AdventAI

Religious Liberty.

By D. E. Maxson

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 18., May 3, 1881

An address delivered in Assembly Hall at Harrisburg, Pa., March 17, 1881, by D. E. Maxson, D. D., Seventh-day Baptist.

Gentlemen, Legislators of Pennsylvania: We have not asked this audience that we may parade our virtues, as a religious denomination, for we lay claim to no especial excellences of Christian character, such as to distinguish us from our brethren of other denominations, and such as we do not cheerfully concede to them. We have not asked you to hear us that we may proselyte you to our doctrines; for while we hold to the tenets of our order with conscientious conviction that they are based in the immutable word of God, and while we fearlessly submit them to the closest scrutiny and to the severest tests of honest investigation, and while we do not

“Spurn the badges our fathers have worn, Nor beg the world’s pardon for having been born,”

we do not the less accord to all who may differ with us, the same honesty of convictions that we claim for ourselves, and the same right to hold them and crystallize them into their life, as we claim for ourselves. “With charity for all, and malice toward none,” we accept the open field of religious belief and Christian culture our country offers us, and claim so much of it for ourselves as we can occupy and improve without infringement of the equal rights of our neighbors. Most cheerfully do we concede that other Christians have as good right to differ with us as we with them. Neither we nor they may honorably hold religious dogmas by the feeble tenure of prejudice or precedent in a country like ours, nor by whatever tenure one man or sect of men may hold their religious belief, may they honorably force them upon others by pains and penalties, or in the least infringe the equal rights of other men and sects of men to their opinions and practices. It is because this equal right on the field of religious belief and Christian culture has been denied us, and we have been and still are suffering pains and penalties for the exercise of our rights of conscience and religion, in the proud old Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the Keystone State of our Republic, that we have asked to be heard.

There is upon the statute books of this State, an ordinance, passed in 1794, making it a penal offense to engage in certain kinds of manual labor upon the first day of the week, commonly called Sunday. Under the provisions of this ordinance, action has been had against Daniel C. Waldo, a member of the Seventh-day Baptist church of Cussewago, in Crawford county, this State, and we have humbly petitioned you, honorable legislature, to so amend this act as to exempt from its penal provisions all persons who observe the seventh day of the week for the Sabbath. We ask this exemption for reasons following:—

  1. The act is in contravention of time-honored and well-established principles of jurisprudence and precepts of law.
  2. The act is in palpable contradiction to the genius and spirit of our American institutions.
  3. The act is opposed to both the spirit and letter of the Constitution of the United States; and,
  4. The act is opposed to the spirit and the genius upon which the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania was founded.

In defense of these several propositions, I shall indulge in no far-fetched inferences, but shall rely upon authorities old as jurisprudence itself, and accepted wherever law is intelligently made and administered. If I shall establish these propositions, the inevitable conclusion will be that the act we complain of and suffer under is so far out of the character of law as not to be entitled to a place on the calendar of any Christian State or civilized nation, and, therefore, shall ask you to amend it as already indicated.

Our first proposition denies to the act of 1794 the character of law, such as may be rightfully enacted and executed by civil authority. What, then, is law, its source, its prerogative, and its limits? In this body, representative of the Christian culture and high intelligence of the State of Wm. Penn, I shall not have to prove, but only need state in passing to my argument, that “The powers that be are ordained of God.” There is no power but of God, therefore, let every soul be subject unto the higher powers. “For rulers are not a terror to good works, but to evil.” “For he is the minister of God; to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain; for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.” Such is the character and function of civil government as stated in the clear and masterly style of that magnificent scholar and divinely inspired lawyer, the disciple of Gamaliel and of Jesus Christ.

With this masterly statement of the nature and functions of civil law, the great masters of jurisprudence have agreed, from Justinian till now. Justinian: “The precepts of law are, to live honestly, to hurt no one, and to give every man his due.” “Jurisprudence is the science of what is just and unjust.” Cicero: “Lex est sanctio justa, jubens honesta et prohibens contraria.” So the expounders of Roman law held.

