It is a matter for congratulation that on some points of the Sabbath question there is now no dispute. It is agreed that the setting apart of one day in seven as a special day of rest from labor is a wise and beneficent arrangement for men. The fact of this agreement is not only seen in the prevalence of such a day among different nations—as formerly in their very early, if not in their earliest, history among the Egyptians, Assyrians, Hindus, and Hebrews—and in its adoption when brought to the knowledge of nations where it had not been previously known—as when the Romans adopted it from the Egyptians at about the beginning of the Christian era, and the Japanese adopted it from ourselves in our own time,—but in the remarkable uniformity with which the worth of the Sabbath has been affirmed wherever the question has been intelligently investigated. Most elaborate researches upon this point have been conducted by physiologists, political economists, social reformers, philosophers, jurists, and statesmen, often upon different grounds and with different methods, but always with the same result. Without dwelling here upon the exceedingly copious material which these researches furnish, as illustrating the harmonious conclusion reached by all, I only quote two extracts, one from a conservative Englishman, and the other from a most intensely radical Frenchman.
Blackstone in his “Commentaries” (b. iv. c. 63) says:—
“Besides the notorious indecency and scandal of permitting any secular business to be publicly transacted on that day, in a country professing Christianity, and the corruption of morals which usually follows its profanation, the keeping of one day in seven holy, as a time of relaxation and refreshment as well as for public worship, is of admirable service to a State, considered merely as a civil institution. It harmonizes by the help of conversation and society the manners of the lower classes, which would otherwise degenerate into a sordid ferocity and savage selfishness of spirit; it enables the industrious workman to resume his occupation in the ensuing week with health and cheerfulness; it imprints on the minds of the people that sense of duty to God so necessary to make them good citizens, but which yet would be worn out and defaced by an unremitted continuance of labor without any stated times of recalling them to the worship of their Maker.”
Proudhon in his “De la Celebration du Dimanche” (p. 67) says:—
“What statistician could have first discovered that in ordinary times the period of labor ought to be to the period of rest in the ratio of six to one? Moses, then, having to regulate in a nation the labors and the days, the rests and the festivals, the toils of the body and the exercises of the soul, the interests of hygiene and of morals, political economy and personal subsistence, had recourse to a science of numbers, to a transcendental harmony which embraced all space, duration, movements, spirits, bodies, the sacred and the profane. The certainty of the science is demonstrated by the result. Diminish the week by a single day, the labor is insufficient relatively to the repose; augment it in the same quantity, it becomes excessive. Establish every three days and a half a half-day of relaxation, you multiply by the breaking of the day the loss of time, and in shattering the natural unity of the day you break the numerical equilibrium of things. Accord, on the contrary, forty-eight hours of repose after twelve consecutive days of labor, you kill the man by inertia, after having exhausted him by fatigue.”
The need of the Sabbath is so clear and its importance so great that it has become a civil institution among the most enlightened States. It is a great mistake to suppose that our so-called Sabbath laws are only co-incident with what men term Puritanic bigotry and intolerance. They are well-nigh co-extensive and co-eval with the Christian world. They began with the first Christian sovereign. The emperor Constantine, soon after his conversion, A. D. 321, decreed that there should be “rest on the venerable Sunday,” and his example was followed with more specific enactments and prohibitions by subsequent Roman emperors, eastern and western, by Charlemagne, by kings of the Franks and the Saxons in the early and mediaeval times of Christian Europe, and still more frequently, and with more minute requirements, by later European kings. In England and Scotland such statutes have existed from a very early period, modified somewhat in different reigns, and made more lax or more severe, according to the changing tone of the times, but on the whole showing an increasing strictness and minuteness in their requirements. The laws of King Athelstan (tenth century) forbade all merchandising on the Lord’s day under severe penalties. In Henry VI.’s reign (1448) the holding of fairs and markets on church-festival days and Sundays—except the four Sundays in harvest—was prohibited. In the reign of Elizabeth (1558) it was enacted that “all persons shall diligently and faithfully, having no lawful or reasonable excuse to be absent, endeavor to resort to their parish church or chapel upon every Sunday and other holy days, and then and there to abide orderly and soberly during the time of prayers, preaching, and other services of God.” The law passed in the twenty-ninth year of Charles II.—anything, surely, but a Puritan king or a Puritan time—requires that “all persons whatsoever shall, on every Lord’s day, apply themselves to the observation of the same, by exercising themselves thereon in the duties of piety and true religion, publicly and privately;” and that “no tradesman, artificer, workman, laborer, or other person whatsoever, shall do or exercise any worldly labor, business, or work of their ordinary callings upon the Lord’s day, works of necessity and charity only excepted.” The second section prohibits drovers, horse-coursers, wagoners, butchers, higglers, and their servants, from traveling, and the use of boats, wherries, lighters, or barges, except on extraordinary occasions. By another section, persons are prohibited from serving or executing any process or warrant on the Lord’s day, except in cases of treason, felony, and breach of the peace.
