Baptism in Symbols

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 5, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 14.

Read the full edition

Baptism in Symbols.

THERE are several passages of Scripture in which baptism is presented to us under certain resemblances, figures, or symbols. These divinely approved similitudes to represent baptism ought, carefully studied, to suggest useful collateral hints as to what baptism properly is, perhaps also as to who may properly receive baptism. If we know what a thing in question is like, we are at least so much nearer knowing what that thing in question is. Let us, accordingly, in the present paper, give ourselves a thoughtful examination of the symbols under which the Spirit of God has chosen to set forth baptism in his holy word.
One conspicuous Scriptural passage in which baptism is expressly, and therefore unmistakably, referred to, in the way of symbol or emblem, occurs in the tenth chapter of the first letter to the Corinthians. The following are the words: “Moreover, brethren, I would not that ye should be ignorant how that all our fathers were under the cloud and all passed through the sea; and were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea.”
I feel that a word needs to be premised of justification for the seriousness with which I shall presently treat the strangely perverse interpretation that the advocates of sprinkling for baptism, the less enlightened, that is to say, among them, seek to put upon this passage of Scripture. I cite in illustration a comment from Arthur’s “Tongue of Fire,” p. 30, curious for perfectly reckless assertion on the part of the author: “The only other case in which the mode of contact between the baptizing element and baptized persons is indicated is this: ‘And were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea.’ They were not dipped in the cloud, but the cloud descended upon them; they were not plunged into the sea, but the sea sprinkled them as they passed.” It is such a popular comment as this, unaffected by scholarship either possessed or borrowed by the commentator, that still continues to blind the eyes of thousands upon thousands of conscientious, non-Baptist Christians all over the world. Meantime, of course, really competent scholars of all denominations hold substantially the same doctrine concerning the passage now under consideration, as that which is here about to be set forth.
In the present passage a special emphasis rests on the word all. Paul is enforcing the idea that no one should be over-confident of final salvation on the ground of any forms or rites observed, or of any privilege enjoyed. All the fathers, he says, shared the high experiences enumerated; but not all were brought safely through their wanderings in the wilderness. For the practical purpose of rendering the historic example more impressive, Paul uses language in a way to make the case of the ancient Israelites seem as closely parallel as possible with that of Christians. In accordance with this plan of discourse, having mentioned the abiding of the fathers under the cloud, and their passing through the sea, he immediately seizes upon the thought of treating these experiences of theirs as constituting a kind of baptism. We examine now, let us keep in mind, this turn of Paul’s rhetoric for the sake of finding out what is incidentally taught in it of a certain subordinate matter. Our question is simply this: What hint as to the true nature and form of baptism does Paul’s implied comparison contain? The right way of reaching an answer will of course be by attentively considering what the comparison implied is.
I say the “comparison,” but perhaps I should say “the comparisons,” rather; for I am inclined to think that we have here, not one single compound comparison, in which “cloud” and “sea” are both together concerned, but two distinct comparisons instead,—first, of baptism to the relation of the Israelites with the cloud, and secondly, of baptism to the relation of the Israelites with the sea. That is, I believe the quick and teeming mind of Paul saw, in two different great experiences of the Israelites, two different available symbols for baptism, and used them both. I draw this conclusion partly from a study of the language of the passage before us, and partly from a study of the Old-Testament history. Paul does not say, “All our fathers were under the cloud while they passed through the sea,” or, “All our fathers passed through the sea under the cloud;” he says, “All our fathers were under the cloud and they all passed through the sea.” The repetition of the word “all” would hardly have occurred if one and the same experience on the part of the Israelites had been intended. They all, Paul would say, had this experience, and they all had that experience. The experiences were two: first, that of being under the cloud; secondly, that of passing through the sea. With this understanding of the first verse, agrees the phraseology of the second. For it is not said, “And were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and sea,” as if sea and cloud united to give them one baptism; but it is said, “And were all baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea,” the preposition in being repeated, as if to indicate two separate experiences on their part, each experience capable of being likened to baptism. We scrutinize the history of the passage of the Red Sea, and we find