SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS AND SEVENTH-DAY BAPTISTS

2%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 4, 1880

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 19.

Read the full edition

SEVENTH-DAY ADVENTISTS AND SEVENTH-DAY BAPTISTS.

A REPLY.

BY. ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
My attention having been called to an article in the Sabbath Recorder of Sept. 9, bearing as a title the first portion of the above heading, and purporting to have been written by Eld. Stephen Burdick, it has seemed to me necessary that some of its statements should not be allowed to go unchallenged.
It appears that the article in question is one in a series written to discourage the united and reciprocal action of Seventh-day Baptists and Seventh-day Adventists in the propagation of the important truths which they hold in common. In other words, if I rightly apprehend the situation, Seventh-day Adventists are ready to ignore the minor differences between themselves and the Seventh-day Baptists so far as to both send and receive delegates from the respective Conferences of the two bodies, and otherwise to labor harmoniously, as far as can be consistently done, in presenting the claims of God’s ancient Sabbath upon men at the present time; while the author of the above article, in common with other members of his denomination, is opposed to such an affiliation for such purposes. If the writer had confined himself to a legitimate argument based upon motives of expediency, or drawn his conceptions of duty from the standpoint which he occupies without misrepresenting the doctrines and opinions of Seventh-day Adventists, I should never have responded to his communication, as I fear that in former years, discussion conducted in the temper in which it has been, by certain individuals, has been productive of evil rather than good. But as my own name is introduced in connection with a work written by myself, in such a way as to do injustice not only to me, but also to my brethren, I feel that silence, under the circumstances, would be inexcusable.
The pamphlet which Eld. Burdick undertakes to review, is entitled, “The Position and Work of the True People of God under the Third Angel’s Message.”
It is but just to myself to state that its extreme brevity on the points presented is attributable to the fact that originally the substance of it was employed in a sermon delivered before those who were presumed to be familiar with the main lines of argument which it handles; since they had listened to a series of lectures in which the same had been more fully elaborated. The object of the discourse was to group together in the briefest manner possible, and present as a whole, the combination of the different parts in one sermon; so that, by a connection of eleven propositions, the speaker might be able by this combination of proofs to impress his auditors more forcibly than otherwise could be done with the conviction that they would be safe in coming to the conclusion that Seventh-day Adventists were actually fulfilling the prediction found in Rev. 14:9-12. At the suggestion of one whose judgment in such matters was valued very highly, it was finally agreed that it should be written out and thrown into book form, as has been done. Had the writer had at his command the space which would have been offered by an octavo volume of hundreds of pages, instead of being confined to the limits of a small pamphlet, he could have handled the subject in a manner more elaborate, and, perhaps, more satisfactory to the reader. Be this as it may, however, it is not necessary that I should stop here, either to fortify or to enlarge upon the arguments there adduced, as my reviewer has not so much as attempted to refute one of them.
His effort, manifestly, has been, by representing the conclusions reached in as odious a light as possible, to create a prejudice in the minds of his own denomination against the people who seek for union with them. In doing so, he dexterously passes from the book and the argument therein contained, to Seventh-day Adventists generally and to their doctrines, applying to each the same epithets, and stigmatizing the views of the latter as resting wholly upon inference.
This is a broad assertion, and would have been of greater value in the debate had it been accompanied by fitting illustrations. It is a common trick of disputants to dispose of the views of opponents in this summary manner; but with a man of candor and reflection such a declaration will have but little weight unless substantiated by facts.
As the gentleman has not attempted to do this, it certainly would be impracticable for us to undertake to prove a negative by taking up the views in question, one by one, and showing that they rest upon arguments perfectly conclusive and satisfactory.
Those desiring to know the reasons of our faith are most respectfully referred to the list of our publications, which contains scores of works in which are discussed, in the most exhaustive manner, the various points which we as a people hold. For thirty-six years they have stood the concentrated fire of criticism from the orthodox world, and still it is confidently asserted by their friends that the contest has simply served to root them and ground them in the faith.
Some of the authors of these works are men of whose intellectual capacity our Seventh-day Baptist friends have spoken in words of the highest commendation.
To their works on the Sabbath question, especially, the Seventh-day Baptists are in the habit of appealing with great confidence, applauding their logic and justifying the soundness of their conclusions.
