AdventAI

The Decay of Justice.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 8., February 22, 1881

No feature of modern society, especially in this country, is more alarming than that indicated by the title of this article. The decay has not begun at the top. Our courts of justice have maintained to a remarkable degree their supremacy and purity, and are still the safeguard of society. Even an elective judiciary, which was regarded by many with grave apprehension, has not realized their fears. Very rarely in the history of our courts has a judge been suspected of rendering a corrupt judgment, as rarely perhaps as in any country of the world. The evil is lower down in the framework of society,—in the people themselves,—but it is all the more alarming on that account. As they are the foundation of power, the institutions of the country sooner or later become assimilated to them in character.

It must be evident to all persons of the least observation that there has been growing up among us, of late years, a sentiment in regard to crime, and a sentimentality in regard to criminals, which is very different from that of our fathers, and which is very different from that which has prevailed among the most enlightened nations. It is claimed to be an advance, but the advance is downward. In a series of articles recently published in one of our leading journals, the object of which was to advocate self-government in schools in place of government by the master, the writer, after propounding his theory and giving some account of its working, stated its substance in the following parenthesis:—

“I ought, perhaps, to explain that I have tried to get out of the habit of using such terms as punishment or penalty, and to substitute the words dose or medicine.”

This sentence contains the gist of the false system of morals and of government which is affecting modern society, and which threatens to sap its very foundations. A large part of the community are “trying to get out of the habit” of recognizing the distinction between right and wrong, and to shake off the consciousness that under the government of God there is a penalty; and that under every righteous human government there should be punishment, actual punishment, for wrong-doing. The modern theory is that sin is not sin, but disease; that crime is not crime, but misfortune; that evil doers, including the most violent and dangerous of criminals, are not to be regarded as guilty, but simply as objects of commiseration.

According to this theory, justice is a figment, and penalty and punishment have no place in the vocabulary of those who hold it. And this is not mere theory; it is rapidly becoming the basis of action with many who bear the name of philanthropists and with many more who act under their leadership. If such ideas were confined to magazines or pamphlets or radical conventions, there would be less ground of apprehension, but unfortunately the social and criminal history of the last few years shows that these dangerous sentiments have been reduced to practice. When some shocking crime is committed, the public mind is instinctively shocked; but no sooner is the perpetrator of the crime arrested and in the way of being brought to punishment, than popular sympathy for the criminal manifests itself. The crime and the victim are speedily forgotten; outraged society, which demands protection against the repetition of such deeds, is lost sight of; the criminal is put into the position of an unfortunate hero battling against cruel and offensive laws, from the severity of which he must be rescued; pseudo-philanthropists, men and women, visit him in his prison and load him with their attentions, not for the purpose of impressing him with a sense of his guilt and bringing him to repentance, but with the effect, if not the intention, of making him feel that he is an innocent and injured sufferer. And every possible plea is resorted to in order to secure his acquittal and release without any regard to his desert of punishment.

When a criminal is convicted, no matter what his crime may be, the tide of popular sympathy rises higher, and if the offense be a capital one, the whole community is stirred by the efforts made to prevent the execution of his sentence, and when all other means fail, the executive is persecuted with entreaties and threats, to secure a pardon or commutation of his punishment with the hope of ultimate release. This is no exaggeration, but a simple statement of facts that have been repeated over and over again within the last few years, and sometimes with a shocking disregard of decency as well as justice.

As a part of the same system, the discipline of our prisons has been made to conform to the new theory of justice, and there are many who, if it were in their power, would convert these places of punishment into luxurious hotels for the comfortable accommodation of the unfortunates who are sent to them. The chief promoters of this change in popular sentiment are not believers in the Christian religion, though some profess to derive their views from the gospel. The word of God nowhere countenances such an obliteration of the distinction between right-doing and wrong-doing. The whole Bible is founded upon this eternal distinction. “Justice and judgment” are declared to be “the habitation” of God’s throne. The greatest manifestation of God’s mercy ever made, that which includes all others, the gift of his Son to be the Saviour of the world, only enforces the claims of justice. He pardons sinners by providing a substitute. “The Lord hath laid on Him the iniquity of us all, the chastisement of our peace was upon him, and with his stripes we are healed.” There is nothing in the precepts of the gospel which requires us to treat those who have committed crimes against society as if they were innocent, or to shield them from deserved punishment. We may not cherish vindictive feelings toward any; but the New Testament, as well as the Old, teaches that rulers are ordained of God “for the punishment of evil doers and for the praise of them that do well.”

If human society is to endure in an organized form, and if human life and property and happiness are to be protected instead of being more and more imperiled, we must cherish in the minds of the community a stricter, sterner sense of justice. We would not have any efforts toward the reformation of criminals relaxed, but we would have them based on a different theory from that which regards them simply as unfortunates. They should be made sensible that they are offenders not only against their own higher nature and their own best interests, but against society and against God.—New York Observer.