our view confirmed. It is distinctly stated in Exodus, that on the eve of the Israelites’ commencing their dread adventure of fording the Red Sea, the cloud “went from before their face, and stood behind them.” There is not the smallest hint to show that at this time the cloud was over the Israelites. The cloud had been before them. It was removed and took its station behind them. Whether in making this change it passed over the host, or fetched a circuit to one side of them, nothing is said that encourages us to form a conjecture. But at all events, the cloud, during the whole of the night in which the whole of the passage was effected, stood in the rear of the Israelites, bright in its aspect toward them, while dark in its aspect toward the Egyptians. There is therefore no natural way in which the cloud could meanwhile have supplied a means of baptism to the Israelites. Elsewhere in the Old-Testament history, it is stated that the cloud stood over the Israelites and was upon them. The time when, is not given. When, however, fixed in that local relation to the host, the cloud might in at least one conceivable way have “baptized” them. Standing behind them, it could not have done so in any way that seems natural. We conclude, therefore, with much confidence, that Paul introduces in the verses here being considered, not one symbol of baptism made up of two parts, but two different symbols instead. There was a symbolic baptism in the cloud, and there was besides a symbolic baptism in the sea. Now the point is, How were these baptisms in a symbol effected? Or, rather, exactly what were the occurrences or experiences that Paul here uses rhetorically as analogues of baptism? Take first the symbol in which the cloud is concerned.
Two mutually contradictory answers have been proposed. One is that the cloud sprinkled water upon the Israelites. To this answer, there are various objections. First, there is no evidence that the cloud was an aqueous cloud. It was dark by day, and it was light at night, having in the latter case the appearance of fire. It is purely and wholly gratuitous to assume that the cloud was vapor of water. More, it is against probability. Secondly, let it have been granted that the cloud was compact of water, still it is sheer assumption,—assumption again contrary to likelihood,—that the cloud shed down showers upon the Israelites. Are we to suppose that the cloud kept the Israelites constantly sprinkled? That it did so upon occasions? When? Why? Thirdly, the proposition is against this view, “In the cloud,” is the phrase. Insert “sprinkled” for “baptized,” and see how the clause looks. “Were sprinkled in the cloud.” Does this seem natural? Even if the cloud had indeed shed water upon the Israelites from its position over them, still surely that fact would not have been stated in the phrase, “were sprinkled in the cloud.” Fourthly, the word baptized is against this view. Baptized means covered with, or in, or under, as for example, with, or in, or under, water. That, however, we must not now say. That is here a begging of the question. We do not yet know what baptized means. We are seeking to know. And we must not use the lexicon for the purpose. We must keep to the symbol here employed to represent baptism.
The three objections above named put sprinkling out of the question. It is not certain that the cloud sprinkled water. It is not likely that the cloud sprinkled water. It is not certain that the cloud contained water. It is not likely that the cloud contained water. But if, in spite of no evidence for it, and in spite of likelihood against it, the cloud did yet both contain water and sprinkle water, still that fact would not naturally be alluded to in the expression, “were baptized in the cloud.” Nay, if sprinkling is baptism, and if the sprinkling supposed took place, then that sprinkling would not have been used as Paul here uses what did take place, namely, in the way of a symbol for baptism. A symbol is founded in, not identity, but resemblance. If a sprinkling with water is baptism, then a sprinkling with water is not a symbol of baptism. The whole purpose of the passage is nullified if you try to make out a sprinkling with water to resemble a sprinkling with water. The Lord’s supper in the context is symbolized by the manna for the bread, and by the miraculous water for wine. Here is resemblance, but not identity. Just so baptism is symbolized by something that is like baptism, but that is not baptism. By what then? Why, nothing is more simple. By the hovering of the cloud over the Israelites, as the water for a moment covers the subject in baptism. But some one says, “Stay, the cloud, you hold, was not vapor of water. No water, and yet baptism?” Certainly, baptism in symbol, not baptism in fact. “The cloud simply over the Israelites, they not enveloped in it. No immersion, and yet baptism?” Certainly, the symbol may not be perfect. Symbols seldom are. Still, we do not know but the cloud, as the Rabbis think it did, may have wrapped the Israelites quite round in its folds. This, however, it is not at all necessary to suppose. The cloud covered the Israelites, according to the expression of the psalm, “He spread a cloud for a covering.” This representation is quite sufficient for the purpose of the symbol. The feature of burial in baptism, one of the most important features of the rite as itself a symbol, is strikingly set forth. This amply suffices the purpose.
