It will be remembered by the readers of the Review that last spring at the special session of the General Conference, a resolution was passed concerning an annual election of elders and deacons, recommending that that these officers be elected in every church once a year. This recommendation of the General Conference was considered by nearly all our State Conferences during the past camp-meeting season, when sessions of these Conferences were held. Quite a number of them passed resolutions indorsing this action, and in order that it might be carried out, appointed a day for the election. In a number of these Conferences this election will occur on the second day of January, when the church quarterly meeting will be held, but in some Conferences a different day was appointed. As nothing of this kind has heretofore been practiced by our people, it seems proper that some suggestions should be made by the General Conference Committee concerning this election, for the purpose of saving confusion.
The resolution passed by the General Conference was as follows:—
“Resolved, That the local elders and deacons in our churches should be elected annually, such election to occur in each church at a time set by each State Conference, except in churches where dissatisfaction with the incumbent has been expressed by at least a respectable minority of the church. In such cases it shall be the duty of the church clerk to notify the Conference Committee of such fact; and elections in such churches shall be deferred till proper help is provided by the committee.”
It may be proper to state some of the reasons why this resolution was passed. In a very few of our churches individuals elected to the office of elder have been found to be unfit for the position, owing to a lack of spirituality or of mental qualifications, so that a change is necessary. When there is no regular annual election, a change in such cases is calculated to stir up the sympathies of the friends of the incumbent, and make the shock much greater than it would be if a regular election should occur annually. There are many instances in which a change of officers would be advantageous to the church. When churches are first organized, and the membership are inexperienced, persons are selected to fill these positions, according to the best judgment of minister and people. It often occurs that after a time others are developed who would be of greater service to the church, and an annual election gives a chance for beneficial changes to be made.
We act upon this plan in the case of ministerial elders; they receive credentials every year, or they are not authorized to perform ministerial duties. Are there not just as good reasons why local elders should be indorsed annually? Good officers will feel much better satisfied to serve when indorsed by their church every year. Should there be those who desire to act as officers contrary to the voice of the church, it would seem highly probable that a change would be beneficial. In most churches no change will be desired. We would caution our brethren everywhere against making changes when those holding these positions give reasonable satisfaction. Do not make changes merely for the sake of a change. Do not experiment in matters so sacred. Only make changes where good reasons exist for supposing others can perform the duties more satisfactorily.
It will be noticed that the resolution carefully guards one point. Elections of new officers are not to occur without the presence of ministers of experience, who are indorsed by the Conference Committee. Where dissatisfaction is known to exist, so that there is a prospect of difficulty or of a change of officers being made, the clerk of the church is to notify the Conference Committee, and in such cases an election is to be postponed until a minister delegated by the committee can be present. Should some churches, that have sent no such notice to the Conference Committee, attempt to change their officers when the time of election is reached, they should at once stop, and have no election till a minister can be present. So it will be seen that where elections do occur on the appointed day, they are really no more than a reappointment of the present incumbents, unless experienced ministers are present, when a change can be made if desirable.
We would suggest as a proper course in cases where there is no difficulty, that when the time of election arrives and church business is to be considered, the elder acting as chairman of the meeting and the clerk being present, some brother make a motion that Eld. A., B., or C., as the case may be, be elected for the ensuing year. This being seconded, the motion might be put, and if carried, the person would be elected to that office. So of the deacon. If the motion was not carried, but opposition was manifested, then the election should be postponed, as above directed, till help can be secured. If the election is carried, the officers will of course go on with their duties with good courage, feeling that they have the sanction of their brethren and sisters. They will need no new ordination, any more than ministers who receive credentials need to be re-ordained. The election would take only a few moments, and there would be no difficulty in it. The only difficulty will be when the church disagree as to who shall fill these offices.
It may be thought by some an infringement upon the rights of the membership to advise no election of new officers without the presence of a minister. This caution is given solely to save the church from difficulty and trial. If a new candidate were elected, he would not be qualified to discharge the duties of elder until he was ordained; he could not be ordained without the presence of a minister; hence there would be no practical benefit in electing a man to that position when he could not serve. There would be great danger that difficulties might arise if there was not a man of experience present, should there be anything like opposition and strife in the election. Trials might arise which would divide the church, and which it would be the work of years to heal; and the ruin of precious souls might result. Every precaution should be used to avoid this. Hence the propriety of having experienced ministers present. It is not so much a question as to the power of the membership to elect a new officer, as of the policy of doing it at such great risks. We should pursue a course of safety if possible.
We look forward with much interest to the first regular annual election of church elders and deacons, which in many of our Conferences will take place on the second of next January. We hope it will result in good, and obviate a difficulty by making provision for changes where they should be made. We trust all our brethren will enter upon this new movement with prayer and a candid spirit, and do nothing rashly,—nothing which will injure the cause. Retain the services of faithful, God-fearing officers, who have served you well in the past. Make changes with great caution. Do not venture upon mere experiments. Act in the fear of God, with the sole motive of advancing the prosperity of Zion.
GENERAL CONFERENCE COMMITTEE.