In the matter of baptism, also, in which they agree with Seventh-day Baptists, we think it will be agreed by the writer that they have argued correctly and well.
This being true, we submit that it is not a little singular that men, who, when discussing views in harmony with Seventh-day Baptists, confessedly manifest such soundness of judgment in reaching their decisions, should change their habits of thought and methods of reasoning so suddenly and so completely when they advance to the defense of propositions out of joint with the faith of Seventh-day Baptists. In other words, that while in everything which relates to what we know as peculiarly Seventh-day Adventist views they should be so far metamorphosed that—whereas in other matters they were in the habit of drawing logical conclusions—they should, in these, content themselves with resting their faith upon mere inference.
What makes the charge the less plausible to our mind, is the fact that they are moved by no earthly consideration of interest or profit in holding on to the doctrines to which they cling and for which they argue; but, on the contrary, that it would be every way for their temporal interests to let go of them if false.
This being true, having both the conceded ability to discriminate, and considerations of personal welfare to induce them so to do, is it not possible that they may, after all, be justified in their course by a logic which, though sound in itself, the gentleman has failed to recognize? In other words, may it not be that he either misapprehends the nature of the line of argument upon which they rely, or that partisan zeal has rendered him incapable of doing them justice?
We do not wish to be understood by this that none of their opinions are in any way supported by inference. Inferences, when drawn from conceded facts, in a proper manner, are legitimate and conclusive.
If the gentleman will examine his own creed, he will doubtless find that, without resort to inference under any circumstances, it would be very difficult for him to offer in its behalf a satisfactory defense. What we insist on is simply that Seventh-day Adventists aim to employ inference only when they can do so with the most perfect propriety and logical safety.
Having said thus much in reference to the strictures offered in the article on the reasoning of Seventh-day Adventists in general, I come now to those which relate to the book written by myself.
Eld. B. starts out with the proposition that Seventh-day Baptists claim for themselves no special mission. So far, so good. After this concession, it will not, at least, be claimed that the author of “Position and Work” did that denomination any injustice in asserting, as he did, that they did not lay claim to such an honor. It will also be admitted that unless the reasoning was unsound by which he attempted to show that those who give the third angel’s message “will understand their mission,” Seventh-day Baptists cannot do the work in question. But this my reviewer has not attempted to do, and hence I need not reconsider its propositions.
The second proposition of Eld. B. is to the effect that Seventh-day Adventists “claim for themselves a special place and mission in the fulfillment of prophecy.”
In this he is correct. After having made the proposition, he proceeds to substantiate it by appealing to the pamphlet entitled, “Position and Work,” calling attention to the fact that it contains eleven propositions to prove the point in question.
These propositions he enumerates, one by one, with substantial accuracy; but when he comes to examine them individually, he makes it manifest that he has utterly failed to comprehend the scope of the argument which he is criticising. I say, Failed to comprehend; for I should dislike to attribute to him an intentional misrepresentation of the same.
To illustrate: The point which the author of “Position and Work” laid all stress upon, was that any people claiming to do the work in question must necessarily fulfill all of the eleven specifications brought to view. He distinctly stated that it would not be enough for them to fulfill one or even ten, in order to substantiate their claim to the honor of giving the third angel’s message; but, that their failure to meet a single specification would invalidate their claims.
The reader will perceive, therefore, that the argument, as employed, was cumulative in its nature, and only complete when fully made out; that is to say, that whereas the fulfillment of the eleven requirements would entitle the class thus fulfilling them to a decision in their favor, that decision could only be given after they had been tested on all of the eleven points, and found to meet the requirements of the case.
After having laid this basis for the proofs, and after having tested the church in the times of the apostles, the church in the times of Martin Luther, the orthodox churches of our own days, also the Seventh-day Baptists, the Mormons, and the Jews of the present time, and having found that they all failed in several particulars, he then applied the test to Seventh-day Adventists. In doing so he distinctly declared that if they should come short in any one of the eleven requirements, they, like the rest, should be made to stand to one side.
Having made the test, and applied the measuring-rod in the eleven different ways specified, and having found that they, unlike the rest, met all of the eleven demands of the prophecy, he concluded that they must be the people whom the Revelator had in view.
Now let us see how his reviewer represents this procedure. Taking up the points, one by one, he exactly reverses the order of our argument, and intimates that our conclusions are drawn after each individual proposition.
