AdventAI

NATURE AND DESTINY OF MAN.—NO. 1.

By Roswell Fenner Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 56, No. 22., November 25, 1880

[NOTE.—The following article is the first of a series written by Eld. Cottrell for the Universalist Herald, published in Notasulga, Ala. Through the courtesy of the editor, Mr. J. C. Burrus, the entire series appeared in that paper.—Ed.]

Dear Sir: I am informed by my brother in faith, Eld. C. O. Taylor, that you favor free and friendly investigation of Bible truth, and that you are willing to publish in your paper the views held by others on the subject of man's nature and destiny, if written in a kind and courteous spirit; so that all your readers may have the opportunity of hearing all sides of the question, and may decide for themselves where the truth is. Accordingly I write to introduce the views we hold, which may be called the third, or intermediate, position,—the medium between two extremes. Here, we believe, the Scripture truth is found.

In the conflict between Universalism and what is called Orthodoxy, there are seeming advantages on both sides. Both hold that man is immortal, and therefore must have a conscious existence in weal or woe to eternity. If the immortality of the soul is not a doctrine of revelation; if man is mortal, and can become immortal only through Jesus Christ; if “the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord,”—if this is literally the truth, then God's love and mercy can be magnified in the “survival of the fittest,” his law honored, and both justice and mercy vindicated, though a large number of the human race should die, or perish, and thus be lost.

With your permission, then, I will proceed to present some of the Scripture evidences on this fundamental question of the nature of man. And in the investigation I shall hold to the testimony of the Scriptures in their most obvious and literal sense. Why not? Have we any more reason, or authority for giving the language of the Scriptures a secret or mystical interpretation, than we have to interpret the language of any writer or speaker in the same way? If you have the right to interpret Moses and the prophets, Christ and the apostles, mystically, have not I the same right to interpret you and all others in the same way? If one writer or speaker may be interpreted in this way, certainly all others may; and language would become useless, having no determinate meaning. If we do not give the language of the inspired writersp. 346 its plain, obvious, and literal meaning, making all figures harmonize with the literal, and thus finding a harmony in the whole, our search for truth will be in vain.

Do the Scriptures teach that any part of man is immortal, that is, “exempt from death; having life or being that shall never end”? The current theology of our times makes man a compound of mortality and immortality. His body, it is held, is material, and therefore mortal; but his soul, or spirit, is a separate spiritual entity, dwelling in the body, conscious, intelligent, and immortal. This view makes the soul, or spirit, the all-important part, really the man himself. If this view be true, if the most important part of man be an invisible, immaterial entity dwelling in the body, we should expect the Scriptures to abound in testimony concerning it. And especially in the account of the creation of man we should expect to have this immortal entity clearly described. Without this, the account of man's creation would be sadly deficient; indeed, the most important thing of all would be left out of the account. Let us, then, appeal to the inspired account of man's creation.

Gen. 1: 26: “And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness.” Here God announces his intention to make a creature called man; but nothing is said of the material, or substance, of which he is to be composed. Gen. 2: 7 gives us the desired information on this point: “And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became a living soul.” Here is the simple and complete record of man's creation. Of what was man made? Was he partly material and partly immaterial? partly made of the dust, and partly of something else? “The Lord God formed man,” not man's body merely, “of the dust of the ground.” Here is no intimation of a double entity, an immaterial, immortal entity to dwell in the body. In this inspired account of man's creation, this supposed entity is utterly ignored, and the deficiency is nowhere supplied in all the Bible. The testimony is not that the body was made of dust, and after that a living soul was put into it. Man, who was made of dust, became a living soul on receiving the breath of life from his Creator. The man was the soul, and the soul was the man, that is, a living creature; and when that “breath of the spirit of life” (see Gen. 7: 22, margin) returns to God who gave it, the dust returns to earth as it was before the creation of man. See Eccl. 12: 7.

But does not the term “living soul,” as applied to man, distinguish him from the brutes, which were also brought forth from the earth? Not at all. The same term is applied to all the beasts of the earth. Gen. 1: 30: “And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to every thing that creepeth upon the earth, wherein there is life [margin, Hebrew, “a living soul”], I have given every green herb for meat.” Hence it is evident that the term “living soul” does not distinguish man from the brutes; for it is applied to both man and beast alike.

But does not the breath of life distinguish man from the brutes? No; for all alike have the breath of life. In Gen. 6: 17, God says, “And, behold, I, even I, do bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh, wherein is the breath of life, from under heaven.” In chap. 7: 15 it is said of the beasts, “And they went in unto Noah into the ark, two and two of all flesh, wherein is the breath of life.” Again, verses 20–22: “Fifteen cubits upward did the waters prevail; and the mountains were covered. And all flesh died that moved upon the earth, both of fowl, and of cattle, and of beast, and of every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, and every man; all in whose nostrils is the breath of life [Hebrew, the breath of the spirit of life], of all that was in the dry land, died.” These testimonies, and many others that might be cited, prove conclusively that it is not the fact that man is a living soul, nor that he has the breath of life, that distinguishes him from the lower order of animals. In these things man has no pre-eminence above a beast. But he was formed in the image of God, and dominion was given him over the beasts,—over all the earth. In these he is distinguished. His erect form, his intellectual powers, and the power of speech, give him a decided pre-eminence. The image, or likeness, pertains to the person. Christ, the second Adam, was not only the brightness of his Father's glory, but “the express image of his person.” Heb. 1: 3.

But it is claimed that because man was made in the image of God, therefore he is immortal. The argument stands thus: 1. Man was made in the image of God; 2. But God is immortal; 3. Therefore man is immortal. If this logic is sound and true, by it we can prove that man is almighty. Thus: 1. Man was made in the image of God; 2. But God is almighty; 3. Therefore man is almighty. An argument that would make man equal to God, in any of his attributes, is most evidently a fallacy. All power and all life is from God, and is dependent on his will. According to the testimony of Inspiration, he is “the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings and Lord of lords; who only hath immortality.” 1 Tim. 6: 15, 16.

We have examined the record of man's creation, and in it we find no evidence of a separate entity residing in his body, answering to the description of the “immortal soul,” or “deathless spirit,” of popular theology. Man was made of dust, and was made a living creature or soul by the power of God. This life was communicated by God, and is perpetuated through the breath of his nostrils; and all this is true of the inferior animals. Where shall we find the evidence of an immortal entity in man, if not in the inspired account of his creation? But this simple story of man's creation is corroborated by all succeeding revelation, as can be abundantly proved.

R. F. Cottrell.