AdventAI

Nihilism and Liberty in Russia.

By George Washburn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 14., April 5, 1881

It is well that we should understand exactly what this Nihilism is. It has not many adherents in Russia, although it has been in some measure fostered and protected by the general discontent which reigns in the empire. The emancipated serfs are discontented because their wild and unreasonable hopes have not been at once realized. They have had their “Freedman’s Bureau,” and it has done much more for them than was promised in the edict; but it has not made them rich, nor enabled them to live without work, and this is a disappointment. The people generally are dissatisfied with the administration. It is centralized, cumbersome, and corrupt. They do not know exactly what they want; but it must be change.

The nobles, and especially the old landholders, are more dissatisfied than any other class. They have lost the power and influence which they had before the emancipation of the serfs, and they have gained nothing in place of it. They are often men of education, and their heads are full of all manner of fantastic ideas as to everything connected with government, religion, and society. They dream of a new civilization, which is to be developed by the Slavic races, and imposed upon the world by Russia. They seize on a new idea with wild enthusiasm, worship it for a time, and then drop it in disgust. They wish a constitution which shall put the political power into their hands, and they were agitating this question when the emperor destroyed their influence by emancipating the serfs. The students in the universities, who come, to a large extent, from this class, are in a chronic state of dissatisfaction. Most of them have no religious belief to balance and steady their minds, and their reading is generally adapted to fill their heads with extreme Socialistic views. The Russian students in the European universities are all Socialists. There is discontent in the army, the navy, and the civil administration. It is very freely expressed by all classes—to foreigners, at least, as I can testify. It is not disloyalty to the Czar, as a general rule; but a vague discontent with the existing order of things. Under the protection of this feeling, the Nihilists have grown up and developed their plans in comparative security.

Russian Socialism, as represented by the Nihilists, differs toto cœlo from German Socialism. Its fundamental principle is individualism. There is no God, no supreme government, and there should be no human government of any kind. Existing society must be abolished, at any cost, and each individual be left to himself. German Socialism is equally without God; but it would establish a despotic government, which should annihilate individualism, own all property, direct all labor, and control all actions. The Nihilists do not represent the liberal party in Russia, which favors constitutional government, although this party has been tolerant of Nihilism, in the hope that it might frighten the Czar into granting the empire a constitution. It has been a mistaken policy from the outset, and there can be no reform in Russia unless society sets itself resolutely against this mad fanaticism. It is fanaticism. These Nihilists are terribly in earnest. It is not gain or notoriety they seek. They count their lives for nothing. It is a revolt in the depth of the soul against human government, as they see it, and divine government, as they conceive it. They have killed the emperor. They will probably try to kill his successor. So far as they can be caught, they will be killed themselves. But what next? Nothing good can come from them in any way.

It is well known that the new Czar is impressed with the importance of reforming the administration, and, as Americans, we must sympathize with this feeling. It is to be hoped, however, that he will not be driven by public opinion to attempt impossibilities. The great weakness of the Russian government is that it is centralized. The Czar is responsible for everything. He has not even a counsel of ministers in any proper sense of the word. Each minister is responsible directly to the Czar for his own department. He is the head of the army, the navy, and the civil administration. From the most distant provinces everything comes up to him. As he is neither omniscient nor omnipresent, this makes good government impossible. The first need of Russia is genuine decentralization. This can only be accomplished by the establishment of local self-government. This exists in small communes now in some parts of Russia; but there should be provincial self-government somewhat on the plan of our State governments. This is the more necessary as Russia is made up of many nations, that have but few common interests or sympathies. An imperial parliament might come in time, as a growth out of these local assemblies; but at present, parliamentary government in Russia is an impossibility,—almost as much so as it would be in China.

There is civilization and enlightenment in Russia; but the empire as a whole is not civilized. Even in Russia proper the mass of the population is sunk in ignorance and superstition. This is the great obstacle in the way of reform and civil liberty. Nihilism can do nothing to remove this state of things. The emperor himself can do but little more than initiate measures for the gradual improvement of the people. Alexander did more in this direction than any of his ancestors, and many think that he did too much. Under the most favorable circumstances, it will be many years before his reforms can produce much fruit. It is a terrible inheritance which he has left to his son,—a vast empire, held together by military power, overburdened with debt, full of corruption among the officials and discontent among the people; with half executed plans of reform, that have unsettled the minds of the lower classes and filled the heads of thinking people with Utopian dreams; with an administration which has become unmanageable and with a throne surrounded by assassins. . . . It is even feared that the present emperor, who is known to be very hostile to Germany, will find an opportunity to involve all Europe in war. This does not seem to me probable. I think that, after an effort to exterminate the Nihilists, he will make an honest effort to improve his government and ameliorate the condition of his subjects. In this task he will have the sympathy of the best men of all nations. Let us not refuse this sympathy, if the progress is slow and uncertain. We have learned, in our own experiments with four millions of negroes and a quarter of a million of Indians, that men are not civilized and enlightened in a day, by the decrees of government, or even by the work of philanthropists. The right of suffrage or citizenship does not at once change the characteristics of a race. We cannot expect that the eighty millions of Russia, many of them as savage as our Indians and the majority as ignorant as our slaves, can be much changed in a single generation. Probably the most important reform decreed by Alexander II. was that which abolished the hereditary character of the priesthood and provided for their education; but it will be many years before this can bear fruit in the development of the religious character of the people. The peasants of Russia and many of the upper classes are very religious, very Christian, as they conceive of Christianity; but it is in general a Christianity of dogma and form, rather than a living Christianity. They must get above this before they can make much progress in preparation for civil liberty.—George Washburn, D. D., President of Robert College, Constantinople, in Independent.