Thinkers Think Thoughts

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 2, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 6.

Read the full edition

Thinkers Think Thoughts.

So it was stated in the old elementary spelling-book. But there is a fallacious argument based on the identity of thoughts and thinkers. Assuming the very point they attempt to prove, namely, that immaterial thoughts can proceed only from an immaterial entity dwelling in the body and independent of it, they imagine the point is proved when they make it appear that thoughts are immaterial; as if thoughts think, or produce themselves! It is therefore inferred that thoughts are not dependent on bodily organization; but, being the product of an immaterial entity, they must continue to eternity, though the body be returned to dust. All this in contradiction of the facts of the experience of thousands whose thoughts have been suspended, so that they were not conscious of life and being for days and weeks.
Our friends forget to apply their logic to other living creatures. The thoughts of a horse or of a dog are equally immaterial. But does this prove that they possess an immaterial entity, and consequently must have a conscious existence as long as eternity endures? If their thoughts proceed from a living organization, why may not man's. R. F. C.