Church and State

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 31, 1881

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 57, No. 22.

Read the full edition

Church and State.

The following paper by “An American Citizen,” addressed to Felix R. Brunot, President of the American Reform Association, was written in the interests of the Seventh-day Baptists. Although not new, it has lately come to our table; and as the subject of which it treats is a live one, and the arguments are as true now as when first penned, we believe our readers will be interested in its perusal:—
The intrinsic importance of the ostensible object of the organization over which you preside, viz., To effect a reformation in the moral, political, and religious condition of the nation, claims the respectful attention and charitable consideration of the people, and may excuse, nay, even require, a thoughtful examination as to the utility, feasibility, and tendency of such enterprise. If to honor God aright it is essential to make the Constitution of the United States a Christian document, and enforce religious obligation generally, by constitutional recognition and statutory enactments, that fact should be universally known, and the legal and social policy of all the States made to conform to it.
The Association is understood to be committed to that view of the matter, and to be laboring to bring the people of the United States, and of the States, respectively, to acquiesce in such change in the national and State constitutions as will give those views the force of law. This has hitherto been believed by a majority of the nation to be unnecessary and unsafe.
It is true that respectable minorities, holding substantially the views promulgated by the Association, have existed in all periods of our national history. Descendants of the Colonists in New England, and other sections of the United States, where church and State were united previous to the formation of our Union, and those who were in sympathy with the ecclesiastico-politico-judicial policy in vogue in those times, have been impressed that our system of government is essentially incomplete and defective, while our Constitution is silent respecting the essential doctrines of religion, and while the national and State legislatures are not empowered by that instrument to define and enforce religious duty.
The existence of your organization at the present period, with such an array of talent and influence as it presents, is proof that the important issue presented must be met and decided by the country, at no very distant day.
A large and respectable portion of the citizens of the United States have entertained the views above stated, and formidable efforts have been made to change or override our constitutional policy from time to time, in State legislatures and in Congress. A notable instance of legislation for sectarian purposes is seen in the Sunday law of Pennsylvania, passed April 22, 1794, and now in force, of which more will be said further on. In 1830, when our existing government had been in operation but little more than half a century, the desire for congressional interference in religious matters found expression in a petition, signed by citizens of nearly all the States, to the national legislature, praying that body to enact a law prohibiting the transportation of mails, and the opening of post-offices, and the delivery of mail matter on the first day of the week. The committee on post-offices and post roads, to whom memorials were referred, reported adversely to the prayer of the petitioners. The report was adopted, and printed by order of the Senate of the United States, and the committee discharged from the further consideration of the subject. They say: “We look in vain to that instrument (the Constitution) for authority to say whether first-day, or seventh-day, or whether any day has been made holy by the Almighty. . . . The Constitution regards the conscience of the Jew as sacred as that of the Christian, and gives no more authority to adopt a measure affecting the conscience of a solitary individual than that of a whole community. That representative who would violate this principle would lose his delegated character, and forfeit the confidence of his constituents. . . . If Congress should declare the first day of the week holy, it would not convince the Jew nor the Sabbatarian. It would dissatisfy both, and consequently convert neither. . . . If a solemn act of legislation shall in one point define the law of God, or point out to the citizen one religious duty, it may, with equal propriety, define every part of revelation and enforce every religious obligation, even to the forms and ceremonies of worship, the endowments of the church, and the support of the clergy. . . . The framers of the Constitution recognized the eternal principle, that man’s relation to his God is above human legislation, and his rights of conscience inalienable. Reasoning was not necessary to establish this truth; we are conscious of it in our own bosoms. It is this consciousness which, in defiance of human laws, has sustained so many martyrs in tortures and flames. They felt that their duty to God was superior to human enactments, and that man could exercise no authority over their consciences. It is an inborn principle which nothing can eradicate. . . . It is also a fact that counter memorials, equally respectable, oppose the interference of Congress on the ground that it would be legislating on a religious subject, and therefore unconstitutional.”
This decision of Congress, made forty-six years since, seems to have been regarded as final and authoritative by the people of the United States generally; but as the one-hundredth birthday of the nation drew near, a very large and respectable number of religionists who cherish views similar to those of their friends, who, in 1830, endeavored to establish Sunday-keeping by law, under the Constitution as it is, knowing they could not support their claims by Scripture, and conscious that that instrument presents an insuperable barrier to the accomplishment of their purposes, now demand such an amendment of the organic law as shall make their tenets and usages the rule of faith and practice of the whole nation! Not satisfied while at liberty to follow their own convictions in religious matters without annoyance, and to give the widest publicity to their views of Christian doctrine and ethics, they claim to say through an amended Constitution what all others shall subscribe to and indorse (or have others subscribe and indorse for them), whether agreeable to their views or not, and that the States respectively shall be empowered and required to enact laws to enforce compliance. The Constitution amended to meet their wishes, it would be asserted that it is the duty of all the States to acquiesce and conform legislative action to the fundamental law of the nation.
