The Sabbath Question

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 26, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 5.

Read the full edition

The Sabbath Question.

(Concluded.)
RELIGION is the only potency which has ever shown itself adequate to improve men. The preaching of God’s word and of God’s will has renovated human hearts, and renewed the face of society; it has succeeded when every other agency has failed; it is doing this in unnumbered instances at the present day; and if we study the facts either of human nature or of history, we are warranted to expect help and success in the future from this and from no other source. Let us, therefore, light our torches at the sun, and while we recognize the Sabbath as a civil institution full of wisdom and beneficence, and therefore to be asserted by all the authority of the State, and deduce it also as a moral obligation to be urged with all the force the conscience can bring, yet as civil institutions no more perpetuate than they produce themselves, and as the sense of moral obligation is awakened and kept alive only by some religious quickening, let us not forget that the Sabbath, in order to be widely diffused and permanent, must come clothed with the power and crowned with the authority of God’s legislation. I think we shall find that the weakening of the hold of the Sabbath upon men is just in proportion to the weakening of their convictions of its divine authority.
Is it true, then, that we have such a command, a universal and perpetual command, of God that we recognize and reverence this day?
Certainly such would seem to be the case at the first view. The command to “remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy” stands in a code of which all the rest has confessedly a universal and perpetual obligation. Like the other nine commandments, this was all written by the finger of God, and was with them the first direct proclamation of the God of Abraham, of Isaac, and of Jacob to his chosen people through whom all the families of the earth should be blessed. There is nothing in the form or the terms of this command which indicates any narrower application or more limited authority than belongs to the others with which it is associated. It constitutes with them the testimony—thus termed by God himself—or witness, of the divine will. We call it one of the ten commandments, but it is noticeable that they are not thus termed in Scripture. There, whenever they are spoken of together, whether in the Old Testament or in the New, they are called the ten words, a distinction quite remarkable. The word of God, the word of the Lord, expresses not simply a particular command, but rather announces the abiding source of all commands. The commands may often have only a local and temporary application, while the word of the Lord standeth forever. God himself, in his utterances to Moses, distinguishes between these words and the judgments of particular statutes which he commissions his servants to declare to his people. It is these ten words, and not the accompanying statutes, which are written by the finger of God on the tables of stone, and which are sacredly preserved in the ark, called the ark of the covenant because it bears the record of this testimony of God’s righteous will, the announcement of which to his people is God’s covenant with them. God’s work in his kingdom of grace is thus analogous to his work in his kingdom of nature; the individual rests upon the species; the particular is upheld by the universal; the laws which are of local application, which belong to a time and a people, are first grounded on a law world-wide and eternal.
These considerations are not doubted, so far as I know, respecting any one of the so-called ten commandments, excepting the fourth. All the others are admitted to be of perpetual and universal obligation, but this, it is said, is Jewish and transitory; all the others carry with them the evidence of their universality in their own statement, but this, it is said, is a positive institution whose ground is not seen by the natural conscience; all the others have a substantial existence which neither the old dispensation could constitute nor the new change, but this is regarded as only the shadow of good things to come, the body of which is Christ. These views are held by many wise and excellent men, and demand our careful attention.
Certainly the reasons for refusing to one of these commandments the unlimited sway which confessedly belongs to all the rest should be so clear as to make it impossible either to mistake or to deny them. But this is far from being the case. When it is said that the Sabbath is only a Hebrew institution, it seems to be forgotten that the Hebrew Sabbath was not alone the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, but a particular and local Sabbath, based upon and representing the general provisions which the fourth commandment contains, but characterized by particular observances and enforced by special penalties, none of which are mentioned in, and all of which are independent of, the commandment itself. These particular observances, these special statutes and penalties, were doubtless wise for the Hebrews, for God enjoined them; but they are not, therefore, wise for all men, and these might all disappear as a local and transient structure whose broad foundation stands unchanged and may be built upon forever. Whatever may be said, therefore, about the Hebrew Sabbath, whether it abides still for them or is done away for them and for all men, does not affect at all the question of the perpetual validity and obligation of the fourth commandment. Again, when it is said that the fourth commandment is not a universal and perpetual injunction, because the Sabbath is only a positive institution and contains no universal precept, we are led to inquire, What is a universal precept? It is not necessary that it be universally acknowledged in order to be universally obligatory. It may be true and binding upon all men, and yet only evidently true to some. It may shine with a resplendent and self-revealing light, while there may be blurred or blinded eyes by whom it is not seen. The light shineth in darkness and the darkness comprehendeth it not; but this is not because the light is not light, but because the darkness is darkness. We must not say, therefore, that the fourth commandment contains no universal precept because we cannot see the ground on which the Sabbath rests, as we can see the ground for prohibiting murder, adultery, and theft. It is possible, to say the least, that to other intelligences the original basis of the Sabbath may be just as clear and just as self-evident, and therefore just as universal, as is the basis of chastity and honesty and truthfulness. A self-evident truth is not thereby instantaneously evident. All the truths of mathematics are self-evident, and yet they are not seen until the eye has been opened and taught to see. I do not suppose that a child in his earliest intelligence recognizes the obligations of the fifth commandment any more than some men recognize those of the fourth; but the obligations are there, whether the child recognizes them or not, and would be there, whether the commandment should announce them or not. I think it is quite possible that there may be many persons in the world, very ignorant persons doubtless, but yet persons who have never thought of the obligations of any of the ten commandments, and who would never think of them till they were taught and trained. Now if it be really better for mankind, as wise men unitedly affirm, that the daily routine of human toil should be interrupted by periods of rest from labor, if it be wise that the body have special times to rest from labor, and the spirit special times to give itself to worship, then a certain length and frequency of such periods is better than another; there is a wise division of such seasons, which to a vision sufficiently broad and clear must be just as evident and just as necessary as is the eternal requisition, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” The distinction between a positive institution and a moral precept, as though the one were grounded on an arbitrary enactment, and the other rested on absolute righteousness, cannot in the least be maintained in reference
to anything which God has enjoined. He does nothing arbitrarily. All his ways are perfect. He sees the eternal and unchanging reason for them all, and could his subjects come to see his statutes in the light in which he must ever behold them, the distinctions which they now make between a law whose reason is apparent and a law whose reason is hid in the will of the Lawgiver would forever disappear.
