The following private letter from Bro. Cottrell speaks concerning a question which is of late years quite a prominent subject of discussion, in a manner to so fully commend itself to the good judgment of the reader that we take the liberty to make the most of it thus public. He says:—
“I suppose —— is honest; but he is so confident that he is right that he cannot take the place of an inquirer. I confess it is so with myself. I cannot claim to be an inquirer after the truth on the subject of man's nature, and the meaning of life and death as used in the Bible; for I am so confident that the Bible means what it plainly says, that I cannot question it at all. So the opposition are so firmly set in their theory of a spiritual death as the penalty of sin that they cannot submit to be corrected by the express terms of Inspiration.
“This theory that to be dead in trespasses and sins—to be dead while we live—is the death threatened against Adam as the penalty of sin, has no second death in it; for a second spiritual death is impossible, unless the subjects should be raised from the first, and made spiritually alive. If the death we die in Adam is spiritual death, then, according to Paul, all are to be made spiritually alive in Christ. But this they do not believe. They hold that unless the sinner be converted, he will remain in that death to eternity. Hence there can be no second death in their theory. But the Bible teaches a second death, however men may ridicule the idea of killing a man, and then raising him to life in order to kill him again for the same offense.
“I have noticed that Christians, when they oppose plainly revealed truth, talk just like skeptics and infidels. Instead of setting forth a better theory, and sustaining it by sound reasoning, they content themselves by raising objections and picking flaws with that which they oppose; as if they had no other object but to overthrow their opponents. No matter if their efforts bring the word of God into disrepute, by making it appear to be contradictory in itself. For example: God threatened Adam with death, in case of disobedience. After the transgression, he explained the meaning of the threatening by the penalty he pronounced,—a life of toil and misery; ending in returning to the earth, out of which he had been made. He then tells to what age Adam had lived when he died. The Bible being true, all this must be harmonious. But Orthodox, Universalists, and infidels will tell you that if the threatening was true, Adam must have been, not only dying, but actually dead, on the literal day of twenty-four hours of the transgression. Would it not be much better for believers to labor to show the harmony of the word which they believe?
“The S. D. Baptists may be mostly Trinitarians at the present time, though I do not think they were originally. I never heard them distinctly preach the theory or say much about it. Accessions from other denominations have doubtless brought it in, and probably most of them consent to it. But when I united with them, about forty-eight years ago, the doctrine was not in their ‘Articles of Faith.’ And I know by the writings of one of their deacons in Rhode Island, who died some years ago at a great age, that he did not believe the doctrine as generally taught. He expressed himself in this way: ‘If “God sent his Son into the world,” I believe that he had a Son to send.’ I quote from memory, but I have the work at home.”