coming of Christ. Every variety of figure and form of expression is used, all pointing to the same end. It is said that they “shall perish,” shall “pass away,” “fade away,” “wither,” “be consumed,” “utterly consumed,” “devoured by fire,” “cut down,” “ground to powder,” “burned up,” “plucked up by the roots,” “broken to shivers,” “dashed in pieces,” “cut in sunder,” “put away like dross,” “cast away,” “vanish away like smoke” or “like a dream,” “perish like brutes,” “shall not be,” etc., etc. If there is any doubt on this question, the difficulty is not in the word of God, but in the mind of the reader. If he comes to the Scriptures with the philosophical assumption that man cannot die utterly, cannot perish so as not to be, he is under the necessity of putting some other construction on these passages. He must interpret them to mean something else. In this way the plain word of God has been so mystified and perverted as to seem to teach the very opposite of what it says,—that the unsaved shall not die utterly, shall not perish so as not to be, shall not be consumed, etc., but shall continue to exist and suffer forever. It is quite useless to argue this question on Scriptural grounds, or to cite passages in point, with those who insist on bringing their own unscriptural philosophy to the interpretation of these passages, or rather the misinterpretation of them. Until they will consent to come to a study of this word as those who desire to know what it really teaches, and not as those who would compel it to teach what they may wish, they must remain, in spite of all its plain utterances, like those who are “ever learning, but never able to come to the knowledge of the truth.”—J. H. Pettingell, in Bible Banner.