There is a great deal of open-hearted and open-handed selfishness in the world. Some of the most liberal givers in the community are thoroughly selfish. Selfish prodigality is by no means uncommon. There are those who look upon themselves as exceptionally generous, and who are even so counted by their fellows, who are unmistakably selfish. This is a truth that ought to be borne in mind when we are passing upon the characteristics of ourselves, or of those whom we have a right to judge, because of our responsibility for their training. Selfishness is not always conjoined with stinginess.
Esau was a good illustration of the thoroughly selfish man, who was open-hearted, open-handed, and prodigally liberal. He was ready to spend a fortune for one square meal. There was nothing stingy about that. Men would be a great deal more likely to call his brother Jacob close-fisted and niggardly. But Esau was really more selfish than Jacob. Esau lived for self. His parting with his fortune so recklessly was merely because just then he wanted something else more than he wanted a fortune. So with his marrying, and so with his failing to cherish and retain his anger against Jacob. If he wanted a wife or two from the heathen nations about him, he took them. What did he care for the opinion of the Lord, or for that of his parents? If his wives didn’t entirely suit the old folks, he would take another of a different sort, rather than have trouble in the family. You don’t hear of Esau’s toiling away seven years to win a woman who had his heart, while all these years “seemed unto him but a few days, for the love he had to her.” Esau was too much taken up with self, too much absorbed in his own personal enjoyment for the hour, to let love or spite have control of him for any length of time. But what did Esau ever do in the line of self-denying or self-forgetful good to others? When did he ever seem to give others the first place in his affections or in his plans? In what did he ever show real unselfishness of character or conduct?
From Esau down to “Jim” Fisk, this kind of an open-handed, generous-seeming, thoroughly selfish man has been a prominent and popular character in the community; and this outside attractiveness has blinded the eyes of many to the sharp distinction between selfishness and stinginess, so that those who are known to give freely, and to have no taint of penuriousness, are generally looked upon as free from the objectionable trait of selfishness. Yet many a free giver is wretchedly selfish; and many an unselfish man is sadly prone to penuriousness.
One man gives freely because of his reckless enjoyment in prodigality; another, because of the reputation his giving brings to him; another, because of the sense of power that comes with the bestowal of gifts on others—the creating thereby of a circle of grateful recipients, if not of conscious pensioners; another, because, with his tender heart and sensitive conscience, it is easier for him to give than to refrain from giving. In none of these instances is it unselfishness which promptsp. 148 the giving; self is in each case at the bottom of the apparent generosity. Another test than that of giving would prove either of these open-handed ones to be a selfish person. Would he deny himself enough to stop and look into this case to see if it is a worthy charity? At a recent public meeting in Philadelphia in behalf of the Society for Organizing Charity, the Rev. Dr. Goodwin made an address on “The Uncharitableness of Almsgiving.” There is a great deal of almsgiving instead of aid-giving, because of the selfishness of the givers. Would the giver make just as liberal donations in this and that direction, if his name were never to be known as a giver? Would he want his left hand to be entirely ignorant of what his right hand was doing in the giving line? Would he be ready to take a gift from another without rendering an equivalent, and thereby lose the proud sense of independence and superiority his giving now secures to him, if he were sure that the one to whom he has been giving, and whose interests he professes to have at heart, would more enjoy that way of doing? Is his giving in any event at a cost of self-denial to himself, either in funds or in feeling? It was said of a good man in a certain church that it was harder for that man to give a dollar than any other church-member; but that he gave more dollars in proportion to his means than any other man in the church. He might have been called a stingy man who gave unselfishly. And there are other men of his sort. They deserve more credit than those who, when they are asked to give, cannot refuse without an excuse of positive self-denial. Free-giving is a very poor test and measure of unselfishness.
If you were always receiving and never giving gifts, you would admit that you were stingy; you would even call yourself mean. So it would be in your estimate of your children. You would be shocked if they found no enjoyment in giving to others. But both for yourself and for your children you should bear in mind that one may give freely and heartily and yet be grossly selfish. Generosity is literally “nobleness of birth or of soul.” He who is really generous will show his generosity twelve months in the year; will show it in uniform courtesy of manner; in tender considerativeness of the feelings of others; in self-forgetting and self-denying deference to the wants or interests or tastes of his companions, in the ordinary intercourses of life—whether in the parlor, on the play-ground, or in the place of public gathering or conveyance. His unselfishness will not hinge upon his holiday giving, nor upon his giving at any time of the year.
Giving may or may not be commendable and beautiful. Unselfishness and generosity are always admirable. There are selfish givers,—givers who are not stingy, but selfish. There are those who, by their giving, deceive others as to their character; but there are many more who deceive themselves into the thought that they are generous because they give freely and gladly. There are others, again, who have little to give, and, who, indeed, have little thought of giving, who are so generous and so unselfish that they hardly have a separate existence, either in getting or in giving. They absolutely live for others, and that is better far than giving to others.
“The nature of such souls is to be blind To self, and to self-seeking; let them blend Their life as harmony and atmosphere With other lives; let them but have a friend Whose merit they may set off or endear, And they are gladder than in any guess Or dream of their own separate happiness.”
Though we bestow all our goods to feed the poor—or to please the rich—and have not unselfish, generous love, it profiteth us nothing.—S. S. Times.