WHERE WAS THE “THINK”?

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 2, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 6.

Read the full edition

WHERE WAS THE “THINK”?

BY E. LANPHEAR.
Many of our orthodox friends hold that the thoughts emanate from the soul, or spirit; or that “the think” is the soul. If this be the case, men often live without a soul; for often men, from a diseased brain, lose their mind for months or years, and on recovery, their thoughts come again; and in fact every man’s mind and thoughts leave him when all of the organs of the brain are asleep. Does any one deny this assertion? If so, let him rise and tell us what his thoughts were during the night, when he dropped asleep at 10 o’clock, and only awoke when the servant girl rang the bell for breakfast. Or will he tell us where “the think” was in the following cases?
Several years ago a neighbor of mine, whose business was threshing, was setting the machine, when the wagon started. The motion loosened the bar that held the machine, and it violently struck him on the head, knocking him to the ground insensible, and breaking his skull; and he was taken up for dead. As he saw the wheels of the wagon begin to move, he commenced to say, “Chock the wheels;” but the bar struck him before he closed the sentence. He was removed to his home after his breath was restored. His case seemed a hopeless one. He lay in this unconscious condition for four days, the attending doctors dressing the wound as best they could. Fortunately, on the fourth day, as the doctor was washing and probing, he chanced to pull on the hair a little, when the sunken skull arose to its original position, relieving the pressure upon the brain. In an instant he finished the sentence, “Chock the wheels,” which he was speaking when the bar struck him. He is a well man to-day, and will tell you that he knew nothing of the time that elapsed or what took place during the interval. The spirit, or breath of life, was in him; and the soul-life was there; but where was the “think”? Was it not crushed from the brain, from whence all thought emanates?
Another case in point: Another neighbor that has lived one block from me for the last twelve years died a short time since. About four years ago he was taken suddenly ill, the brain being somewhat affected, and his mind fluctuating more or less day by day. He became dropical, and it was decided that he was afflicted with softening of the brain. The man’s mind gradually faded out, and during the last part of his life there was no more appearance of thought or knowledge of being about him than about a log. He breathed the breath of life all this time, and must have been a living soul. But where were the thoughts? They had passed away, the brain not having power to act. The science of phrenology proves this, and common sense and observation sanction it, church orthodoxy and heathen tradition to the contrary, notwithstanding.
Another case: A girl ten years of age residing in Jefferson Co., N. Y., fell, injuring the spine and affecting the brain. For several years she was unconscious; and all this time was fed with liquids from a spoon. Physician after physician was called, but seemingly to no purpose. Finally, Dr. Maxson, now living in Syracuse, was called. Under his treatment she was restored to health and consciousness, and is now a woman, and has a family of her own. She claims that she had no consciousness during those years; and, in fact, had to learn her alphabet again, like a child, after her recovery. The soul, spirit, or life was there; but where was the power of thought?
If the soul, or spirit, is the seat of thought, why did they not act in these cases, and thousands of others that come under our observation? Let heathen theology rise and explain.