But it is surprising to me that the reason for the fourth commandment, the reason clearly stated in the commandment itself, is so greatly ignored, or at least is brought forward with so little prominence, in the discussion of the Sabbath question: “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day.” Here is a reason divinely announced for the divine injunction, “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy;” and if we only note this reason until we see its divine and glorious significance, I think we can never after doubt the universality or the perpetuity of the injunction to which it is attached. What does it mean, then, when it says God rested from his work, and therefore commanded man to rest? Man becomes weary from his labor and needs rest for his refreshment; but surely this is not true of God. He has wasted no power in his work which he needs rest to restore; and while man may find his rest a recreation from which he rises with new energy to his work, and while this may make it wise, must make it wise, for him to have his stated times for rest, this is only incidental, and does not reach at all the high significance of the reason which requires him to rest because God rests. God rests because he is a spirit, and as a spirit finds completeness in his work. Nature never rests; nature never is complete. From day to night, from night to day, swifter than a weaver’s shuttle, bringing life to death and death to life again, nature never finds a beginning which is not an end, nor an end which is not a beginning. “One generation passeth away, and another generation cometh; the sun also ariseth and the sun goeth down, and hasteth to the place where he arose. The wind goeth toward the south, and turneth about unto the north; it whirleth about continually, and the wind returneth again according to his circuits.” “Is there anything whereof it may be said, See, this is new?” Such is the ever-recurring question of nature, to which the ever-recurring answer of nature must be: “The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be, and that which is done is that which shall be done, and there is no new thing under the sun.” But the answer of the supernatural, of the spiritual, is: “Behold, I make all things new.” The spiritual originates and consummates, begins and finishes, its work; and it is the announcement of himself as spiritual and supernatural when the Creator of the heavens and the earth beholds his work that it is good, and rests in the completeness of what he has done; rests not because he is weary, but because his work is worthy of him and needs no further repetition. There is thus something sublime in the primeval record: “Thus the heavens and the earth were finished, and all the host of them. And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made, and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it, because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.” And therefore it is meet that man made in the image of God should remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy, should perpetually hallow and sanctify the day whose announcement is God’s witness to himself as spiritual and supernatural, and whose keeping is man’s witness that he is supernatural and spiritual too. That the Sabbath is a day of rest from bodily labor, wherein man on his natural side finds rest and refreshment, is abundantly true; but this is only incidental, is but the means whereby man rises to his true spirituality and rejoices in communion with the Father of spirits. This is the reason for the Sabbath, and the law remains while the reason remains. Instead of the fourth commandment announcing what is sometimes called a merely positive institution arbitrarily enjoined, the true view shows us in this commandment the very ground on which the application of all the others rests. The commandments are not given to nature, but only to spirit. They have no significance save to the free will, and it is only in this fourth commandment that the free will implied in all the rest is explicitly declared,—the free will of Him who made the heavens and the earth, and in whose image man was made.
We learn from the record that the Sabbath was observed by the children of Israel before the ten commandments were given. “To-morrow,” says Moses (Ex. 16:23), “is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord;” and again (verse 26), “The seventh day is the Sabbath;” and once more (verse 29), “The Lord hath given you the Sabbath;” and still further (verse 30), “So the people rested on the seventh day.” It is certainly remarkable that this is the only matter in the ten commandments which Moses lays before the children of Israel before the ten commandments were given; but this is not strange if the fourth commandment contains, as I think it does, the reason which justifies all the rest. The Sabbath, thus, is not a new institution commanded from Mount Sinai, but one already known, which they are solemnly enjoined to remember. If the act of remembrance points backward to the beginnings of the human generations, the command to remember points as truly forward to their end.
I think we are warranted to say from all this that the fourth commandment is at least as universal in its obligations as any of the ten, and that while there was a Jewish law of the Sabbath which was local, and which has passed away, this was wholly accessory to the fourth commandment and dependent thereupon, while the fourth commandment is as independent of it as are the second and fifth and sixth and seventh and eighth and ninth commandments independent of the particular Jewish laws against idolatry and disobedience to parents and murder and adultery and theft and false-witness.
