Editors Review and Herald:
In your issue of July 29, 1880, is a review of an article of mine in the World’s Crisis of July 14, 1880, which “review” did not come to my notice until the present month, and as you ask me several questions therein, I take the liberty of sending you the following answer, trusting you will allow it to come before your readers in the REVIEW AND HERALD.
In your “review” you say: “Mr. B. further says, ‘The seventh-day theory rests upon a frame-work of unwarranted assumptions. It assumes there was a duty to observe the Sabbath ages before the law relating to it was announced.’ We reply, The seventh-day theory assumes nothing of the kind. Has Mr. B. ever read our arguments? Has he ever read Gen. 2: 3? Will he tell us what the word ‘sanctified’ means in that passage? He knows, as every one else knows, that the word means to set apart to a sacred, or religious use, and that can be done only by giving a law concerning its observance. Therefore, as soon as the great facts upon which the Sabbatic institution is founded, were accomplished, a law was given to our first parents for its observance, and through them to all their posterity, in all places and all time.”
1. I have read your arguments, both as contained in pamphlets and tracts, and in Andrews’ “History of the Sabbath,” which I have read with great care in times past, not to speak of the many books from the Orthodox (so-called) which argue for the Sunday-Sabbath, but agree with you as to the meaning of Gen. 2: 3.
2. I agree with you as to the meaning of the word “sanctified” in that passage, and especially with your remark that such sanctification “can be done only by giving a law concerning its observance.”
3. Being agreed thus far, we come to the point on which we differ; and I desire to say, in the kindest manner possible, that your very next sentence (quoted above) contains one of the “unwarranted assumptions” to which I referred. You do not quote any law, nor refer to any place where it is stated, but simply assert, “A law was given to our first parents for its observance.” And this assumption is but an inference (at most) drawn from what appears to me to be another “unwarranted assumption;” namely, that Gen. 2: 3 refers to a sanctification of the Sabbath in Eden. You present no argument for such application; you take it for granted that it can only be so applied, and seemingly ignore the fact that any different application can be suggested. Do you not therefore assume that application?
Now, with your consent, I will present the reasons why it appears to me to be an unwarranted assumption. We are agreed, I suppose, as to the Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch.p. 20 It could not, then, have been written by Moses until after the exodus from Egypt. A portion of the laws were written shortly after the memorable transaction on Mt. Sinai (Ex. 24: 3-8), and I suppose the remainder of the Levitical laws, and the historic record of the sojourning of the Israelites in the wilderness, were written at intervals between the giving of the ten commandments on Sinai and the death of Moses; and I presume you will agree with me in saying that probably during the same period Moses wrote the book of Genesis. I do not present any argument for these statements, because I assume that as to the Mosaic authorship of the five books attributed to Moses, you agree with the vast majority of Christians.
But this being granted, what then? It follows that the directions concerning the Sabbath at the falling of the manna, and the formal annunciation of the Sabbath law from Sinai, were matters of past occurrence when the book of Genesis, and the account of creation in particular, were written by Moses. When the Israelites read for the first time the Mosaic account of creation, they were familiar with the Sabbath law given from Sinai, and, admitting for a moment that the sanctification of the Sabbath grew out of the Sinaitic law, the statement of Moses at the close of his account of creation that “God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it,” would be consistently and intelligently understood as referring to its sanctification by the Sinaitic law, because that act of sanctification was already a thing of the past when the statement in Gen. 2: 3 was written. And if it could be so applied consistently (and as I maintain it ought to be applied), then it is an unwarranted assumption to apply it to a supposed sanctification, by a supposed law, immediately at the close of the creation week. In brief, the statement in Gen. 2: 3 appears to me to be in the nature of a parenthesis, penned at some time after the Sabbath law was given from Sinai, and which does not tell us that God sanctified the seventh day in Eden, but states the reason why he sanctified it (not referring at all to the when, although it had already been set apart on Sinai), “because that in it he had rested.”
