ALCOHOLIC WINE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 19, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 16.

Read the full edition

ALCOHOLIC WINE.

[From Les Signes des Temps.]
DOES the Bible justify the use of alcoholic wine as a beverage? By alcoholic wine is meant wine that has been fermented. Such wine possesses the power to intoxicate, and this power comes from the alcohol contained in the wine. The alcohol is produced by the process of fermentation. The question which we wish to consider is this: Does the Bible justify the use, as a beverage, of wine that possesses the power to intoxicate? Observe that we speak here of wine as a beverage, and not of wine as a medicine to be employed in some emergencies. Though we regard all alcoholic liquors as things from which we should wholly abstain as a matter of conscience, yet we believe that there are some emergencies, when nature is sinking in absolute exhaustion, that a small portion of brandy or other alcoholic liquor may be the means of saving one's life. But this admission in no way justifies the use of alcoholic liquor as a beverage. The question is therefore very simple. The Bible certainly says some things in praise of wine and in favor of its use. We shall examine some of the most direct and important of these testimonies, and we have no wish to detract from their just force. What the Bible pronounces good, and worthy of our acceptance, we will always treat with just respect. But no one will deny that the Bible also speaks in the strongest terms against the use of wine. Does the Bible, then, contradict itself? By no means. Every word of God is pure. All Scripture is given by inspiration of God. There is no contradiction between those scriptures that speak in favor of wine and those that speak against it. The wine which the Bible condemns is fermented, or alcoholic, wine, and it is condemned because of its power to intoxicate. The wine which the Bible approves is wine that possesses no injurious properties. It will not cause men to blaspheme God, nor to use obscene language, nor to behave as fools, nor to abuse their families, nor to take their own lives. This will become evident when we examine those scriptures which speak in favor of wine.
The process of preparing sweet wine and keeping it from fermentation is very simple, and was well understood by the ancients. The juice of the grape must be heated to the boiling point and sealed from the air. Such wine may be kept without difficulty, and may be freely used without any injury.
Now let us examine some of those passages which condemn the use of wine. We shall find that the wine condemned in the Bible is always that wine which has power to intoxicate, and that it is condemned for this reason, and no other. The first instance in which wine is mentioned in the Bible is Gen. 9:20, 21: “And Noah began to be an husbandman, and he planted a vineyard; and he drank of the wine, and was drunken; and he was uncovered within his tent.” This is the only blot upon the character of Noah. He once became absolutely intoxicated. What caused this intoxication? The use of wine. What kind of wine was this? It was alcoholic wine. Was God pleased with what Noah did? By no means. His fault is placed on record, for the admonition of his posterity. If Noah, one of the most eminent of God's servants, sinned against God by coming under the power of wine, then we also may sin in the same manner. Let those who think they stand, take heed lest they fall.
We call attention next to the case of Lot. The use of wine left a blot upon the character of Noah which should have been a warning to Lot. He ought to have said, If Noah fell into sin by means of wine, I must stand on my guard and abstain from it. But Lot thought as many now think, that he was in no danger from the use of wine. He believed that he could stand where Noah fell. He refused to be warned by the sin of Noah, and so his daughters were able to lead him twice into intoxication, and each time into shameful and outrageous sin. (Gen. 19:30–38.) Lot drank alcoholic wine. The Bible tells us what he did, and what resulted from his action. It expresses no opinion with regard to his conduct, but virtually bids us judge of it for ourselves.
In the tenth chapter of Leviticus we have the sad history of Nadab and Abihu. Instead of offering with their incense sacred fire, which God had kindled, they took strange fire, that is, common fire, and offered that before the Lord with their incense. For this sin they were struck dead by fire which came out from before the Lord. What caused these two young men to commit the sin for which they were thus slain by the angel of God? They had been drinking wine, and were partially intoxicated. They had no thought of committing sin against God; but they would have known that they were doing this had not their minds been darkened by the intoxicating power of wine. The force of this is seen from the fact that God spoke at once to Aaron and his sons, forbidding them to use wine when they appeared before God. “And the Lord spake unto Aaron, saying, Do not drink wine nor strong drink, thou, nor thy sons with thee, when ye go into the tabernacle of the congregation, lest ye die: it shall be a statute forever throughout your generations; and that ye may put difference between holy and unholy, and between unclean and clean.” Lev. 10:8–10. The priests must never taste wine when they were to appear in the presence of God. Why not? Because it would render them incapable of putting difference between holy and unholy. It would benumb their sensibilities and render them unfit to appear in the presence of God. Will the unfermented juice of the grape have this effect upon men? By no means. It is alcohol that produces this effect. What shall we say, then, of Christians who drink freely of alcoholic wine at their tables, and then present themselves before God in family or public worship? Will not alcohol produce the same effect now that it produced in the case of Noah and Lot and Nadab and Abihu? The two sons of Aaron were not intoxicated as we use the word. They were able to serve as priests. They had drank just enough to exhilarate them a little, as we should say, but they had actually destroyed their power to discern the difference between things holy and things profane. What, then, must be the condition of those ministers of God's word who dare to drink freely of alcoholic wine, and then to come before the people with a message from God?