Is there now anything in the New Testament which would set this doctrine of the Old Testament respecting the Sabbath in any different light? In the Old-Testament representation the Sabbath appears as a blessing. The rest from labor which it enjoined was a privilege which all were to enjoy. “In it thou shalt not do any work,” etc. This not only was a privilege, but was recognized as such by the early keepers of the Sabbath, and is now recognized as such by all who carefully contemplate it, even by those who look no farther than its physical and natural relations. It would be strange, therefore, if the new dispensation with its larger blessings were to abridge, or do away with, any of the blessings of the old.
In studying the New Testament, it is quite evident that the true doctrine of the Sabbath was exceedingly important in our Lord’s eyes, as we see from the prominence with which he brings it forward, both in his works and his words. I need not note the points, sufficiently familiar, which illustrate this. But in them all two truths stand out with great distinctness, and together constitute Christ’s full teaching in this matter. The first is that the Jewish attachments to the Sabbath were largely corruptions and perversions, which not only might be disregarded, but which should be set aside; and the second is that the Sabbath itself is quite distinct from Jewish observances, and has a ground and meaning quite independent of these. When he says, “The Sabbath was made [i. e., become] for man,” I do not see how we can avoid the conclusion that he is here looking at a universal fitness of the Sabbath for a universal human need; and when he says, in justification of his work of healing done upon the Sabbath day, “My Father worketh hitherto, and I work,” it seems equally clear that he is here placing the Sabbath again upon its original grounds in God’s work, which, complete as creation, continues also as a preserving energy, which is at the same time complete. Because the Sabbath is made for man, the Son of man, he in whom manhood is truly reproduced, the Divine Man is Lord of the Sabbath day whose utterances respecting it admit of no appeal, and must be for all men. The more one ponders on the prominence of the Sabbath in the teachings and the life of Christ, and the more one penetrates to the meaning of this institution as illustrated by Christ’s words and his example, the greater, I think, must be his sense both of its importance and its universality. Christ’s teachings here as elsewhere come before us in large outline. They suggest rules rather than announce them. But their suggestions are seeds which in a good soil will bear their fruit after their kind, and in a healthy soul will formulate themselves in rules for the practical observance of the day, indicative both of its sacredness and its beneficence. . . .
It is sometimes said that as in the gospel dispensation we are not under law but under grace, therefore the law can no more be obligatory upon us, and that it is to forget the liberty wherewith Christ maketh us free and be entangled again with the yoke of bondage, when we insist upon commandments as rules of life. Our actions should be prompted, it is said, by the inner behest of the Spirit, and to be controlled by laws and commandments is to fall from grace. There is a certain truth in this, enough to make it plausible and give it currency with some minds, but there is also a certain ignoring of the truth. To those who are under the gospel, in whom its spirit lives, the law has become translated into a life, its external obligation has become an inner inspiration; but are its obligations thereby relaxed? has it thereby any the less constraint? Is the law against theft any the less a law or any the less obligatory where people are perfectly honest through an inner inspiration than where they are only kept from theft by the sheer force of the law? The law has become translated into a life, but has it lost its authority in the process? Nay, has it not rather gained in authority, as the command of a father grows in its constraining force in exact proportion to the growing love and reverence of his child? I think we fall into a very serious error when we argue that the law of commandments has lost its force in the gospel. “Stand fast,” says Paul, “in the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free;” but we are not to forget that liberty is not a disregard of law, but an obedience to the law; the bondage has become changed to freedom, not by a change of the law, but by the changed motive for obedience to the law. The law is truth, and it cannot, therefore, be set aside; the law is right, and it must therefore be always obligatory. There is the same law in the old dispensation and the new, and precisely the same obedience thereto is required in both. The difference is that through the new motive now brought in, the obedience which failed before is now secured. This is precisely as Paul argues in the Epistle to the Romans: “For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh, that the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.” The law requiring righteousness is not relaxed, but is rather intensified in the gospel, as argues the author of the Epistle to the Hebrews: “For if the word spoken by angels [i. e., the law given from Mount Sinai] was steadfast, and every transgression and disobedience received its just recompense of reward, how shall we escape if we neglect so great salvation, which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord?” “I came not to destroy the law,” said He who was both Lord and Christ, “I came not to destroy, but to fulfill.” The love to the Lawgiver with which the grace of God in the gospel inspires us, and which transforms the commandments of God into divine benedictions, leads the soul to a loyal devotion whose depth and breadth and intensity elevate and glorify, as not before, the authority of the law. “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” We must come back, therefore, to the original ground of the Sabbath; and here the presentation of its claims may rest—as a divine institution, made for man, made because the unmade Wisdom saw its fitness for man’s need, made as a witness that the Creator of the heavens and the earth is a spirit, and made for man as a testimony also to his own spirituality. The law remains while the reason remains.—
J. H. Seelye, A. M. (President of Amherst College), in Princeton Review.