An illustration occurs to me as follows: On the 4th of July, 1776, representative men of the American colonies signed a “Declaration of Independence.” Then followed a war; the success of the colonies; the formation of Congress, and, in process of time, the setting apart of the 4th of July as a national holiday in commemoration of the signing of the Declaration. Now, suppose an historian, writing the story of the signing of that memorable paper, adds to his narrative, “Therefore the 4th of July was set apart as a national holiday, because on that day the Declaration of Independence was signed by our fathers.” Would anybody be justified in assuming that the historian meant to teach that the 4th of July was set apart as a holiday from that very time, July 4, 1776, especially when we can point to the law of Congress whereby it was subsequently set apart? Would anybody be justified in saying that the Congressional law was only a re-enactment of a previous law, and that the historian’s statement proves its prior origin and existence? It seems to me these questions must be answered in the negative. On the other hand, would not all agree that the historian, writing subsequently to the Congressional enactment, simply introduced his statement very pertinently to show the relation between the original occurrence and the subsequent law which sprang from it? I think they would; and thus it seems to me the statement of Moses in Gen. 2: 3 is to be understood and applied.
For this exposition I claim no originality. John Milton says (“Christian Doctrine,” b. 1, chap. 10), “The most probable supposition is that Moses, who seems to have written the book of Genesis much later than the promulgation of the law, inserted this sentence from the fourth commandment, into what appeared a suitable place for it; where an opportunity was afforded for reminding the Israelites, by a natural and easy transition, of the reason assigned by God, many ages after the event itself, for his command with regard to the observance of the Sabbath by the covenanted people.”
Dr. Gill, in his Commentary, on Gen. 2: 3, says, “These words may be read in a parenthesis, as containing an account of a fact that was done, not at the beginning of the world, and on the first seventh day of it, but of what had been done in the times of Moses, who wrote this after the giving of the law of the Sabbath. . . . He takes this opportunity here to insert it, and very pertinently, seeing the reason why God then, in the time of Moses, blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it, was because he had rested on that day from all his works.” (Ex. 20: 11.) And the same reason is given here, taken plainly out of that law which he had delivered unto them.”
By referring to Gen. 32: 32, you will find a similar instance where a custom which sprang up in after time is referred to in connection with the history of the event from which it had its origin.
I offer the foregoing statement as my justification for saying you unwarrantably assume a Sabbath duty ages before the law relating to it was announced. If in any reply you will show the unsoundness of its reasoning, and the incorrectness of my conclusion, I will endeavor to keep my mind as free as possible from bias, and accept that which is better supported, and more reasonably maintained.
Respectfully, your brother,
C. E. BARNES.
Salem, Mass., Nov. 20, 1880.
REPLY.
It is necessary to the profitable examination of any question, to have the issue between the disputants clearly defined. It happily seems to be the case in the present instance that the point in dispute is very tangibly presented. Mr. B. acknowledges that the word “sanctified” means “set apart to a sacred or religious use,” and that this could be done in no other way than by giving a commandment, or law, in reference to the object so sanctified. If, therefore, the Sabbath was sanctified at the conclusion of the first seventh day of time, then the Sabbath was at that point instituted, and from that point there has been a law in existence for its observance. This much we understand him to admit.
The one question, then, between us is, Was the Sabbath sanctified at the close of creation week, or was it not sanctified until the time of Moses, twenty-five hundred years later? We say, It was sanctified at the close of creation week. Mr. B.’s claim is that, by the figure of prolepsis, the record concerning the sanctification is thrown in out of its chronological order; that is, that although connected with a narrative of events which took place during the first seven days of time, this particular act of sanctification that is recorded, nevertheless did not occur until twenty-five hundred years later, in the days of Moses.
We think there are very apparent reasons for objecting to Mr. B.’s positions.
In the first place, it will be conceded that the entire first chapter of Genesis and the first two verses of the second chapter are a record of events occurring in chronological order, and immediately connected with each other. Between the second and third verses of Genesis 2, there is no indication whatever of any change in the narrative; no indication that the language is used in any different sense in the third verse from that in which it is used in the second verse; and no one would have conceived that this was anything but a record of the next and immediately transpiring event, if this theory respecting the institution of the Sabbath in the days of Moses did not demand it.
Secondly, the Sabbath is plainly set forth as a memorial of creation, and all the reason that exists for commemorating that event existed from the event itself. Can any man tell us, therefore, why twenty-five hundred years were allowed to elapse before the Sabbath was set apart as a memorial of creation, when the same reason for its observance existed from the beginning?
Thirdly, in the record of the fourth commandment itself, in which the reason for the institution is again given, it is said, “For in six days the Lord made heaven, and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.” When did he bless and hallow it? Beyond all controversy, so far as this record goes, at the time when he had finished the work of creation, and rested that day. The position occupied by Mr. B., therefore, does as great violence to the fourth commandment as it does to the record in Genesis.