Solomon speaks thus of wine: “Wine is a mocker, strong drink is raging; and whosoever is deceived thereby is not wise.” Prov. 20:1. How does wine mock men? It promises to make them happy, but it brings them to misery and distress. It promises them health, but it gives them redness of eyes and trembling of limbs. How does it happen that men are deceived by this mocker? It has the power to gratify their appetite, and they are pleased with its taste. They are glad to believe that it will keep its promises, and they have not wisdom enough to learn by the experience of others. They see others brought to ruin by this mocker, and they never for a moment think that their fate may be the same. What kind of wine is this? It is alcoholic wine, for Solomon classes it with strong drink. Here is another testimony from the wise man: “Who hath woe? Who hath sorrow? Who hath contentions? Who hath babbling? Who hath wounds without cause? Who hath redness of eyes? They that tarry long at the wine; they that go to seek mixed wine. Look not thou upon the wine when it is red; when it giveth his color in the cup; when it moveth itself aright. At the last it biteth like a serpent, and stingeth like an adder. Thine eyes shall behold strange women, and thine heart shall utter perverse things.” Prov. 23:29–33. This passage shows us why wine is called a mocker. It promises men great happiness, and it brings them to misery and ruin. What kind of wine does Solomon speak of? It is wine that is capable of biting like a serpent and stinging like an adder. It causes some men to quarrel like dogs, and others to babble like fools. It brings redness to the eyes and sorrow to the heart. What is this serpent in the cup, which thus mocks men? It is alcohol. What does Solomon prescribe as a remedy against this mocker,—the moderate use of intoxicating wine? By no means. He prescribes total abstinence in the strongest terms. He did not believe that we could gather grapes from thorns or figs from thistles, and he forbids us even to look at the intoxicating cup.
But in reply to this it will be said that our Lord Jesus Christ made wine on the occasion of a wedding. (See John 2:1–11.) Did he make such wine as that which Solomon calls a mocker, and which he says bites like a serpent and stings like an adder? The Saviour made an abundant supply; and as he made it expressly for that occasion, and as the governor of the feast pronounced it excellent, there can be no doubt but that it was freely drank on this occasion. Let us suppose that this was alcoholic wine, and let us see what would be the natural result, in such case, of this miracle. Part of the guests would lie helpless upon the floor, unable to return home till they recovered from their intoxication. Others would lose their senses and babble as fools; others would utter words of blasphemy, and wish to fight with their best friends. Others would sing drunken songs, and use immodest words. When the guests returned to their homes that night, they staggered in the streets, and needed to lock arms with one another to keep from falling to the ground. They disturbed all the people by the way with their drunken songs and obscene language, and when they arrived at their own homes, they caused terror and distress to their families. The next day they were unable to work, and needed to spend the time in sleep, that they might recover from their drunken debauch. Was this the nature and this the effect of our Lord's first miracle? It is impossible that this should be the case. If Satan were endowed with the power of working miracles, we should believe that he might gladly furnish alcoholic wine, for nothing could better advance the interests of his cause.
Our Lord made pure, sweet wine, such as we find described in various places in the Bible. Fermentation is caused by action of the oxygen of the atmosphere, and requires a considerable space of time for its accomplishment. If the wine which our Lord made was fermented at the very moment when he made it, it required a second miracle for that purpose, and this miracle was wrought to render the wine intoxicating in its nature. Though our Lord is greater than Solomon, he is not greater than the spirit of inspiration by which Solomon spoke, and we may be certain he did not work a miracle to make that kind of wine which Solomon calls a mocker, and says will bite like a serpent and sting like an adder. Isaiah speaks thus of sweet wine: “Thus saith the Lord, As the new wine is found in the cluster, and one saith, Destroy it not; for a blessing is in it; so will I do for my servants' sakes, that I may not destroy them all.” Isaiah 65:8. The new wine in the cluster has no intoxicating power, and is a blessing from God to man. This is the kind of wine Pharaoh drank. His butler speaks thus: “Pharaoh's cup was in my hand; and I took the grapes, and pressed them into Pharaoh's cup, and I gave the cup into Pharaoh's hand.” Gen. 40:11.
When Melchisedec met Abraham to pronounce upon him the blessing of God, he brought forth bread and wine. Melchisedec was the priest of the most high God. He was superior to Aaron,—a priest of the same order with our Lord Jesus Christ. We have seen that Aaron was forbidden to drink alcoholic wine when engaged in the duties of the priesthood, and we may therefore be certain that Melchisedec, who held a more sacred priesthood than that of Aaron, did not use alcoholic wine when sent by God to pronounce his benediction upon Abraham. (Gen. 14:18–20.) But it is supposed that Paul reversed all the warnings contained in the Bible against alcoholic wine when he said to Timothy: “Drink no longer water, but use a little wine for thy stomach's sake and thine often infirmities.” 1 Tim. 5:23.
What the Bible says with regard to self-denial does not attract the serious attention of one person in a thousand, but this one verse which seems to favor the gratification of the appetite is eagerly quoted by all the world. People in good health quote this verse to justify themselves in the free use of wine as an ordinary beverage. But such cannot be the meaning of this passage. At the time when these words were written, Timothy abstained wholly from the use of wine. He had been with St. Paul during many years, and had been careful to imitate the example of the great apostle. This shows conclusively that Paul as well as Timothy abstained totally from the use of wine. Timothy had now become enfeebled by excessive labor, and Paul counseled him to no longer drink water exclusively, but to take a little wine on account of his feebleness. People in ordinary health cannot justify their use of wine by this passage. If we should admit that it referred to alcoholic wine, it justifies the use of only a little, and that in case of sickness. But we do not believe that St. Paul advised Timothy to drink that kind of wine that Solomon calls a mocker. God forbade the priests to drink any wine when they ministered in holy things, lest they should be unable to discern the difference between the holy and the profane. The office of Timothy was no less sacred and responsible than that of the priests. Besides this, the example of Timothy, should he use the wine that could intoxicate, would be seized by the multitudes who have no government over their appetite. We believe that Paul counseled Timothy to use a little wine that was sweet and pure, and that he did not counsel him to use that which would bite like a serpent and sting like an adder.
J. N. A.