The expounders of English law are still more explicit. Bracton and Blackstone both quote these Roman authorities approvingly, and add: “The primary and principal objects of law are rights and wrongs.” Jacob’s Law Dictionary gives the following definitions of law: “A rule for the well governing of civil society, to give to every man that which doth belong to him. The law of nature is that which God at man’s creation infused into him for his preservation and direction, and this is an eternal law, and may not be changed. All laws derive their force from the law of nature, and those which do not are accounted no laws.” Hooker: “Of law no less can be acknowledged than that her seat is the bosom of God, and her voice the harmony of worlds. All things in heaven and earth do her homage; the least, as feeling her care, and the greatest, as not exempt from her power.” Blackstone: “Law, the science which distinguishes the criteria of right and wrong, which teaches to establish the one and prevent, punish, or redress the other. The law of nature being co-eval with mankind and dictated by God himself, is, of course, superior in obligation to any other. It is binding over all the globe, in all countries, at all times, and no human laws are of any validity, if contrary to this; and such human laws as are valid derive all their force, and all their authority, mediately or immediately, from this original law of nature enacted by God.” Lord Chief Justice Hobart, in elucidation of this fundamental principle of law, says, “Even an act of Parliament made against natural justice is void in itself,” for, says he, “jura natura, sunt immutabilia, et legis legum.” Blackstone applies this principle with equal clearness. He says, “If Parliament enact a thing to be

done which is unreasonable, I know of no power that is vested with authority to control [execute] it.” He goes on to say, “If any human law should allow or enjoin to commit crime, we are bound to transgress that law, or else we must offend both the natural and the divine laws. The law of nations depends entirely on the rules of natural law, and in the construction of leagues and compacts of communities, we have no other rule to resort to but the law of nature. Those rights which God and nature have established, such as life and liberty, need not the aid of human laws to be more effectually invested in every man than they are, neither do they receive any additional strength when declared by municipal law to be inviolable. On the contrary, no human legislature has the power to abridge or destroy them, unless the owner of these rights shall himself commit some act that amounts to a forfeiture.” Our own immortal statesman, J. Q. Adams, has put this doctrine of the higher law of nature in these terse and vigorous words: “The law of nature is antecedent and paramount to all human governments. Every individual of the human race comes into the world with rights which, if the whole aggregate of human power were concentrated in one arm, it could not take away. The Declaration of Independence recognizes no despotism. It declares that individual man is possessed of rights of which no government can deprive him.” Our own Spooner, after a careful study of this whole question of law, lays down the following lucid definition and conclusion: “Law,” he says, “is the rule, principle, and requirement of natural justice. Law is a fixed principle resulting from men’s natural rights; and, therefore, the acknowledgment and security of the natural rights of individuals constitute the whole basis of law as a science and a sine qua non of government as a legitimate institution.”

Now, without further reference to authorities, we plant ourselves on these immutable and indisputable principles of law, and in the light and behest of them we arraign the law of 1794, of Pennsylvania, as illegitimate and void, and the penalties its execution has inflicted as unjust and despotic. God in both nature and revelation has given all men the indefeasible right to work at honest, industrial pursuits six days in every week and rest the seventh day. Yea, more; he has made it the duty of every man to do so, by first doing it himself, and then enacting it into eternal, immutable law, binding on all the race in all time, in words following: “Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work. . . . For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.”

Now this order of the six days’ labor and the seventh day’s rest, is the order of High Heaven, and based in the natural rights and natural needs of men, and therefore we deny all governments and authority to interfere with it, and hold all such interference to be, without the nature and authority of law, simple impertinence and violation of natural justice. The law of labor and the law of rest are natural laws of human life, put in it by the Creator of it, as the sine qua non of its coming to its best estate; and the Author of that life and of the law under which he set it a going, has very kindly designated the right proportion of rest to labor. Six day shalt thou labor, but the seventh day is the Sabbath; in it thou shalt not do any work. With this order of High Heaven’s appointment mid the thunders and lightnings of Sinai, there is no authority this side the throne of God that may rightfully interfere. It is deeply set in the nature of things, and therefore “immutabilia et lex legum.”