This point was ably discussed in the Bibliotheca Sacra, in 1856, from which we transcribe a few paragraphs. Speaking of the arguments of a writer who took the same position as Mr. B., it says:—
“The first thing that strikes us in the survey of this entire passage, is the at least apparent violence done to the narrative in the book of Genesis. He may well lay great stress upon this narrative as creating, if not, as he asserts, ‘the whole controversy upon the subject,’ at least an important part of it. But certainly it seems to demand the existence and exigencies of some preconceived theory, to account for the gloss which he has put upon it. Who that had no such theory to defend, would imagine the sacred writer here to describe a transaction which, according to the supposition, had not occurred for two thousand five hundred years afterward? It would not be asserted by him, or any of those who occupy the same side in this controversy, that the interpretation thus given to this passage is the one which would naturally present itself to any one of ordinary intelligence upon the first perusal of it. We will not allege, indeed, that the obvious, or seemingly obvious, import of the passage is always the true one. But if there be no dispute respecting the terms employed (and there is none here), and if the subject matter be of easy comprehension (as in the present instance), then the onus probandi rests upon those who would reject the obvious for the more recondite construction.
“Here is an historical statement; and the only question is, Does Moses, after describing the work of six days, suddenly, and without any intimation, alter his style when he comes to describe the procedure of the seventh day? and, using a highly rhetorical figure, does he set down in connection with the record of this procedure an event which did not take place until twenty-five centuries had elapsed? We have said, Without intimation, but it should be added also, In the face of the fact that the whole, being a plain narrative, would inevitably be differently understood by all who might read it apart from the light of such an hypothesis as the one now under examination. This, assuredly, is not what we might have expected to discover in any book written beneath the guidance of the Divine Spirit, and intended for the instruction of the unsophisticated in all ages. We utterly deny, then, that ‘it was natural in the historian, when he had related the history of the creation and of God’s ceasing from it upon the seventh day, to add’ the words in question, unless they are expressive of an event which actually occurred at the creation. And to state in the way of argument that Moses does ‘not assert that God then blessed and sanctified the seventh day,’ but simply that he did so for a certain reason, is to be guilty of a species of sophistry very unworthy the gravity which becomes the discussion of such a theme. How could he have conveyed more lucidly the idea that this was done then, than by recording it, as he does other things, in the past tense, and also in immediate connection with that very cessation from work on the part of God which it was designed to commemorate? True, he assigns the reason for this consecration; but he does this in such a manner as to imply that as the reason existed from the beginning, so also did the consecration. And it is but natural to ask, What ground could exist for the appointment of such a memorial in after ages, which did not operate ‘from the foundation of the world?’
“On the whole, it does appear to us that until all the principles of sound criticism are abandoned, and we are at liberty, by a dextrous andp. 21 convenient application of the figure prolepsis to convert history into prophecy at our pleasure, we cannot adopt the interpretation which this writer has so strenuously advocated. We can understand what is meant by the total rejection of this inspired record, or by the reduction of it to the rank of a mere myth; but we are at an utter loss to understand the position which accepts its divine authority, and acknowledges the opening portion of Genesis to be the narrative of real transactions, and yet, to serve the purpose of a theory, would mutilate and distort its obvious meaning, and that in gross violation of all the laws which guide the historian and chronologist’s pen.”
Mr. B.’s illustration, drawn from the Declaration of American Independence, is not logical, as it is not a supposable case; for who could conceive of a competent historian undertaking to give a chronological narrative of events, and yet setting them forth in so bungling a manner as to mislead the reader, as he supposes? Let him find an historian who has thus written, and then establish his reputation as a competent writer, and he will have furnished a pertinent illustration, but one, even in that case, coming far short of being entitled to any weight in this instance, inasmuch as human writings cannot be taken to govern the divine.
His reference to Gen. 32: 32 is fatal to his own position, unless he can show that the custom there mentioned did not date from the event to which it owes its origin.
Against the authors which he quotes on his side of the question, as Milton and Dr. Gill, we can array such authorities as Clarke, Scott, Henry, the Religious Encyclopedia, and a multitude of others who as strenuously argue the position we hold, and who are entitled to as much regard as men of mental ability and logical acumen. We rest our conclusions, however, not so much upon the authority of great names, as upon the evident meaning and intent of the narrative, and the intelligence and candor of the reader.
U. SMITH.