SISTER C. P. WHITFORD, Berkshire, Vt., writes to a friend who is investigating our views as follows:—
Evidently you are interested, in some degree at least, in the reading I have sent you; and this fact is a source of encouragement to labor on, sowing the seed by the side of all waters, not knowing which will prosper, this or that. I shall continue to send you the Signs for a time. I have not time or strength to answer at great length, objections which may arise in your mind to the positions we take as a people. Our publications will do that more fully and ably than I can; but there is one subject referred to in your letter that I will speak of briefly. You cannot think that we are correct in thinking that the darkening of the sun and moon in 1780 and the falling of the stars in 1833, are a fulfillment of the signs which the Saviour said would precede his coming; and mention as a reason that the sun has been darkened a number of times since, and also that falling stars, or meteoric showers, have occurred on the morning of the 13th of November ever since 1833. These are simply objections, not good Bible reasons, as I think I can plainly show you.
These signs in the sun, moon, and stars are predicted by our Lord, and recorded by the evangelists. (Matt. 24; Mark 13; Luke 21.) In these records, not only the same signs are given, but the same time is pointed out for their fulfillment, namely, a period commencing just this side of the long and bloody persecution of the papal power. In Matt. 24:21, 22, the 1260 years of papal supremacy are brought to view; and “immediately after the tribulation of those days” (verse 29) the sun was to be darkened, etc. Mark is still more definite, and says, “In those days, after that tribulation.”
The days, commencing in A. D. 538, ended in 1798; but about twenty years before they ended, the spirit of persecution had been restrained by the Reformation, and the tribulation of the church had ceased. And right in this period, exactly at the time specified in the prophecy, the fulfillment of these signs commenced in the darkening of the sun and moon. The fact that the same phenomenon may have occurred manyp. 341 times since, is no good reason why the prophecy was not fulfilled at this time. Indeed, had there been no darkening of the sun and moon, and falling of the stars at this time, the prophecy would have failed; but these events took place at the right time, and are therefore an exact fulfillment, and we must accept them as such. One significant fact will be noticed in connection with all the foregoing signs. They were each instinctively associated in the minds of the people at the time of their occurrence, with the great day of which they were the forerunners, and on each occasion the cry was raised, “The Judgment has come;” “The world’s at an end.”
You think they are not yet fulfilled. Please notice this fact: They were to occur under the sixth seal. See Rev. 6:12, 13. Your view cannot be correct, because there follows another seal,—the seventh and last.
Again, if your view is correct, the papal hierarchy have not yet lost their power. As they were to have only 1260 years of rule, of course they did not, according to this view, receive the power in 538, as all historians and Protestant commentators agree. But the pope did lose his power in 1798. He was taken prisoner by Berthier, a French general, and died the next year in exile. According to Mark, the sun must be darkened before this time—1798—and not until after the tribulation ended, which was about 1778. We must therefore look for the fulfillment of the Saviour’s prediction between the years 1778 and 1798. Just at the right time, between these two dates, in 1780, it did occur; and if there were a thousand dark days before or since, it would not prove that this was not the event which fulfilled the prophecy. I trust you will give the subject thought and due consideration. May God bless and keep you in patient waiting unto his coming and kingdom.