Nearly a hundred years after this act was passed, and not a hundred years ago, in the twenty-first year of George III.’s reign, it was enacted “that any house, room, or other place which shall be opened or used for public entertainments or amusement, or for publicly debating on any subject whatsoever, upon any part of the Lord’s day, called Sunday, and to which persons shall be admitted by the payment of money, or by tickets sold for money, shall be deemed a disorderly house or place; and the keeper of such house, etc., shall forfeit the sum of £200 for every day that such house, etc., shall be opened and used as aforesaid on the Lord’s day.” The third section of this act provides “that any person advertising or causing to be advertised, or publishing an advertisement of any public entertainment or amusement, or any public meeting for debating on any subject whatsoever on the Lord’s day, to which persons are to be admitted by the payment of money or by tickets sold for money, shall forfeit £50 for every such offense.” These laws are still upon the English statute-books, though they have been supplemented, not relaxed, by acts passed in the reign of George IV. regulating inns, taverns, etc., on the Lord’s day, by an act passed in the fourteenth year of William IV., whose preamble asserts it to be “the duty of the legislature to remove as much as possible impediments to the due observance of the Lord’s day;” and by an act in the thirteenth year of Victoria (1850) which repeals the exception in the statute of Henry VI., of four Sundays in harvest, thus making all fairs on Sunday illegal.p. 50
These Sunday laws of Great Britain are embodied in a greater or less degree in the Sunday laws of this country, every State in the United States, with the exception of Louisiana, and every territory, with the exception of Arizona, Utah, and the Indian Territory, having deemed it wise to enact something of the same. The usual course of legislation in each State or Territory has been to enact some general law modeled on the English statutes or on that of some other State, and when subsequent acts have been passed, the law has generally been rendered more strict.
But notwithstanding this general conviction respecting the wisdom and beneficence of the Sabbath, and these increasing appliances among the most enlightened nations for the better observance, we are to-day mourning over what seems to be its increasing desecration. This, however, ought not to surprise us. It only represents a universal tendency among men. Singular as it may seem, the fact is clear that human nature is far more active in throwing away its privileges than in preserving them. Arts and literatures and social refinements have been discarded by those who professed them far more frequently than they have been retained. If we look at the actual facts unblinded by any theory which prejudices them, we fail to find any inherent law of progress to a better state in human nature. On the other hand, the truth revealed is that of an inherent law of deterioration. Civilized nations have often become savages when left to themselves; savages left to themselves have never become civilized. Upward impulses, with man as with nature, come first from above. Nature does not improve itself, but all its culture comes from men who have themselves been cultivated. The desert or the wilderness, left to itself, or left to the savage, remains a desert or a wilderness still; while in the presence of the cultivated man surrounding nature takes on the type of his culture, the desolations of the desert rejoice, and the wilderness buds and blossoms as the rose. But let the human skill which has converted the waste into a garden be discontinued, and the garden becomes a waste again. We can trace the process by which the golden and luscious pippin has been brought out of the brown and bitter crab, but it is only by man’s skillful grafting, planting, and pruning that this result has been secured, and not by any spontaneous process through which the coarser stock has evolved itself into the finer one. So of all our cultivated flowers and fruits; they have been gained by arts of man, and not by any original and unaided tendencies of nature; and if the skill which has produced them should cease its care, they themselves would cease, and only the wild and worthless originals would remain. In like manner, man finds all his improvement in a divine incentive, and not in any impulse original to himself. A divine gift, and not any human creation, is the source of all human progress, and when men have renounced this gift, and sought to go forward by their own appliances, the invariable result has been that these appliances have become more and more inapt, and the efforts to employ them have become more and more feeble, until progress has ceased, and the means of progress have been lost altogether.
