We happen to be of the number who see a silver lining to this cloud, and believe that out of all this “bobbery” shall grow a blessing. The blessing doth already appear in the resurrection of the evidences of Christianity and the logical discourses which are heard from the pulpits where the voice of this man is heard in the land. The position is taken by many ministers that the day for argumentative discourses is past. We have frequently heard able men in preachers’ meetings and at other places, make the statement, and one of the ablest ministers in this country has voiced such utterance in a lecture on preaching.
It won’t do. The gospel must be set to logic and not to rhetoric, in order to convert the world or to keep it converted. Preaching that doesn’t prove anything does not fortify against error. Many of the pin-feather infidels of to-day have been captured from under the shadow of rhetorical pulpits, and more will go before we learn that the human mind will not take everything for granted or because the preacher says so. Men of intelligence will investigate for themselves, and they will do it along lines furnished them by the sentiment-makers of their day. If we ignore the existence of God, taking for granted the divinity of Christ and the inspiration of the Scriptures, and fail to give thoughts and proofs way-marking the line of safe and healthy investigation, contenting ourselves with glowing utterances, bright thoughts, and rounded periods, we may please and satisfy the conservative, but we do not fortify the young men against enemies who are sure to beset them. Then when Ingersollism comes, they are led off to investigate under infidel tuitions, with results which it does not take a Solomon to forecast.
True, our arguments will not be remembered in detail, but their impressions will be retained, so that the man goes even to an infidel lecture in impervious armor, or better, like a vaccinated man to a small-pox pest-house; it can’t hurt him much because of the something which has preceded it and forestalled its influence. True, as point after point is assailed, he will not be able to recall the whole Christian argument, but he will remember that “our preacher” upset all that two or three years ago. And he will remember that his proofs of the positions assailed have not been equaled by the lecturer, and will leave the place with a deeper reverence for Christianity, and the conviction that infidelity is a weak swindle.
Ingersoll will indeed be a blessing, though a left-handed one, if he stops our idealizing, moralizing, rhetorizing, and other fool(izing), and makes us face the logic of the gospel. The reason of our hearers cries out for the bread of sound reasoning, and cannot be satisfied with stones. They have a right to the proof, and must have it. Infidelity comes, not only of the bad lives of Christians, but of rhetorical pulpits. Now if its attacks drive us back to discovering the foundations of truth, and keeping them bare, then even Ingersoll will not have lived in vain.
Do we not forget that argument has been the basis of the greatest religious successes? Jesus, the Christ, was mighty in argument, and in his public discourses put to silence the most astute logicians of his day. Paul and the other apostles were strong in proof, their discourses were chains of mighty reason. Luther drew the gospel arrow in a logical bow, so did Knox, so did Wesley. The men who are mighty in producing conviction follow the same tactics. Rev. C. G. Finney, the greatest of modern evangelists, was greatest in reasoning power. Mr. Moody, in a homely way, is a logical reasoner. Walton, of our own Conference, one of the most successful of soul-winners throughout a long ministry, can preach no other way. It may be that Ingersoll will help us back to the old way of meeting the inquiries of men’s reason by a reasonable presentation of the gospel, and so rightly dividing the word of truth as to be workmen that need not to be ashamed, showing ourselves approved unto God by the convictions that follow its presentation.—Conference Worker.