If it be claimed that while the legislature may not interfere to disturb the proportion of labor to rest, it may determine the order of their recurrence, and ordain which of the seven days of the week shall be the day of rest, it is answered, that the beneficent Author of life and its law of laborp. 276 and of rest, has left no discretion with men, nor any open field for human legislation in that matter, but has himself adjusted it, and made it the indispensable feature of the law, that the rest-day of the seven shall be the seventh, and no other. The Sabbath day was a memorial of God’s rest-day, after a finished creation, and as the creative work was not finished till the close of the sixth day, then “in necessitate rei,” the rest from the finished work could not begin till the dawning of the seventh day, and no memorial of that day could be any other than the recurring seventh day of each hebdomadal period. The Mosaic history of the creative work and the rest therefrom, is too clear to be mistaken: “And God saw everything that he had made, and behold it was very good, and the evening and the morning were the sixth day. Thus, the heavens and the earth were finished, and all the host of them; and on the seventh day God had ended his work, and he rested on the seventh day from all the work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it, because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.” Thus it was ordained in the beginning, and upon this ordinance the Sabbath law of the decalogue was based. Thus, as clearly as statutory provision can make it, has the Author of the law of laws fixed not only the proportion of the working and the resting days, but also the order of their recurrence, and based it all in the immutable nature of things. No other day but the seventh could be the memorial day of God’s rest from his finished creation, for the reason that until the dawn of that day there was no finished creation, and no divine resting from creative work. With this divine order no human legislature has any authority to interfere by enacting statutory restrictions. If the governments of the world combined should enact that all men should rest on the seventh day of the week and work on all the other six, it would add no obligation not now existing, to do the same; should the same combination, on the other hand, enact that this man or that should not work on any one of the first six days of the week, and should not rest on the seventh, it would not by one whit change the already existing facts and obligations in the premises. They are settled by authority above and beyond the sphere of human legislation.

The fact is, gentlemen, this matter of Sabbath-keeping is between man and his Maker, and there is not an inch of ground in it all where human law has any prerogative whatever. The first table of the decalogue, comprising the first four commandments, sets forth the duties that grow out of the relations of man to God; and human governments have no prerogatives whatever concerning these relations and duties. The second table of the decalogue, comprising the last six commandments, sets forth the duties that grow out of the relation of man to man. To see to the application of the principles of this table of the decalogue to human affairs, is the one sole function of government. Government may rightfully see to it—ought to see to it—that I do not kill my neighbor, do not slander him, nor steal from him. It is for just such functions God has ordained “the powers that be.”

But let it be granted that all do not accept the order God has fixed, and for some reason, sound or unsound, some think they should rest on the first, or sixth day of the week, and work the other six, by what authority may they enact their notion or belief into law that shall be binding upon those of the other opinion? I think God worked on the first six days of the week and rested on the seventh, and put that example into statutory provision for the whole human race. My Brother Jones, here, thinks God has somehow changed that order and obligation, so that he ought to rest on the first day of the week, and work on all the others. According to my best ability to study facts, apprehend principles, and deduce conclusions, I have reached my belief; according to his best ability he has reached his; and we live neighbors. Now what shall we do? I honestly think he is wrong in his belief and practice; and it rather worries me, as Sabbath comes on, to have him plowing in the field right over against my study window, or driving his noisy wagon by my church during service. Bro. Jones honestly thinks he is right, and my work over against his window, and driving by his church on his Sabbath, annoys him. What shall we do? I will candidly admit that he is as astute a thinker, as good a reasoner, and as honest a seeker after the divine will, the law of laws, the infallible guide, as I am, and he admits that I am his equal in all these respects. We meet and kindly reason the case with each other, but remain of the same opinions still. I get petulant, and scold him; then I get foolish, and threaten him; but he keeps right on. In a moment of weakness I wish I had power to compel him, to impose some penalty on him, for working on the seventh day of the week—the Sabbath, as I think it; and if the truth must be told, my good-natured neighbor, once in a while, almost wishes he had some authority to stop my working on Sunday. But then we are equal in strength. He cannot coerce me; I cannot coerce him.