A single State (Pennsylvania) has a law, enacted more than eighty years ago, which approximates the views of the Association, and which they seem to desire to have in force in all the States, with the addition of such recognition of God as Creator, and Christ as Ruler of nations, and Sunday as the Sabbath of the nation, as would meet their views as theologians. While it is a felicity to believe their doctrinal views are generally sound and worthy to be embraced by all, it is nevertheless contrary to the convictions and sense of propriety of very many (and, it is believed, of a vast majority of the nation) to make the Constitution the umpire between religious sects, instead of protecting the religious rights of all, and favoring the abettors of one theory to the detriment of all others; and yet this seems to be the very thing aimed at by the Association. They would doubtless spurn an amendment, which, while it acknowledged God as Creator and Jesus Christ as Ruler of nations, also recognized the true Sabbath, instituted by Jehovah, as the memorial of his creative work, to be observed by all as such, and as a preventive of idolatry, by bringing the Creator often to mind, and looking forward to the rest of Heaven, of which the Sabbath is a type. Nor would the observers of the true Sabbath have such amendment made to the Constitution, if they could have it for asking. If the institution is a Scriptural and divinely established one, that is sufficient; if not, constitutions and statutes could not profitably establish a Sabbath when Jehovah saw no need of one.
In the settlement of the question so earnestly pressed by the Reform Association, it will be seen whether the people have any religious rights which they deem worth defending, and which the Association and the country are bound to respect.
The Sunday law of Pennsylvania, above alluded to, was passed, and is retained on the statute book of the State, by men who hold the identical views entertained by the Association on that subject; and but for their presence and influence in the Legislature, the law would have been amended long ago, and the State relieved of the odium of enacting and sustaining a statute directly hostile to the organic law of the United States and of Pennsylvania, unjust and oppressive to a respectable portion of her citizens, impotent for good to all classes, and unsuited to the civilization of the age and the genius of Christianity. That law is apparently the nucleus of the Association’s operations, and may be taken as a specimen of what may be expected as likely to follow the success of its enterprise.
And what are the characteristics, and what the fruits, of this Sunday law of 1794?
1. It is clearly unconstitutional.—The Constitution of the United States says: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” That of Pennsylvania is similar, and quite as strong; and yet in full view of these prohibitions, members of the Legislature, on their solemn oath to support those Constitutions, enact and refuse to amend a law compelling more than fifty thousand citizens—who believe it their duty by the command of Jehovah, to devote six days of each week to labor and business as much as to keep the seventh day holy, and to respect the original arrangement of the week religiously—to abstain from labor and business on one of the days on which the fourth commandment enjoins labor, viz., the first day of the week, as clearly as on any other day.
2. The law is sectarian.—It discriminates in favor of those denominations who observe as a holiday the day of pagan sun worship, disregarding the day of divine institution entirely, and against those who keep the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, and feel it incumbent on them to labor on the first day as one of the six working days of the week.
3. It is unjust.—It prohibits fifty-five thousand persons from laboring and doing business one-sixth part of their time, and indirectly takes from them that share of their earnings; and it subjects them to many annoyances on the Sabbath of Jehovah, which they feel bound to observe, while those who holidayize on the first day are protected by law from interruption.
4. It fosters unbelief in sacred things.—If an intelligent person is reproved for disregard of the first day as the Sabbath, he may demand Scripture authority for sanctifying that day as holy time, and as no man can refer to a single scripture to sustain such claim for it, and the Sunday law and the general practice can only be urged in support of such claim, it is fair to infer that if a false claim is set up for Sunday, the church may set up false claims for other doctrines and usages; and if one important institution is ignored and a substitute adopted without divine authority, it may be so of all the rest; therefore, they may claim that the church does not believe the Scriptures, and why should they hold others to believe them? They claim sanctity for a human institution, without authority from the Bible, and a heathen one at that.
5. Its tendency is to sink the tone of piety.—To be conscious that one is disregarding the day of God, on which he rested, and making a substitute of a day which Jehovah never sanctified as a day of rest, or commanded to be kept as holy time, will deprive the worshiper of much of the pious inspiration attendant on true Sabbath-keeping, both directly and indirectly.
6. The law is cruel.—It punishes persons for no other offense than following their honest convictions, and laboring on their own premises as the command of God enjoins, by imposing on them exorbitant fines; and if such fines with costs are not paid immediately, the prisoner must be sent to jail “to be kept at hard labor six days for each (alleged) offense, on bread and water only.” The prisoner must be kept continuously at “hard labor” no more than six days, no less. He must labor during the whole term of incarceration, which of necessity will include Sabbath day and Sunday both unless he is committed early Monday morning, and this is not likely to be done. If not arrested within three days after such alleged offense, he cannot be taken at all for it, and if committed as late as Monday afternoon he must work both Sabbath day and Sunday. So it is next to impossible to keep and enforce this Sunday law without breaking it. What a law! what an illustration of Christian civilization, especially as courts, bailiffs, constables, and jailors have no discretion allowed them by the law! The prisoner must not be allowed any rest, especially in working hours, but must “be kept at hard labor.” He must not be allowed to work moderately; he must have no food except bread and water, furnished by the jailor or others; to deviate from this direction would be a culpable offense against the law.
7. This law must be enforced (mainly) on those who keep the Sabbath of the Bible.—It is believed no one who professed to keep the first day has ever been so punished, though more than fifty-five thousand first-day men in the State work every Sunday without any notice being taken of it by arresting them.
8. Legislators are sensible of the impropriety of this law; yet fealty to political party or religious sect seals their lips from exposing the odiousness of the law, or from giving their votes to amend it, though under oath to support the Constitution of the United States and of this State. It seems preferable to them to blink at the unconstitutionality of the law, rather than to become unpopular with the political party or religious sect with which they may be identified, by exploding a hoary error. While at each time the subject has been considered by the legislature, there have been honorable exceptions, the majority of both Houses have treated the subject with indecent levity, and ridicule unbecoming their position.
(To be continued.)