The Logic of Unbelief

33%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 19, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 58, No. 4.

Read the full edition

The Logic of Unbelief.

The logic of unbelief is a curious study. In science and philosophy a theory is judged by its positive proofs and by its adequacy to the facts; but in unbelief a theory is proved, not so much by positive facts and arguments as by its objections to opposing views. In particular, a theory of which an irreligious use can be made acquires a very high degree of probability from that fact alone. The chief strength of unbelief, so far as it is a matter of reason, lies in this false method. We fail to notice that the unbeliever is also a believer, or that his denials are also affirmations. When this is seen, it may appear that his doctrines require at least as much faith as those of his opponents.
In atheistic arguments we constantly meet with this oversight. Objections are urged against theism, and various difficulties are pointed out both in the argument and in the conception. Thus, it is urged that the argument can never amount to demonstration, a claim which all admit, and then the odd conclusion is drawn that, therefore, atheism is true. The pointings of probability and the demands of reason are all in favor of theism; but objections can always be raised, and this the atheist mistakes for a proof of his own view. It never occurs to him to ask whether his own theory be not in every way more objectionable and unsatisfactory; he rests his case on the difficulties of the opposite doctrine.—Sunday Afternoon.