AdventAI

SPIRIT VS. FLESH AND BONES.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 5., February 1, 1881

The words of Christ to his disciples after his resurrection, “Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself; handle me and see, for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have,” Luke 24: 39, have been considered one of the strongest texts in support of the popular idea of the conscious, intelligent existence of human spirits, or spirits of men, in a disembodied condition. While the term spirit is used in many different senses, we fail to see any proof in this passage that it can be taken to represent what is so generally claimed in the theological world as above set forth. That which gives a wrong turn in the interpretation of so many passages of Scripture on this subject is the arbitrary definition of soul and spirit which has been constructed.

This definition of the word spirit, namely, a disembodied, conscious entity, is not drawn from the Scriptures, but from heathen mythology, and adapted to its position in the Christian world by being arrayed in the garb prepared for it by the papal apostasy. Setting aside that definition as unsupported by Scripture, we ask how Luke 24: 39 can be made to suggest such an idea, “A spirit hath not flesh and bones;” but what kind of a spirit, or whose spirit? The text does not say. Is there any intimation here that the spirit was the spirit of a deceased human being? Is there anything to connect it, in any manner, with the human family? The most that can be proved by it is that there are spiritual existences which have not flesh and bones as have the members of the human family in their present condition; but there is nothing in this text to show to what order of beings such a spirit belongs.

We believe in the existence of spiritual beings. Such, to speak only of those who are more intimately connected with the human family, are the angels of God. And a spirit of this kind, so far as the record of the text is concerned, may be all that is referred to. At best the essential point is lacking to show that this passage supports the popular view; for there is no intimation that the spirit to which Christ referred had ever dwelt in the flesh in human form.