AdventAI

LIFE INSURANCE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 12., March 22, 1881

A short article on this subject in the REVIEW of March 1, has called forth some strictures from the Michigan Tribune, published in this city. In said article a brief extract was given from Testimony No. 12, admonishing S. D. Adventists that they should not engage in life insurance, as it is a kind of commerce with the world of which God does not approve.

With this the Tribune takes issue, and regrets that we hold this view of the subject. Nevertheless, in its effort to defend the insurance business, candor and an imposing array of stubborn facts in the past history of insurance companies, compel it to make the following admissions, which we give in its own language:—

“While many life insurance companies may have been no credit to the projectors and no benefit to the insured, it does not follow that all are dishonestly inclined, and that after a few years of success they would make a failure of the enterprise and defraud the people,” etc.

Again it says:—

“To be sure, a large number of the old line insurance companies have failed, some of them honestly, some otherwise; but we cannot see wherein particular exception should be taken to mutual associations, or those which have a secret organization.”

Here is a frank confession that many life insurance companies have been no credit to the projectors, and no benefit to the insured. But if they have been no benefit to the insured, they have been an injury; for they have taken money from them for which they have rendered no equivalent. And this, in the aggregate, amounts to an immense injury inflicted on the community.

Again it is admitted, that “a large number of the old line insurance companies have failed, some of them honestly, some otherwise.” In either case, the insured lost all they had paid. The fact that there have been exceptions, and that not all have been either unfortunate or dishonest, does not materially alter the case. Could the facts as they now appear have been known from the beginning, what course would a sound business policy have led a person to pursue? It seems to us he would have reasoned something like this: “A large number of these companies are destined to fail. I do not know which ones. Some will fail dishonestly. This class will be as likely to work up a large patronage as the others, and probably more so. I am therefore far more likely to lose than to gain. Hence my best course is to keep out of them altogether.”

In the light of the history of insurance companies for the past twelve years, it must be admitted that such reasoning would have been sound, and such a course prudent. But this is virtually just the counsel given in the Testimony above referred to. That was published fourteen years ago, before the grand collapse of insurance companies commenced. S. D. Adventists generally heeded it; and what has been the result? Simply this, that thousands upon thousands of dollars, on the Tribune’s own showing, have been saved by this people for their legitimate work, which would otherwise have been sunk through the misfortune or fraud of insurance companies.

And further: Insurance agents now urge as one argument to induce people to take out policies, the fact that two out of every three will suffer their policies to lapse, and from the funds thus accruing the company will make a dividend to the third man, who keeps his payments up. It has been ascertained from careful observation that this proportion may be depended on. When, therefore, they receive payment after payment of money from their patrons, they do it with the assured certainty that two-thirds of them will never receive a penny in return. Men may call this “the golden rule,” “helping one another,” practicing the “greatest virtue, charity,” and so on. But all such gush collapses before the fact that the most there is golden about it is the golden harvest reapedp. 189 by the companies, and the only rule is that by which a man will knowingly suffer his neighbors to deplete their coffers for the benefit of his own.

A circular issued by the mutual companies against the old line companies has fallen into our hands, in which we find displayed in bold lines and dressed in mourning, these words:—

“In memory of one hundred and forty-three dead ‘old line’ life insurance companies, that died leaving two hundred and thirty nine thousand nine hundred and eleven sorrowing policy-holders, mourning for forty-six millions one hundred and ninety-eight thousand eight hundred and seventy-eight dollars, and causing a loss to widows and orphans of hundreds of millions of life insurance.” Then follows a list of “names of the deceased, being only a partial list of insurance companies that have been hurried to untimely graves by the ‘get all you can, and keep all you get’ system.” On the other hand, the old line companies make a similar charge against the “mutuals,” substantiating their statements with facts and figures.

We do not overlook the fact that some are benefited; but if the foregoing statements are true, the few are benefited at the expense of the many, something as the winning ticket in the lottery benefits the holder. But we are speaking now of the business as a whole.

Finally, the American Machinist, an authority not to be accused of wild and fanatical views on commercial questions, in its issue of Jan. 1, 1881, says:—

“Speaking of accidents and insurance against them, it needs only a knowledge of the immense sums which the American public annually pay for the privilege of getting disgusted and throwing away their policies in a few years, to lead us to the conclusion that the prevailing system of life insurance in this country is a delusion and a snare.”