We shall not, therefore, counteract the downward tendencies of human nature by seeking to stem them through barriers which human nature itself can provide. We shall not stop the increasing desecration of the Sabbath by demonstrating its folly through any increasing disclosure of the advantages of this sacred day. Nothing is easier nor more common than to have the understanding convinced of the better course while the man actually chooses and follows the worse. In the practical conduct of life, men are not governed by their understandings, but by their sentiments; and if we shall ever exercise a living power over men, it can only be by influences which reach the fountain of their sentiments, their heart, their will.
Can we gain such a power by appealing to the sentiment of duty? Can we, in the case in hand, secure the desired regard for the Sabbath by arousing the conscience to see and feel that such a regard is not only advantageous, but right and obligatory? Doubtless the sentiment of duty has shown a mighty power in human life. What revolutions in character, what wonders in life it seems to have achieved! And yet with the great majority of men, to-day or at any time, the sentiment of duty seems utterly powerless. Does it control men generally, or has it ever done so? Some men doubtless seem to do the right by the simple constraint of obligation. They seem to be kept from doing wrong simply because it is wrong; but is this true? has it ever been true since the fall of the great mass of mankind? Nothing is more plain than that vice and crime of any sort run riot with human life in defiance of the most undoubted sense of obligation.
The morality taught by Socrates, by Zoroaster, by Confucius, by Shakya-Muni, was in many respects of unblemished purity and was proclaimed with unsurpassed power; but it did not change men; it did not raise the people to whom it was taught; it did not prevent them from sinking to a lower and lower depth of degradation. In no nation in the world is the virtue of truthfulness taught more earnestly or more prominently than in the schools of China to-day; yet in no nation is duplicity more evidently the rule of life. Says Dr. Wells Williams in his “Middle Kingdom” (vol. ii. p. 96): “There is nothing which tries one so much when living among the Chinese as their disregard of truth. Their proneness to this fault is one of the greatest obstacles to their permanent improvement as a people, while it constantly disheartens those who are trying to teach them.” Unless we can add to the constraint of a moral principle the command also of a moral sovereign, no appeal to the sentiment of duty and no awakening of that sentiment will ever make it actually dominant over men.
Morality does not save men. It has never saved them. It has no power to produce any correspondence to itself in human life. I do not enter here at all upon the question whether there have ever been individual instances of men who have changed from vice to virtue by moral precept alone; leaving that question to be answered as it may, this much at least is evident, and is all I here desire to urge, that the preaching of morality, however clear, however vigorous, has always proved a failure so far as the mass of men are concerned; it has never gone down deep into society and molded it internally and from the center with a regenerating and vivifying power. Hence, I argue, we shall not succeed in securing the desired observance of the Sabbath, if we only add to the evidence of its obvious advantages the evidence also of its equally obvious moral obligations. Men are just as likely in the present, and will be just as likely in the future, to turn their backs upon both these evidences as they have been in the past.—J. H. Seelye, President of Amherst College, in Princeton Review.
(Concluded next week.)