A thought strikes me. Here are neighbors settling all around us, some Germans, some Irish, some Swedes, and all sorts. Now if I can win enough of these to my religious views of the Sabbath, we will overrun neighbor Jones, and by-and-by have power to compel him to stop his work on the seventh day, whether we can make him change his opinion or not. A few fines, and, if need be, a good term of imprisonment, may be, will tone his earnestness, and possibly convert him to our views; at any rate, we will be rid of his annoyance. Day by day my retainers increase, and, full of my spirit, begin to clamor for the fray. But somehow it transpires that my quiet neighbor Jones is pursuing the same course, and has gathered a clan of swordsmen, all anxious to measure arms with mine. The fray goes on, and many a trusty lance is broken before the shout of victory decides whose pennon floats last over the bloody field. It is mine; and over the prostrate form of the man who has persisted in working on the seventh and resting on the first day of the week, I stand by the proven strength of my right arm. I command him, with pains and penalties, to desist his practice so annoying to me. But he expostulates: “I think I am right, and feel, deeply feel, that by the power of your might you have trampled on sacred, God-given rights.” If he had proven the stronger, he would have crushed me as I have him, and by just the same authority.

What have we done but roll the wheels of progress away back into the Dark Ages, when feudal arrogance and priestly proscription held high carnival in the midnight of that eclipse which well-nigh quenched the sun in the heavens? My right to my opinion and practice was just as good as his, and his just as good as mine; and neither had the shadow of right to proscribe and coerce the other, nor would a million adherents to one increase by one iota his right to compel the other. If, instead of coercing my neighbor by the use of the sword, I had done it by the ballot, and put the act into the form of law, the despotism would have been none the less. There remains above all my authority over him or his over me, our equal rights to determine for ourselves what is the divine law and order of working and resting,—what are our respective relations and duties to God, our Maker. A million men have no more right of coercive interference in the matter than one man has; and putting it into legal form does not make it into law, nor clothe it with any of the authority of law. I am sure, beyond a doubt, that God, law, and order justify me in my work on the first day and rest on the seventh. It is a sacred religious conviction I am following. My conscience approves my course, and would severely condemn me were I to abandon it. I would burn at the stake rather than give it up. My Brother Jones would die in defense of his position—it is a matter of principle and of conscience with him. Now I deny to myself any right to dictate to him that he shall not follow his conviction by putting pains and penalties across his path. And with equal emphasis do I deny his right to interfere with me. We stand co-equal before God and nature in the right to follow our own convictions and satisfy our own consciences in the premises; and if it be not pleasant for him to see or hear me at work on his day of rest, no more is it pleasant for me to see and hear him at work on my day of rest. And if I may not compel him to make my pleasure the criterion of his duty, no more may he compel me to make his pleasure the criterion of my duty. My pleasure and convenience must be just as sacred in his regard as his in mine, and none the less if he have a host of adherents and I but a handful. While civil law has no prerogative whatever in the case to determine which shall yield to the other and how much, there is a high, divine law of Christian courtesy and kindly regard for each other’s comfort which will make us vie with each other in efforts to make our own views and ways as little offensive as possible.

To this high law of Christian courtesy we, as Seventh-day Baptists, hold ourselves strictly amenable; by God’s help we will always try to conform to the Golden Rule of doing as we would be done by. We like our ways because we do conscientiously believe them to be the ways of obedience to God’s high behests.

“The good round about us we do not eschew, Nor think of ourselves with egotist view; But the old paths we keep until better are shown, Credit good where we find it, abroad or our own; And while, ‘Lo here and lo there,’ the multitudes call, Be true to ourselves, and do justice to all.”

Thus, in the name and behest of law, humbly, but earnestly, and, if need be, heroically, we shall keep claiming our place and our equal rights with all other religious sects to understand for ourselves what is God’s will, and therefore our duty, in this matter of working and resting, and all else that God, by nature, makes the common and equal rights of religious beings. We ask no exclusive privileges, nor such as we would not grant to others were our numbers ten to one of theirs. The eternal God gives us the right to find out truths for our own guidance, and enjoins us to live them with the kindest regards to what others may find who differ with us. This we are doing, and we only ask to be let alone in it, and solemnly pledge ourselves not to infringe the equal rights of others.

“We do not pray over the Pharisee’s prayer; Nor claim that our wisdom is Benjamin’s share; Truth to us and to others is equal and one; Who shall bottle the free air or hoard up the sun? So a man be a man, let him worship at will, In Jerusalem’s court or on Gerizim’s hill.”

And let all others keep hands off. A man before his God, in solemn service, has rights which not all other men may touch with so much as the tip of the finger but with audacious sacrilege. —Sabbath Recorder.

(Concluded next week.)