SOME REMARKABLE ADMISSIONS

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 18, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 3.

Read the full edition

SOME REMARKABLE ADMISSIONS.

BY C. C. LEWIS.
I HAVE been greatly interested of late in reading some papers and addresses presented at the Massachusetts Sabbath (Sunday) Conventions held at Boston and Springfield in October, 1879. Perhaps the most remarkable of these essays is one by Rev. Prof. Henry Lummis, who seems to have had the courage to express before that body of eminent clergymen thoughts which must trouble the minds of many teachers more than they dare express.
The theme of Prof. Lummis was, “The Obligation of One Rest-day in Seven; so that the seventh-day rest is obligatory, if the first is not.” After showing that the obligation of one day’s rest in seven is found in man’s own nature; that his need of such a rest has become so evident that eminent statesmen, successful merchants, and enterprising manufacturers have long since conceded the fact, simply on the ground of political economy, he then raises the question, “Have we well-established grounds for making one day rather than another the day of rest?” and enumerates from Bishop Wordsworth the reasons for regarding the Lord’s day as the consecrated day of the week, as follows:—
  1. Christ rose from the dead on this day.
  2. He appeared twice in succession on this day.
  3. He gave special evidence of his resurrection on this day.
  4. He gave the earnest of the Spirit on this day.
  5. He sent the full effusion of the Holy Ghost to his church.
He subjoins: “Our Lord does not seem to have shown himself to his disciples in the intervening six days. Thus he distinguished the first day from all other days of the week as his own day. And the Holy Spirit, in recording those appearances in Holy Scripture, and by calling it the Lord’s day, has consecrated that day to him.” The following comments of Prof. Lummis are given entire:—
“There are, it must be admitted, some difficulties in regard to the reasons assigned above; not for preferring the first day of the week as a memorial day of the Lord’s resurrection, but for its preference over the seventh as a rest-day. The asserted authoritative change is a difficult point to establish, as is felt throughout Protestantism.
“Men cherish days on which great benefactors were born. There is surely reason why we should reverence the day on which Jesus Christ became the first-born from the dead. Herein men can agree. But, in the absence of any definite word in respect to the change, can we be quite sure that he meant that the first day of the week should take the place of the day signalized as the rest-day for at least fifteen hundred years, possibly for four thousand or even five thousand or more? With all respect for those who may deem the problem simple of solution, I confess to a consciousness of obscurity here. And it grows, the more I study the history of the seventh and of the first day. Is it evident that Christ, without mention of the fact, should have desired and ordained that this first day of the week should become the most honored and sacred of all days?
. . . I believe that the apostles would naturally regard the day as well as the fact of their Lord’s resurrection with profound interest; I think I can see reasons why John at Patmos might first among the disciples call the first day of the week the Lord’s day; and I find no occasion for doubting that there were religious services connected therewith, and that this Lord’s day gradually took precedence of all the days of the week; but that in the absence of a specified command the first day of the week took forthwith the place of the ancient rest-day, and that without controversy between the adherents of the old and the maintainers of the new, is so out of the ordinary course of human proceeding, that if not inexplicable, it must be admitted to be very strange. The clear, definite, unmistakable, divine assignment of the seventh day of the week as the rest-day, is in striking contrast with a want of assignment in the case of the substitution of the first
for the seventh, if it has been really made. No man who believes the sacred record, has ever doubted that the Israelites were commanded to keep the seventh day sacred as the weekly rest. But many good, many learned men, gravely question whether an authoritative voice has ever enjoined such keeping of the first day.”
He next quotes Isa. 58:13, 14; 56:6, 7, and Jer. 17:24, 25, after which he continues thus: “In these specific mentions of the rest-day it was the Sabbath,—the day indicated in the decalogue. Would it not seem that a change, if made, would have been as specific as was the designation of time in the law? Do not the expedients resorted to, to adjust the problem, indicate the uncertainty of the thing attempted to be explained? Would a Jew be at any loss to point out his ground for observing his rest-day? It is certainly questionable whether the use of the expression, ‘the Sabbath,’ for the first day of the week, does not imply a conclusion not warranted by the premises in the case.”
“Perhaps it will be asked, ‘Does not the essayist observe the Lord’s day as a day of rest?’ If he answers, ‘Yes,’ how can he consistently keep the first day, and yet hold the seventh to be more evidently binding?”
“Men are not always consistent. Embarrassments may be found on both sides of a question. The following escape from the dilemma is suggested: The legislation of Moses was not in reference to one day in seven; it named a specific day, the day which God originally hallowed, because on it he had rested from his work. This was to be to the Hebrews a memorial of their escape from the bondage of Egypt, a land where they had enjoyed no rest-day.”
The Professor here attempts, in the usual manner, and with the usual result, to prove this assertion, and in the course of his remarks he says, “If the decalogue unchanged still binds, I see no escape from breaking the divine law except by a prompt return to the observance of the seventh day. . . . No other rest-day, it must be conceded, has the recorded divine authority which belongs to the seventh day. Here it stands supreme. On the other hand, no other day of worship has the consensus of so large a part of the human family, no other day is in such harmony with the customs of the nations through many centuries, as the first day.”
Our essayist concludes, “If no days but the first and seventh present so high claims as do these, if none have any claim if these do not, then it must be granted, that, if the first day of the week is not the day for a day of rest, the seventh is; if the seventh is not, then the first is.”
Probably no one will question such a profound conclusion.