AdventAI

PETER NOT THE ROCK.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 21., May 24, 1881

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

The following extract from the discussion between Archbishop Purcell (Romanist) and Alexander Campbell (Disciple) sets forth in so clear a manner the reasons for rejecting the theory that Christ styled Peter the rock upon which his church was to be built, that I have thought it worthy of a place in the REVIEW for the purpose of reference.

The intelligent reader is aware of the fact that the declaration of Christ on this subject furnishes the staple from which Romanists manufacture one of their most effective arguments for their hierarchy. The syllogism, as they put it, is brief, and runs as follows:—

“Christ constituted Peter the rock upon which he built his church. The pope is the successor of St. Peter; therefore the pope sustains to the Christian church the same relation which Peter did; i. e., he is at the present time the rock upon which the Christian church is built, and should be honored as such.”

Those who read the following from Mr. Campbell will readily perceive the fallacy of this piece of papistic logic; since it will be made to appear that the premises are unsound, and therefore, the conclusion wrong:—

“WHAT OFFICE HAD PETER?

“What was his ecclesiastical power and patronage? Was Peter the prince of the apostles? Was he made the vicar of Christ? Ay, this is the question! It requires explicit—nay, positive—Scripture authority; where is it?

“He offers several passages to this point. I shall examine the prominent texts, and begin with the sixteenth chapter of Matthew. I read from Griesbach’s Greek Testament. In this chapter, Christ asks his disciples the question, ‘Who do men say that I am?’ and afterward asks them, ‘But who say ye that I am?’ and Peter answered, ‘Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God;’ and Jesus answered and said unto him, ‘Blessed are you, Simon Barjona; for flesh and blood has not revealed it to you, but my Father who is in Heaven; and I say also to you, that you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my congregation, and the gates of hades shall not prevail against it.’ Matt. 16:13–18.

“‘Upon this rock;’ was Peter this rock? The words sound much alike (petros and petra). Let us examine the passage. One of the internal evidences of the truth of the apostolic writings is that each writer has something peculiar to himself. So has every speaker and teacher that has appeared among men.

Jesus Christ himself had his peculiar characteristics. One of his peculiarities, most clearly marked by the four evangelists, is that he consecrated every scene, and circumstance, and topic of conversation to religion or morality. A few examples, out of many that might be given, must suffice. When standing by the sea of Galilee, he says to the fishermen, who were casting their nets into the sea, ‘Follow me, and I will make you fishers of men.’ At the well of Samaria, he says to the Samaritan woman from whom he asked a drink, ‘Whoever shall drink of this water shall thirst again; but whoever drinks of the water that I shall give him, shall never thirst; but it shall be in him a well of water springing up to eternal life.’ While with his disciples in the temple, and seeing the sheep going up to be sacrificed, he says, ‘My sheep hear my voice, and they follow me,’ and he speaks of himself as the true Shepherd, who lays down his life for his sheep. His disciples having forgotten to take bread when embarking on the lake, when talking about it, he took occasion to say, ‘Beware of the leaven of the Pharisees.’ When on Mount Olivet, among the vines and olives, he says, ‘I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser.’ And when looking at the temple, he says, ‘Destroy this temple, and I will build it in three days.’

“So in the passage before us. He asks his disciples an all-important question, in reply to which, one of them, who happens to be named Peter, utters the great truth upon which he is to found his church forever, ‘THOU ART THE CHRIST, (THE MESSIAH) the Son of the living God.’ Jesus turns to him, and says, ‘Thou art stone, and upon this rock (on this great truth which flesh and blood has not revealed to thee), I will build my church,’—‘ei su Petros, kai epi taute te petra’—‘You are Peter, and upon this petra’ strikes the ear of a Grecian as ‘Thou art stone, and upon this rock,’ strikes the ear of an Englishman; and, as we have seen, is a part of the Saviour’s peculiarity.

“The construction of language requires that the word ‘this’ should refer to something antecedent, different from thou or you. They are different in person and case. But not only does the Saviour’s peculiar characteristics, and the change of person from ‘thou’ the personal, to ‘this’ the demonstrative, fix the sense; but other considerations of great moment forbid any other interpretation.”

Allegan, Mich.