For example: He says on the first point, “They must understand their mission.” “Inference involved: The Seventh-day Adventists are ‘the true people of God’ described in Rev. 14:12, because they proclaim to the world no mere human opinions or theories, but, on the contrary, ‘have been raised up of God . . . for the purpose of giving to men the last message of mercy.’”
The reader will perceive that Seventh-day Adventists are represented here as claiming in the work in question that they were the true people of God who are giving the third angel’s message, and that they claim this independently of any merely human theory.
Now this deduction is false in two particulars: 1. The book in question nowhere bases any such claims upon the simple fact that they fulfill that “one” specification, independently of the rest; 2. It nowhere argues that their claim to the honor depends upon any theory which is the result of special divine revelation, or which is not based purely upon conclusions drawn from the word of God, as the result of logical deductions made therefrom. On the contrary, it enters into a careful examination of the subject, and labors hard to prove that all their claims are of such a nature that they can be tested by any man who will carefully weigh the arguments adduced.
Proposition 2: “They must be, in the fullest sense of the word, followers of Christ.” “Inference: Seventh-day Adventists are the true people of God, because they alone are, in the fullest sense of the word, followers of Christ.”
Here, again, an effort is made to make us urge that Seventh-day Adventists regard themselves as, in a sense higher than that known to others, the followers of Christ. For such a conclusion there is not the slightest authority to be found in the discussion of the proposition in question in the pamphlet named. All that is insisted is simply that they, while meeting the other ten specifications, also meet the one which requires that those who give the message should be “Christians.”
This claim was not urged in any invidious sense, since the writer freely acknowledged that Christians are found outside of the Seventh-day Adventist denomination. Nay, more; it is well known to those acquainted with the faith of that denomination, that the message found in the eighteenth chapter of Revelation, “Come out of her, my people,” applies—as understood by them—to a future event, and, accordingly, that God not only has a people at the present time among the orthodox churches, but, also, that many of them remain even in the bosom of the Romish Church.
Perhaps the gentleman’s liberality will hardly extend beyond this. Perhaps, also, it will enable the reader to see the injustice of an inference so skillfully worded as to make it appear that we arrogate to ourselves a piety higher than that possessed by anybody else.
Should the reader wish to investigate the point farther, he will find by appealing to Proposition No. 2, p. 50, as applied to Seventh-day Adventists, that our effort was simply to show that they were Christians in the sense that they receive the teachings of the New Testament, in contra-distinction from the Jews, who receive merely those of the Old Testament, and reject Christ.
Proposition 3: “They must obey the ten commandments.” The inference which the gentleman says that we draw from this proposition is as follows: “Seventh-day Adventists are God’s true people, because they alone obey the ten commandments.”
We hardly know what language to employ in order to do justice to so grave a perversion of our words, without appearing to be too severe.
We cannot bring ourselves to believe that the gentleman intentionally misrepresented what we said; but the simple fact is, we declared the very reverse of what he states. Please remember that he charges us with saying that Seventh-day Adventists alone keep the commandments of God.
Now read the following, which was spoken of Seventh-day Baptists, as found in “Position and Work,” p. 48: “That they [i. e., Seventh-day Baptists] keep the commandments of God, it affords us great pleasure to say is undeniably true; also that they accept the teachings of the New Testament, or the faith of Jesus, as they understand it.” Note again, on p. 46, the following: “As we would not pass by any, let us consider the case of the Hebrews. They are endeavoring to keep the commandments of God, it may be; and it is possible that they are conscientiously observing his Sabbath.”
The reader will perceive that in the foregoing citations is found a complete refutation of the charge made. Instead of saying that Seventh-day Adventists alone keep the commandments of God, we do, in the most unequivocal terms, recognize the fact that Seventh-day Baptists are also doing so.
It will also be noted that, whereas in speaking of the Hebrews a doubt is implied in the use of the words, “it may be,” because of the relation which they sustain to Christianity, which renders it difficult, if not impossible, for them to keep the commandments in the higher sense of the term, there is no such reservation made in the case of our Seventh-day Baptist friends; their claims to that honor being acknowledged in the fullest manner.
We leave the reader to decide whether great injustice has not been done us by our reviewer, in representing us as he has in this matter. The reason we object so strongly to the course pursued is, that—as every intelligent man knows—the perversion of the facts was of such a nature that—whether the gentleman intended it or not—it was calculated to create a strong prejudice in the minds of the members of his own denomination against Seventh-day Adventists. That prejudice might have served a purpose in preventing the co-operation of the two bodies in the work of God; but in the end it would have recoiled upon those who had unjustly harbored it.
(Concluded next week.)