The symbol for baptism contained in the relation of the Israelites to the cloud, appears thus to exclude sprinkling as the rite intended to be alluded to. Immersion, on the contrary, for baptism, entirely satisfies the conditions of the case. So much for baptism, then, as it is presented in the symbol of the cloud. A very brief notice will enable us to dismiss the symbol contained in the passing of the Red Sea.
In order to make this symbol seem consistent with a mistaken view of what baptism is, it has been assumed by some (Arthur in his “Tongue of Fire” affords an example) that the divided sea scattered spray on the Israelites as they passed through between the walls of water on either side. This assumption is purely gratuitous. There is not the slightest evidence in its favor. There is every probability against it. Is it to be supposed that God would so imperfectly work his attempted miracle? Is it like the Wonderful in Working that he should indeed separate the body of the sea to make dry land in its bed, and yet wet the Israelites as they passed with spray from the waves? Of course, if it were related that such was the case, there would be nothing for us but to believe it and to believe it for wise and good. But it not being related, will anybody pretend that it is probable?
On the other hand, how like an immersion it was!—like, observe, without being the same,—for the Israelites to venture themselves down to the bottom of the sea and enclose themselves within those dread walls of water heaped up on either side! Conceive the event as a spectacle. The observer beholds the great procession of the Israelites descending between those beetling watery walls into a lane stretched out long and narrow across the whole breadth of the sea, at the point where the passage was made. The host are lost, as it were, in “the midst of the sea.” After an interval, they issue from their entombment in a resurrection upon the farther shore. How vividly like the majestic enactment on a colossal scale of a baptism, with its submersion, its instant of disappearance from view, its subsequent emersion, on the part of the subject! How worthily impressive an image of the beautiful ordinance by which the obedient disciple signifies his death to sin and his resurrection to righteousness, is thus seen to be that great critical act of the Israelites, in which they give themselves irrevocably up to the leadership of Moses, passing from the bondage of Egypt through a tomb in the sea to emerge beyond this entombment into their new life of national freedom and power! Is it less than irreverence, unconscious irreverence, it may be, toward the word of God, to treat this passage as the upholders of sprinkling for baptism are forced to do? Think of Paul’s bringing forward an inexpressibly august and awful event of Jewish history, the crossing of the Red Sea, to make, pray, what use of it? Why, forsooth, to separate from it an incident, namely, the sprinkling of the Israelites with spray, an incident that if it ever occurred at all, which is in the highest degree improbable, was certainly deemed by the sacred historical writers too trivial to deserve even a mention at their hands—to separate, I say, an incident so insignificant from so tremendously significant an event, making it the type of a Christian ordinance which the whole of the context shows Paul meant to signify to the utmost possible impressiveness! Is this not an anti-climax, nay, a plunge into bathos, impossible to the rhetoric of Paul?
It ought, perhaps, to be noted that the “were baptized” of our common English version should, according to the best authorities, read “baptized themselves,” or “caused themselves to be baptized,”—the sense thus being that the baptism was an act performed by the Israelites of their own accord. The bearing of this on the question, What persons may justly receive baptism? is too obvious to need pointing out.
Before the final dismissal of the present passage from consideration, it may be well to remark that the finding in it of two symbols for baptism instead of one, is not in the least material to the conclusion drawn as to its teaching on the form of the rite. If you please still to regard the symbolic baptism as a single one, jointly made up from the cloud and the sea, the result is the same. The baptism in that case consists in the enclosing of the Israelites in the sea while they are canopied over with the cloud. In any case, the nature of the symbol employed requires that the thing symbolized, namely, baptism, should be immersion.—Wm. C. Wilkinson, in The Watchman.