“The words of a talebearer are as wounds.” Prov. 18:8.
There are other ways of “doing murder” than by the use of the cord, the knife, or the poison; and, short of death, how much evil may be wrought on a man! The acutest pain is not always that which has its seat in the body; but very many are brought down with sorrow to their grave by the unseen yet barbed and poisoned arrows which stick fast in the soul. “The words of a talebearer are as wounds.”
If an accurate estimate could be made of all the wreck and suffering of this world, it would be found, in our opinion, that war does not take the heaviest share to itself. War has its alleviations; it has its fierce joys and its pomp and circumstance,—what men call “glory.” War is not perpetual. The gates of the Temple of Janus have been shut; but from “the words of the talebearer” you have no cessation: to them there is no alleviation. In a fair stand-up fight you may vanquish your enemy, and feel that you have finally made an end of him. With the talebearer you cannot grapple; he fights you at a distance, in the darkness; he stabs you as you sleep, or from behind. He follows you everywhere, eats with you from your own dish, and then lifts up his heel against you. Besides, he is usually so weak, wretched, and worthless a thing, that you cannot even grasp him hard, for fear of causing the annihilation that is ever so near him. You can only suffer silently, and possess your soul in patience. “Have you heard the news?” he breathlessly begins. “A said to me that he heard B say to C, that you were heard saying”—saying something. Or you are speaking to the talebearer, or to some one in his presence, about a friend. He overhears part of your utterance, and immediately he is off to your friend with the intelligence of what you said, or did not say, of him “behind his back.” He puts all his own ignorance and malice in his report,—not one grain of your kindliness, humor, and genuine love for your friend,—and the deed is done. The poison is in the “wound” which “the words of the talebearer” have made, and you have one friend fewer, one enemy more, than you had in this world.
But that is only the source of the waters of wrath. Crescit eundo. The river grows, and gathers strength and bitterness, as it flows on from mouth to mouth and man to man. “The beginning of strife is as when one letteth out water;” and it is only “where there is no talebearer that the strife ceaseth.”
The talebearer is, almost of necessity, a liar. His tale is usually a reported one, and he makes no effort to sift its truthfulness, and to separate the false from the true. He is careful to inform you that he is not the originator, but simply the repeater or reporter of the story, and that he tells it you “exactly as it was told to him.” He has lost part of the facts, however, by the way; does not repeat others; gives emphasis to such places as are capable of being made to look very black, and there he leaves it and you, with a comfortable sense of having discharged a painful duty. He has been “faithful,” and having sown the tares, he goes to sleep till they grow; and they do grow, very rapidly.
At other times he is unusually earnest; he has seen and heard himself. This time there can be no doubt, for he is the witness. “You may take my word for it, he actually did say so and so; I give you his very words: I could swear to them, if need were.” Very likely, and yet in such a case there may be, and often is, the biggest and the blackest lie of all. For there are so many things that a man who is even willing to report honestly and truthfully, cannot report. There are the circumstances out of which the conversation grew; there is the whole scope and drift of that which preceded and followed; there is the tone of voice, look, manner, each shading of which varies the meaning of words; there is, above all, the feeling in the heart of the speaker, which hardly ever is at any one time all conveyed by any one statement, and the part left behind unexpressed might, and most probably would, have changed the aspect of all the rest; and if you add, as you always ought, the ignorance and malice of the talebearer, where and what is “the truth” which could be sworn to?
It adds unspeakably to the poignancy of the “wounds” caused by the “words” of the talebearer that usually he has so little else to carry than “tales.” Of his own, beyond coloring matter, and a little of the inventive faculty, he has most commonly next to nothing. In other respects he is frequently a harmless sort of creature, like the fly that will settle on your face, and which is sufficient to keep you awake. He does not always mean to make strife, only he must talk; and in the utter absence of other presentable materials, he is driven to that frequent refuge of the destitute,—talebearing. There is a world of meaning in these two lines of Thomas Hood’s, that—
“Evil is wrought by want of thought As well as by want of heart.”
If there were fewer that listened to idle tales, there would be fewer talebearers in the world. But men not only listen to the tattle of the talebearer, but they believe him, and in many cases act upon his utterances. It is astonishing what disregard man shows for the simplest, most ordinary, and most obvious laws of evidence, when the talebearer is in question. If the veriest blackguard is hailed from the street, brought into the presence of a magistrate, charged with the paltriest offense, and a sworn witness against him begins by saying “Mr. A B told me—” “Stop, Sir,” says the magistrate; “what Mr. A B told you is not evidence. Bring Mr. A B here, and let him tell that himself. Be good enough, sir, to confine yourself to what you yourself saw and know.” And, observe, all this must be said and done before the person accused. Behind his back, absolutely nothing can go on. At each stage he must be permitted to examine and cross-examine the witness, add explanations, call other witnesses to bring out all facts of the case, and then reply on the whole evidence, before even committal can be arrived at. But the talebearer puts himself in the witness-box; the accused party is absent and ignorant of the whole transaction; the talebearer is not sworn, often not examined nor cross-examined; no witnesses are heard for the defense, no explanations are asked, no corroborative evidence demanded; the other party constitutes himself judge and jury, rapidly sums up, gives judgment, passes sentence, and immediately orders execution. And sometimes this sentence so arrived at is “death,”—death to all friendship between him and me: “I shall never speak to him again.” Death! let the sentence be executed without delay. How often has this, most monstrous and summary proceeding been gone through in the reader’s own experience!
Every honest man should set himself to the putting down of these pests of society. They should be hunted out and exterminated, as the vilest of vermin. Men should combine, and go in league against them, as they do against vipers, snakes, and the whole serpent tribe. Traps, gins, and snares should be set for their feet, as for wild beasts and foxes. And the method of procedure is simple. Take it from another of those wise proverbs, given to us by God: “Where no wood is, there the fire goeth out.” The fire will be effectually extinguished without the necessity of water, if only you stop the supply of fuel. Cease to listen to the talebearer, and his fire will go out; his “wounds” and his “words” will be harmless. Cease to listen, or cease to give credence; hear as if you heard not; pass on to other matters; go clean over him and his tale, and forget it utterly. He who adds fuel to the fire by repeating the tale of the talebearer is only a shadow less guilty than he who originated it.
“Lord, who shall abide in thy tabernacle? who shall dwell in thy holy hill? He that walketh uprightly, and worketh righteousness, and speaketh the truth in his heart. He that backbiteth not with his tongue, nor doeth evil to his neighbor, nor taketh up a reproach against his neighbor.” He that backbiteth not with his tongue; i. e., he who is no talebearer. But there is another side to it: “Nor taketh up a reproach against his neighbor.” If there were fewer men to “take up” the evil reproach, there would be fewer to make it up, and fewer to carry it about when made. The talebearer usually concludes—for he is a coward—with, “Now, mind, do not for the world say that I told you; don’t mention my name at all in the matter.” He who acts on such “information” is as bad as the man who gives it, if not worse. “Will you go with me and repeat all that before his face, that I may hear his explanation, and know whether this be all true, and whether I have got all the truth?” If not, then a speedy end ought to be made to the whole business—the heel put on the burning coal to crush it in the dust.—Rev. Thomas Alexander, M. A.