AdventAI

A Blessing, or a Curse?

By Dudley Marvin Canright

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 21., May 24, 1881

We are all proud of our numerous libraries and free reading-rooms, so common throughout the land. They are supposed to be a great blessing. But read the following from the Detroit Evening News, of May 7, 1881:— “Of the 12,885 volumes taken out of the public library during the month of April, 8,259, or about 66 per cent, were works of fiction. One would be able to form a more accurate opinion of the balance of good or evil done by the institution if the character of the fiction were reported in some detail, so that it could be known whether trash or good novels predominated. The excess of fiction is almost as great as in the Boston library, where the analysis of a recent report convinced many persons that the library did more harm than good. There are as excellent general reasons against the policy of furnishing free books by taxation as there are against the policy of furnishing free newspapers or free clothes by the same means, but thesep. 329 reasons were thought to be overbalanced by the opportunities of popular education found in a free public library. In the light of these reports, which show that romantic trash is the chief matter furnished, the argument of education disappears, and that of mental demoralization takes its place.”

Satan is ever on hand to turn every blessing into a curse, as the above well illustrates.

D. M. Canright.