AdventAI

CONTROVERSY IN FUNERAL SERMONS.

By Dudley Marvin Canright

From Review and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 3., July 12, 1881

Is it profitable to indulge in controversial preaching at funerals? I know that there is a great temptation to do so, and that it is often done, both by our people and by others. Yet after long and carefully noting the effect, I have come to doubt the propriety of doing so. I notice how we feel when an orthodox minister takes advantage of a funeral to oppose our views and advocate his own. We never like it, but always find fault with it. If it is the funeral of a relative, where we attend as mourners, then we feel misused and aggrieved, and are not slow to say so.

Then why is it not the same when the case is reversed? When our ministers preach against the views of others, especially where there are mourners present who do not agree with us on the state of the dead, does not such a course tend to wound and exasperate instead of convincing and winning? My observation is that this is the result in most cases. Doubtless there are cases where a thorough doctrinal sermon on the sleep of the dead would be appropriate at a funeral, as where the deceased and all the mourners were of our faith, and where the funeral was held in our own church. Then a mild doctrinal sermon might be appropriate, if care were taken not to use any sharp, offensive language. Neighbors and friends are expected to attend a funeral out of respect to our common humanity, without any regard to the religious ideas of the deceased, or any desire to hear the preacher or his peculiar doctrines.

To take advantage of these circumstances and compel persons to listen to what is offensive to them, is uncourteous, to say the least. It is not doing unto others as we would have them do unto us.

But setting aside the right or wrong of it, is it expedient? Do we gain anything by it? Do we not offend more than we convince? Do we not give the impression that we are mere controversialists, rather than devoted Christians?

Should not the solemnity of a funeral, when hearts are sober and tender, be taken advantage of to impress all with the solemn realities of life, death, and the Judgment? If this is done, we shall gain the sympathy of all right-minded people, and impress the careless with their own danger and duties. I simply offer these thoughts as my own mind on the subject; others may think and act differently.

D. M. CANRIGHT.