AdventAI

How a Jew Looks at It.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 5., July 26, 1881

Mr. H. P. Mendes, a Jewish divine, preached at the Nineteenth Street Synagogue, New York City, May 14, a sermon on “The Christian Sabbath,” which was published in the N. Y. Herald. The concluding portion of his remarks, as reported, we give below. If Sunday-keepers do not wince a little under the sting of this Jewish lash, their sensibilities are more obtuse than one would suppose. Mr. Mendes examined the six texts principally relied on to prove the first-day Sabbath, after which the report continues:—

To sum up, there is not a single instance in the New Testament that Sunday, in the time of the apostles, was specially used as a prayer day; and, as Ridgley declares, “We do not find that the seventh-day Sabbath was abolished by positive law.” The New Testament speaks continually of the Sabbath of the Jews, or seventh-day Sabbath, but never of its abolition, or of the institution of the Sunday Sabbath. With regard to the directions sent to the Gentiles by the apostles, to argue that they are not to keep the Sabbath because the apostles did not include it in their list of duties, would be an argument against their keeping Sunday, for Sunday is not in the list or anywhere commanded, while as a matter of fact, they, the Gentiles, do not even abstain from what the apostles did direct.

Bishop Taylor “affirms without qualification that the primitive church kept both the Sabbath and the Sunday until the time of the Laodicean Council (A. D. 364), and almost in everything made them equal; and therefore did not esteem the Sunday to be substituted in place of an obliterated Sabbath, but a feast celebrated by great reason and perpetual consent, without precept or necessary heavenly injunction.”

Now the only ground for changing the Sabbath from the seventh to any other day that the Christians can assume, is that it was done by apostolic direction. But is it likely that the Christian converts would for three hundred and sixty-four years keep two days, if they knew that apostolic direction existed for the transfer of the seventh day to Sunday? The seventh-day Sabbath was allowed to be observed by Christians in the apostolic age; and the strongest indication imaginable, short of a direct historical statement, exists that in the early ages of the church the alleged transference of the Sabbath from the seventh day of the week to the first was unknown. There is no historical evidence that the apostles even hinted at instituting a first-day Sabbath.

If it was instituted in honor, as Justin Martyr observes, of the alleged rising of the Nazarene from the dead, then the reason is very insufficient, because if the Nazarene is to be considered as a man, as the Unitarians regard him, then it is impious to honor a man at the expense of Him who ordained the Sabbath at Sinai. If he is to be considered as a God, as the Son in the Trinity, as other Christians regard him, then it is absurd to honor the Son at the expense of the Father. If both days were still sanctified, it would be comprehensible; but to abolish the day which the Father instituted, and replace it by a day which the Son did not institute, and to which he certainly would have objected as destroying a command of that law he declared he had come to fulfill, is a remarkable instance of the aberration of the human intellect in the sphere of religion, where logic, clear thought, and soundness are most to be desired.