“Dr. Todd (Congregational) and his church in New Haven are reported in the newspapers as having ceased to insist in their views of Scripture teaching on the doctrine of everlasting punishment, but as still holding that the Lord will come to judge the world in righteousness. If this is so, Dr. Todd and his church have gone over to the Universalists; for the Universalism of to-day is simply anti-everlastingism.—Michigan Christian Herald, Feb 10, 1881.
Not at all, brother! There is much “anti-everlastingism” that is not Universalism. The Bible is full of it; and Christendom is filling up quite encouragingly with it. Because a wicked man is not to burn to all eternity in conscious suffering in a lake of fire, it does not follow that he must be saved. For, the soul not being by nature immortal, the Gordian knot does not need to be cut, but is easily untied; and the view thatp. 105 the wicked may cease to be, and every vestige of death, hell, Satan, sin, and suffering be thus wiped out of the universe, is destined to triumph. And it deserves to triumph; for it gives us better views of the character of God, and vindicates the justice of his dealings with his creatures.
Such texts as Ps. 37: 10, 20; Mal. 4: 1; Matt. 3: 12; Rom. 6: 23; Gal. 6: 8; 2 Thess. 1: 9; 2 Peter 3: 7; Rev. 20: 9, 14; and a host of others, teach very strongly “anti-everlastingism,” but they just as effectually cut off Universalism.
We are glad of the change which Dr. Todd and his Congregational church have made; for the “everlastingism” of the old school of theology is the very hotbed of skepticism and Universalism.